Rumour 2024 Hypothetical trade and FA Thread

[Strapping Young Lad]

2024 Picks



2025 Picks

 

[Bugs1977]

Yes Mitch has had a bad injury history. But he’s not a ****ing spud.



I tell my son “Kick it like Mitchy Lewis does”

If he get's his body right then the dude could end up being the final piece to the puzzle

 

[Bugs1977]

Finn Maginess has currency imo. Be a good fit at Sydney.

I can only imagine the melts in here when Finn ends up tagging either Day or Nuke out of the game in a big final

 

[seysearles]

Finn Maginess has currency imo. Be a good fit at Sydney.

That sends shivers down my spine. I dont rate Maginness much but i think that's pretty much how i felt about JPK also.

 

[Hodginator]

When Finn has played this year, I recon he played some good footy.

Tough team to crack into though for our fringe players such as Finn, Mitchell, Huss, etc

 

[Platten44]

Pick purchasing will come in by 2025 so there's always a way to get the draft collateral. All we would need is for Mac to say the magic words 'make me a Hawk' and we'd find a way to make it happen.

If we get Barrass, Battle and Perryman and with the pay rises for our players who have re-signed this year we won’t have any cap space to purchase picks.

 

[VandoHawk]

Finn Maginess has currency imo. Be a good fit at Sydney.

 

[Nugett]

I can only imagine the melts in here when Finn ends up tagging either Day or Nuke out of the game in a big final

It would be Josh Kennedy all over again

 

[OsakaHawk]

It would be Josh Kennedy all over again

Yeah Josh Kennedy all over again, so Finn gets traded to the swans just like Kennedy did and we win a threepeat all over again just like last time, sounds like a plan to me

I don’t want to trade Finn, I just don’t like the comparison

 

[Nugett]

Yeah Josh Kennedy all over again, so Finn gets traded to the swans just like Kennedy did and we win a threepeat all over again just like last time, sounds like a plan to me

I don’t want to trade Finn, I just don’t like the comparison

I wouldn’t want to trade Finn either, when he does play, he plays his role and plays it well. Think his best game was against the Suns where he was playing as a defensive forward

 

[CHUBBSS]

I just did. Those comments are few and far between. Feel free to bump all the ones you can find but I think you’ll find that one game of his has created all this clucking in the chook shed.

I have an oddly good memory, you may not

 

[Spanish Sahara]

When Finn has played this year, I recon he played some good footy.

Tough team to crack into though for our fringe players such as Finn, Mitchell, Huss, etc

WE have also had a super healthy year as a club for the most part, particularly to the midfield group so spots haven't naturally opened up

 

[Bugs1977]

Yeah Josh Kennedy all over again, so Finn gets traded to the swans just like Kennedy did and we win a threepeat all over again just like last time, sounds like a plan to me

I don’t want to trade Finn, I just don’t like the comparison

Yeah that's all good and well but as long as you can guarantee that a reoccurrence like the 2012 GF nightmare doesn't happen then I'll okay it. That day still burns deep with me and I don't think I will ever get over it. Living in NSW was hard until we got retribution in 2014.

 

[The Chad and I]

When Finn has played this year, I recon he played some good footy.

Tough team to crack into though for our fringe players such as Finn, Mitchell, Huss, etc

He's got enough to become a very good footballer in a team that plays him as a ball-winner.
Sydney is gonna do it to us again.

 

[Bugs1977]

View attachment 2079601

I think this GIF works a little better. Finn Maginness 3 year extension incoming

 

[Newmo89]

Agree. I rate him highly and it worried me that hes slipped back into the VFL and isnt even getting names in the extended squad. Would be upset if we lost him.

Has spent a bit of time in the rehab group the past month, which may explain why his name hasn’t been on extended benches.

 

[Newmo89]

Keep in mind there's 2 parts to the NGA. For the HFC to have priority access to him he'll need to meet the criteria under part 2. I'm sure Newmo89 will confirm this for us if he does / doesn't.

Have had it confirmed from two different sources that Anderson is in the NGA and that we can bid on him this year.

 

[Dewnior]

Finn Maginess has currency imo. Be a good fit at Sydney.

Straight swap for Tom McCartin

 

[Billyc]

He's got enough to become a very good footballer in a team that plays him as a ball-winner.
Sydney is gonna do it to us again.

Nonsense. Nothing like Kennedy as a player. The only similarity is their dads played for Hawthorn

 

[Blackhawk42]

It would be Josh Kennedy all over again

I'm not really sure I can envision Finn becoming a 3 time All Australian, 3 time B&F, Gary Ayres Medalist and club captain personally.

But I guess stranger things have happened.

 

[matey]

Like Cody Anderson’s nickname …… “Beast from the East”. Great WWE wrestling name!

 

[The Chad and I]

Nonsense. Nothing like Kennedy as a player. The only similarity is their dads played for Hawthorn

OK.

I'm not really sure I can envision Finn becoming a 3 time All Australian, 3 time B&F, Gary Ayres Medalist and club captain personally.

But I guess stranger things have happened.

Nobody envisioned Kennedy doing any of that either, nor Finn right now.
Rather the point is that Finn is likely to go onto become a very good player that we wished stayed at Hawthorn, much like Kennedy.

 

[moistie]

Finn Maginess has currency imo. Be a good fit at Sydney.

The thought of a second father son going to Sydney and setting the league on fire would cripple me.

 

[tl92]

The thought of a second father son going to Sydney and setting the league on fire would cripple me.

We took Tom Mitchell who won a Brownlow.

 

[TylerDurden]

 

[Billyc]

I love how quickly they became a rabble again. It all stems from ignoring their former president’s completely reasonable concerns, which were proven correct, just because they were winning.