List Mgmt. Trade Targets / Rumours Part 2

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't understand why you've moved Dougal on? I watch a few of your games and thought he showed a heap of potential. Would have loved Geelong to have picked him up.

Can someone explain to me why he's left? Did the club initiate it or did he?
Depends who you ask. Suppose it doesn’t matter because this was a **** deal.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Because Hinkley is the dumbest f***er in AFL football

You've downgraded your first pick in the draft and secured #18?

If any team drafted a KPD as promising as Howard with #18 they'd be happy with his progress?

I am just totally baffled by this.
 
We just facilitated Freo getting two 1st round draft picks for a 29 yo winger.
While we gave up a promising 23yo key position player in an area where we have no depth for the last first round pick and dropping off our own 1st round pick

Not to mention what we accepted for polec last year given he is pretty much a younger version of said Freo winger

Go Ports

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
 
I don't understand why you've moved Dougal on? I watch a few of your games and thought he showed a heap of potential. Would have loved Geelong to have picked him up.

Can someone explain to me why he's left? Did the club initiate it or did he?
You'll have to ask Jason Cripps and Chris Davies, because none of us have any idea what the fk they're doing...
 
Dougal & Ryder trade is ok. I would've thought we could've extracted a little more out of the deal, but on the surface we scored over 200 extra points for next year from a small 2 spot drop. So realistically that's not too bad.


The big issue I have is Frampton. We've given him up for possibly 20-30 draft points. That's nothing. If GWS finish top 4 it's less than 50 points. That's a crap deal.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

This is a bad trade- 10 alone could get you 12 and 18- we’ve thrown in Dougal too! Ryder for future pick swaps is ok as we didn’t want him on our list.

The worst part about this trade- St Kilda we’re desperate to get 10. Without it they don’t get Hull. We had the strong hand in this negotiation. St Kilda’s ability to get 2 players hinged on us.

Although I’ll wait until 7:30 pm tomorrow to make a judgment on it all, we need to makeup ground now to come out even in the trade period overall. This trade in isolation has made us weaker.
 
Absolutely done with this Kern of a football club at the moment. Saving face for their failed trades of years past to give up on future potential. I rarely post and/or get mad about football but this is a joke
 
You've downgraded your first pick in the draft and secured #18?

If any team drafted a KPD as promising as Howard with #18 they'd be happy with his progress?

I am just totally baffled by this.

Talk to his manager.
 
I don't understand why you've moved Dougal on? I watch a few of your games and thought he showed a heap of potential. Would have loved Geelong to have picked him up.

Can someone explain to me why he's left? Did the club initiate it or did he?

We are an idiot.
 
We just facilitated Freo getting two 1st round draft picks for a 29 yo winger.
While we gave up a promising 23yo key position player in an area where we have no depth for the last first round pick and dropping off our own 1st round pick

Not to mention what we accepted for polec last year given he is pretty much a younger version of said Freo winger

Go Ports

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
And a year after we gave up a 25yo winger and 27yo HBF for a single first round pick.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top