Review The Good, Bad and Ugly vs. Hawthorn Hawks

Remove this Banner Ad

I didn't see the game I will preface this.

Question for the group:

Did the side come out onto the MCG and play slow possession kick and catch football while trying to defend the game to death? Only to reach a point midway through the 3rd quarter, Nicks decided to flick a switch and we went to all out attack.
Wouldn't put much stock in anything from that halfway through the 3rd onwards. After the half time break the line in the sand was drawn and we came out with even less intensity than the first quarter. Hawks were 100% in cruise control after they walked in that first few goals.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

There's something on the nose .....one of the most important games of the season & we come out to play like meek lambs

Interesting, similar comments were made about some of our players in the SANFL ??

That said, there's a tipping point with injuries .....Milera, Thilthorpe, Rankine, Pedlar, Worrell, Himmelberg .....then add Walker, & Dawson

8 players missing !

Smith is gone, is running like a Draft Horse, and he was directly responsible for half a dozen turnovers in that 1st Qtr and half

Don't be fooled by Crouch's disposals .....it's fools gold ....each time HAW broke clear at CBA's, it was Crouch languishing back in the centre circle
It's foolish to think that getting cheap disposals, with zero impact, compensates for his snail pace & lack of any form of defence

Laird also, as I indicated last year, has slowed down .....and his #1 wood, his 2 mtre circle speed has gone
Telling that Laird was sent to DEF ....so there's a recognition of the problem .....you can't hide Crouch, and we truly have no-one in the SANFL capable of making a significant in-put

Anyone saying we don't need a Stiffy Johncock type BP ...and Michalanney can do the job .....BS
Michalanney needs to be played higher up the ground, to use his pace, and replace Smith .....not be dragged back to the goalsquare as he was today

Full of admiration for Soligo, Hinge, Keane, Nankervis, and Cook .....growing admiration for Butts 👍

Burgess, simply a fill-in, not AFL standard ....a FWD line of Burgess and Fog .....man, that's ugly

Dawson couldn't run

But yet again, the root cause of all our problems is a slow, impactless midfield
 
There's something on the nose .....one of the most important games of the season & we come out to play like meek lambs

Interesting, similar comments were made about some of our players in the SANFL ??

That said, there's a tipping point with injuries .....Milera, Thilthorpe, Rankine, Pedlar, Worrell, Himmelberg .....then add Walker, & Dawson

8 players missing !

Smith is gone, is running like a Draft Horse, and he was directly responsible for half a dozen turnovers in that 1st Qtr and half

Don't be fooled by Crouch's disposals .....it's fools gold ....each time HAW broke clear at CBA's, it was Crouch languishing back in the centre circle
It's foolish to think that getting cheap disposals, with zero impact, compensates for his snail pace & lack of any form of defence

Laird also, as I indicated last year, has slowed down .....and his #1 wood, his 2 mtre circle speed has gone
Telling that Laird was sent to DEF ....so there's a recognition of the problem .....you can't hide Crouch, and we truly have no-one in the SANFL capable of making a significant in-put

Anyone saying we don't need a Stiffy Johncock type BP ...and Michalanney can do the job .....BS
Michalanney needs to be played higher up the ground, to use his pace, and replace Smith .....not be dragged back to the goalsquare as he was today

Full of admiration for Soligo, Hinge, Keane, Nankervis, and Cook .....growing admiration for Butts 👍

Burgess, simply a fill-in, not AFL standard ....a FWD line of Burgess and Fog .....man, that's ugly

Dawson couldn't run

But yet again, the root cause of all our problems is a slow, impactless midfield

Mate I said ages back he has lost the players
 
Laird has been playing poorly all year and today's game was no better. If his stat padding style had any substance he'd have not been moved out of thew middle
That post is to defend Crouch. It definitely isn't defending Laird with those turnover numbers.

I don't think there's a single person here who actually wants Laird in the midfield anymore.
 
There's something on the nose .....one of the most important games of the season & we come out to play like meek lambs

Interesting, similar comments were made about some of our players in the SANFL ??

That said, there's a tipping point with injuries .....Milera, Thilthorpe, Rankine, Pedlar, Worrell, Himmelberg .....then add Walker, & Dawson

8 players missing !

