Review Good/Bad and the Umpiring.

[Mr_Moogle]

I just remembered Lame Cornes is going to have to review this game tomorrow morning.

 

[FR0GGY]

So agile below his knees!

No comment

 

[I Lost My Keays]

It was a great moment the lads getting behind Izak after the last goal

 

[Redleg Crow]

Good:

Recalling this from David King

 

[Dirty Bird]

I’m still in disbelief about the the sholl “play on” holding the ball call.

Was an interesting call.

The AFL changed the rule this year about 'feigning a pass, equals play on and not pinging them for 50' however, SPP was within the protected zone.

That was probably a 80/20 call (between 50 to us/free to them).

But as there's technically a grey area in the ruling, the AFL can give it the tick of approval (publicly, while most likely telling the umpire directly - "You ****ed up")

 

[GrommoT]

Someone's got a spring to their step - revitalift?

 

[CrowBloke]

Thilthorpe pointing directly at Lachie Jones after he choked was my favourite part.

I loved the Chayce Jones "I can't hear you" gesture to the hushed ferals.

 

[MsTopG]

 

[Rotayjay]

#sackhinkley will be trending tonight

Save Ken!

 

[Smoooothy]

Rd 16 2014

AFL Tables - Greater Western Sydney v Adelaide - Sat, 5-Jul-2014 2:10 PM - Match Stats

afltables.com

I'm actually surprised it's happened at all tbh

 

[craig crowing]

Glory Glory
What is best seeing our team of kids run all over a opposition .
Or seeing Port Adelaide getting smashed.
Apart from finals ,yes I remember them ,there is no greater time in life than winning a showdown and easily in the end.
Like many bit shocked Dawson got trophy and personally I thought for whole game effort ROB all round game deserved it .
Even Milera did something in last Qtr.
Yes I am still on the Jones support group and hope can kick on from tonights game.
There will never be a worse umpires call than that Sholl holding the ball. NEVER.

 

[MrBarry]

More silk than arse in my opinion.

Eddie was great but an arsey player, and I say that with the utmost respect.

Rankine is more polish.

Disagree, Eddie is one of the great small forwards over a long long period.

What Rankine has that Eddie didn't have is explosiveness and ability to play up the ground.

 

[chrisso crow]

I’m still in disbelief about the the sholl “play on” holding the ball call.

Apparently the 'protected area' has gone from being anyone within 10m not affecting the play being penalised, to being non-existent.

There were 2 incidents tonight. Can't recall who the other one was though.

 

[John Who]

I think the bad was negligible when the effort was clearly the GOOD tonight.
What’s great is that all the young lads have shown a step up from last year.

Ugly in first quarter - 2 umpire frees against our players, being caught holding the ball while being tackled from behind after a mark. The rule should have been 50m penalty for us, since the opposition player didn’t get away from the restricted zone after a mark. That ruined the spectacle of an otherwise entertaining 1st quarter.

 

[Iron]

Himmelberg watching this game.

 

[The Perfect Stranger]

Murray (PSSD pick) was great, Butts was a worry against Old Man Dixon

Our recent other KPD's

Butts - struggling
McAsey - pick 6, enough said
Frampton - ordinary and shown the door, better with the Pies (what's changed - a new coach?)

Doesn't say a lot for our recruiting, but tonight's not the night to complain

Murray will be the gun top tier tall defender. Not hard to go out and recruit a good kpp to compliment Murray. I still like Butts but he appears to be playing hurt.

 

[John Who]

Apparently the 'protected area' has gone from being anyone within 10m not affecting the play being penalised, to being non-existent.

There were 2 incidents tonight. Can't recall wo the other one was though.

I think the second one was Hinge? But I can’t be entirely sure.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

That can't be right based on time on ground figures.

Also, Izak Rankine played 100% of the game on the ground

Hahaha they said he might not have the work rate to be elite clowns

 

[Klug]

Good: Rankine 3rd goal snap out of the pack.







Bad: 2 x ridiculous play on decisions







Ugly: Dance step Dwayne

 

[Anzacpaul]

Disagree, Eddie is one of the great small forwards over a long long period.

What Rankine has that Eddie didn't have is explosiveness and ability to play up the ground.

I'm not knocking Eddie for a second, I'm just saying Eddie had that knack of pulling them out the wazoo and doing the little frenetic things to arse out a goal.

Rankine seems to be smoother and cleaner.

It might sound like nonsense but I'm sure there's someone out there who knows what I mean.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

I think the second one was Hinge? But I can’t be entirely sure.

Yep it was and it was just as horrific but just in front of goal

If the vic footy shoes don’t expose these this week they are as big a sham as we already think

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

First time we've kicked over 100 points in a Showdown since 2017.

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

Thilthorpe is one of us. Giving it to Port supporters after every goal he kicked.

I love watching him play. He celebrates a goal from a team mate as much as any supporter.

 

[Danger in Texas]

Murray has been amazing ever since playing on buddy at SCG last year

Adding layers to his game now too

His offensive game is on a steady incline. He’s learning to use his strong boot to best advantage

Mainstay

 

[Crow_68]

Looks like Kenny's gone now (unfortunately). I reckon once he leaves the floodgates will open and a few players will leave with him.

Jonas, Boak, Dixon, Lycett all on their last legs.
Very little depth running round in the SANFL.
No 2023 first round draft pick.
They are in a world of hurt.