Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Robertio]

Yep, never recovered from the premiership party in Cancun.

Whilst Pies nursing hangovers, poor old Bagger fans stuck on the Blueshakes.

Yeah stuck higher on the ladder than the Pies.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Yeah stuck higher on the ladder than the Pies.

Disastrous fade out from the Blues, from ensconced in 2nd, to falling into 8th, to being flushed down the toilet 0-60... those hard Blue hearts shattered, not sure they'll ever recover

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[doppleganger]

Yeah stuck higher on the ladder than the Pies.

A soft fixture and 4 gimme wins against historically bad teams will do that.

We arent talking who was higher on the ladder, we are talking who was better.

The Blueshakes wasted one of Crippa's finest seasons, poor Shakers going backwards now and have lost their best clubmen too!

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Disastrous fade out from the Blues, from ensconced in 2nd, to falling into 8th, to being flushed down the toilet 0-60... those hard Blue hearts shattered, not sure they'll ever recover

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

The poor buggers have had their hearts ripped out so many times it's no wonder they have built such thick walls of delusion around themselves. It's the only way they can go on.
They'd be rocking back and forth in the foetal position sucking their thumbs if they let their minds take in the true horror show that is Carlton in the 21st Century.

 

[Worm4]

Disastrous fade out from the Blues, from ensconced in 2nd, to falling into 8th, to being flushed down the toilet 0-60... those hard Blue hearts shattered, not sure they'll ever recover

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Disastrous fade out from the Pies, from premiers, to falling into 9th, and being flushed down the toilet by the bombers,...those pie hearts shattered when port defeated the dockers, not sure they'll ever recover

 

[Fadge]

Disastrous fade out from the Pies, from premiers, to falling into 9th, and being flushed down the toilet by the bombers,...those pie hearts shattered when port defeated the dockers, not sure they'll ever recover

A typically non factual statement from you, as always.

There was no 'disastrous fade out' from the Pies... we were playing our best footy at the end of the season after a slow start to 2024. So literally the polar opposite of a fade out.

The Pies games against the Bombers were hardly in the realm of 0 and 60, with a draw and a loss after the match being in the balance for a long way.

And finally, the Fremantle loss to Port Adelaide had zero impact on Collingwood and their finals chances. We'd already missed out by the time that game was played, so zero relevance to our 'hearts being shattered'.

So 0 from 3 for you in a standard performance from a Carlton poster.

I guess it's an improvement on 0 and 60...

 

[Worm4]

A typically non factual statement from you, as always.

There was no 'disastrous fade out' from the Pies... we were playing our best footy at the end of the season after a slow start to 2024. So literally the polar opposite of a fade out.

The Pies games against the Bombers were hardly in the realm of 0 and 60, with a draw and a loss after the match being in the balance for a long way.

And finally, the Fremantle loss to Port Adelaide had zero impact on Collingwood and their finals chances. We'd already missed out by the time that game was played, so zero relevance to our 'hearts being shattered'.

So 0 from 3 for you in a standard performance from a Carlton poster.

I guess it's an improvement on 0 and 60...

Jeez it's easy to go fishing in this joint. 1 big fish, and a heap of sardines

 

[Cyclops]

Jeez it's easy to go fishing in this joint. 1 big fish, and a heap of sardines

Funny that's also a way to describe Carltons list

 

[Robertio]

A soft fixture and 4 gimme wins against historically bad teams will do that.

We arent talking who was higher on the ladder, we are talking who was better.

The Blueshakes wasted one of Crippa's finest seasons, poor Shakers going backwards now and have lost their best clubmen too!

Just as i thought, you have nothing.

 

[doppleganger]

Just as i thought, you have nothing.

LoL coming from the Bagger who battles most with understanding the ladder.

Even Essendon would have made finals in 2024 if they were fixtured (gifted) 4 gimme wins over historically bad opponents like Carlton were.

 

[Pistol Night]

Jeez it's easy to go fishing in this joint. 1 big fish, and a heap of sardines

And yet all you caught is crabs again

 

[Worm4]

And yet all you caught is crabs again

 

[Robertio]

LoL coming from the Bagger who battles most with understanding the ladder.

Even Essendon would have made finals in 2024 if they were fixtured (gifted) 4 gimme wins over historically bad opponents like Carlton were.

Essendon couldn't beat Carlton though mate, now you're just talking rubbish.

 

[Fadge]

Essendon couldn't beat Carlton though mate, now you're just talking rubbish.

They wouldn't have needed to, in the same way as Carlton finished above Collingwood, despite losing two games to them, courtesy of the North/Richmond double ups.

 

[Robertio]

They wouldn't have needed to, in the same way as Carlton finished above Collingwood, despite losing two games to them, courtesy of the North/Richmond double ups.

Don't you love it?

 

[HeathySure]

I hope the blues supporters were all over Cattoggio in race 8 at Flemington today. Its about the best thing thats happened to them in 25 years