Smith is gone, is running like a Draft Horse, and he was directly responsible for half a dozen turnovers in that 1st Qtr and half

Don't be fooled by Crouch's disposals .....it's fools gold ....each time HAW broke clear at CBA's, it was Crouch languishing back in the centre circle
It's foolish to think that getting cheap disposals, with zero impact, compensates for his snail pace & lack of any form of defence

Laird also, as I indicated last year, has slowed down .....and his #1 wood, his 2 mtre circle speed has gone
Telling that Laird was sent to DEF ....so there's a recognition of the problem .....you can't hide Crouch, and we truly have no-one in the SANFL capable of making a significant in-put

Anyone saying we don't need a Stiffy Johncock type BP ...and Michalanney can do the job .....BS
Michalanney needs to be played higher up the ground, to use his pace, and replace Smith .....not be dragged back to the goalsquare as he was today

Full of admiration for Soligo, Hinge, Keane, Nankervis, and Cook .....growing admiration for Butts 👍

Burgess, simply a fill-in, not AFL standard ....a FWD line of Burgess and Fog .....man, that's ugly

Dawson couldn't run

But yet again, the root cause of all our problems is a slow, impactless midfield
LOL

Draught Horse even..
 
You mean when he was averaging 20 disposals and kicked 10.10 in the first 8 weeks of last season and looked a totally different defensive player in there that even Southerntakeover made a comment that he would have fun at Collingwood. But Nicks hasn't given him a slight look this season until Rankine got injured and even when that happened and Nicks said Rachele will play midfield minute last week, he didn't really played midfield but only attended a majority of CBA.
Actually try watching the game, without your biases ....we're judging Rachele on now, not 15 months ago
 
Fair enough but the fact he successfully avoided stuffing things up is because he never had any influence on the game... until the junk at the end.
I like the guy but his lack of effective output is a career negative. He won't last without significant improvement... in spite of his alleged talent.

Not our biggest problem but there is no sugar coating his contribution to a team failure today.
He spent the majority of the game as our deepest forward, the ball didn't get down there that much
 
Laird has been playing poorly all year and today's game was no better. If his stat padding style had any substance he'd have not been moved out of thew middle
HUH?

Laird has been very ordinary most of the year, Crouch has not.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Absolutely shit take. He is not even in the top 10 when it comes to our problems
Not really, he was put out to dry by the club, let go like his brother for any takers, he had none. It is a systemic of the issue of our club, we can't make clean breaks when we want to
 
There's something on the nose .....one of the most important games of the season & we come out to play like meek lambs

Interesting, similar comments were made about some of our players in the SANFL ??

That said, there's a tipping point with injuries .....Milera, Thilthorpe, Rankine, Pedlar, Worrell, Himmelberg .....then add Walker, & Dawson

8 players missing !

Smith is gone, is running like a Draft Horse, and he was directly responsible for half a dozen turnovers in that 1st Qtr and half

Don't be fooled by Crouch's disposals .....it's fools gold ....each time HAW broke clear at CBA's, it was Crouch languishing back in the centre circle
It's foolish to think that getting cheap disposals, with zero impact, compensates for his snail pace & lack of any form of defence

Laird also, as I indicated last year, has slowed down .....and his #1 wood, his 2 mtre circle speed has gone
Telling that Laird was sent to DEF ....so there's a recognition of the problem .....you can't hide Crouch, and we truly have no-one in the SANFL capable of making a significant in-put

Anyone saying we don't need a Stiffy Johncock type BP ...and Michalanney can do the job .....BS
Michalanney needs to be played higher up the ground, to use his pace, and replace Smith .....not be dragged back to the goalsquare as he was today

Full of admiration for Soligo, Hinge, Keane, Nankervis, and Cook .....growing admiration for Butts

Burgess, simply a fill-in, not AFL standard ....a FWD line of Burgess and Fog .....man, that's ugly

Dawson couldn't run

But yet again, the root cause of all our problems is a slow, impactless midfield
Not playing Hamill was a massive error.

Only appropriate player on our list to put on a guy like Dylan Moore.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Actually try watching the game, without your biases ....we're judging Rachele on now, not 15 months ago
You don't think how Nicks treated him with no midfield minutes this season has affected a young and developing midfielder? All Rachele did was attended a majority of CBA last week and then played forward even when Nicks said Rachele will play midfield.
 
Has been a concern for a long time, I think I may have posted my concerns regularly.....Rachele was put into the midfield for half a qtr, and strolled up & down the centre square for most of that period .....he was in no-man's land ......meanwhile, Soligo was helping his defenders in the goal square

Terrible work rate, terrible body language .....that's why the midfield experiment with him was ditched.

