This thread is like Gina Rinehart and Ajay Rochester (2014 version) arguing about who is hotter.
Both lists are far from it, but aren't as bad as Carlton or Richmond.
West Coast have been smashed by injuries and Crows have been smashed by expansion clubs and average trade deals.
Crows top 5 are better, but West Coasts next 10 are better than the Crows' betteso at present West Coast are the r side, but that will change going forward (until Dangerfield comes to Geelong) if the rest of the Crows players can catch up.
I disagree - how can you say West Coast are better than Adelaide
Adelaide were in front in the last qtr against Geelong - where as the Eagles were totally non competitive- ok the Eagles had a few out - but so have the Crows - Walker and Henderson come to mind
Go back to the last 2 home games the Eagles had last year - Geelong beat them by 12 goals and the Crows beat them by about 14 goals- the Crows are far better placed going forward than the Eagles
Eagles wont make the 8 - and along with Carlton and Richmond wont win a premiership in the next 5 years