PatrickBateman
Norm Smith Medallist
IMO he should be playing the Matt De Boer role as a pure tagger.
I agree, but....
De Boer is a genuine, tough, hard at it, uncompromising defensive tagger. Physical, annoying, not very agreeable, etc. This is why he's good at it.
Guthrie is the opposite of everything I've just said with regards to De Boer. He's basically a softy in how he approaches his footy, this is his general demeanoru too. This is clear. You know, he's such a lovely guy... There's your answer, Guthrie can't.