He's not the only though one, there's a whole multitude of players who haven't developed under Nicks.

I honestly think Rachele is going to be one of those players who will flourish under a better coach.

I'm just hoping that Nicks hasn't completely broken him by the time we replace him.
 
Not playing Hamill was a massive error.

Only appropriate player on our list to put on a guy like Dylan Moore.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app
It's definitely a list weakness .....we've had Stiffy, and Laird ....and now no-one to close down small fwds, all teams seem to be focussing on
 
There's something on the nose .....one of the most important games of the season & we come out to play like meek lambs

Interesting, similar comments were made about some of our players in the SANFL ??

That said, there's a tipping point with injuries .....Milera, Thilthorpe, Rankine, Pedlar, Worrell, Himmelberg .....then add Walker, & Dawson

8 players missing !

Smith is gone, is running like a Draft Horse, and he was directly responsible for half a dozen turnovers in that 1st Qtr and half

Don't be fooled by Crouch's disposals .....it's fools gold ....each time HAW broke clear at CBA's, it was Crouch languishing back in the centre circle
It's foolish to think that getting cheap disposals, with zero impact, compensates for his snail pace & lack of any form of defence

Laird also, as I indicated last year, has slowed down .....and his #1 wood, his 2 mtre circle speed has gone
Telling that Laird was sent to DEF ....so there's a recognition of the problem .....you can't hide Crouch, and we truly have no-one in the SANFL capable of making a significant in-put

Anyone saying we don't need a Stiffy Johncock type BP ...and Michalanney can do the job .....BS
Michalanney needs to be played higher up the ground, to use his pace, and replace Smith .....not be dragged back to the goalsquare as he was today

Full of admiration for Soligo, Hinge, Keane, Nankervis, and Cook .....growing admiration for Butts 👍

Burgess, simply a fill-in, not AFL standard ....a FWD line of Burgess and Fog .....man, that's ugly

Dawson couldn't run

But yet again, the root cause of all our problems is a slow, impactless midfield

As I said last week... Everyone was fapping over how good we were when I said 'Lets see us back it up this week against actual opponents away'.

As expected we weren't up to it, really outside Rankine and Worrell you can't blame injuries (granted Tex and Dawson were ginger in game day but it didn't cost us the game).

Our soft weak insipid gutless spineless squib underbelly cost us the game along with that bald bloke in the coaches box.
 
Forgot to mention earlier. Also seemed like we were completely oblivious to the new htb interpretation. Showed absolutely zero awareness that we'd be allowed less time and looked stunned every time they paid it.

As much as it seemed like Hawthorn did get an extra second compared to us, we certainly did ourselves no favours.
 
I was at the game and frankly disappointed with the game not living up to the potential.

Watched Raschele a lot in the second and last qtr. Was at the top in the Olympic stand.

He was lacklustre, didn't put his body on the line when there were 50/50 and his leads were poor. For example, instead of waiting right time to dash for a lead, he would burst before the player could set for a pass. These early burst resulted in running too close to the marker who was unable to kick, only option would have been a chip into a rapidly closing defensive zone.

Very disappointed in Josh. Watching him live, I'm convinced that he is a passenger this season. No urgency and ball watching too.

I know that the anti Nicks fans would blame the coach for the poor performance but the Crows were making basic skill errors.
 
Last edited:
Laird has been playing poorly all year and today's game was no better. If his stat padding style had any substance he'd have not been moved out of thew middle

As bad as he has been, he could at least be deployed behind the ball to address an extremely predictable imbalance. Crouch is midfield and bench, there’s no future in that.
 
He kicked 3 goals. That's his influence. You just deemed them unimportant for reasons that make no logical sense in the context of that game.
"That game" actually had ceased to exist and was fully completed as a sporting contest by the time he entered the statistics in a numerical sense. And in spite of these statistics, they had no bearing whatsoever on the result of the contest.

It is paradoxical, but in this instance, the quantitative mathematical statistics become illogical as the full length of the game is an irrelevant measure in determining the actual sporting contest.
 
Good... we will get a better pick in the national draft this year, which is mid fielder strong. With the loss, we maybe more likely to use future potential players, such as Dowling, Taylor, Ryan and Curtin for the second half of the season.
Bad.... smith and the first half intensity
Ugly..- we lost
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Review The Good, Bad and Ugly vs. Hawthorn Hawks

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top