Search results for query: *

One of our players has it

wasn't told but think he had gastro during the week

Brown late withdraw so vfl so maybe him? All I've been told is beams is out so would only be guessing on brown in.

Hearing on pretty good authority beams is out

What a bizarre response, when did I say there will never be a role for him? With where his game is at currently I think he is at the back of a line of very strong small-medium forwards and there just won't be a spot for him in my view once Hoskin is back. Saying that I think with some time...

Shouldn't be this week, but I think Stephenson is going to end up being pushed out. Was given a lot of luxuries last year with the amount of space our coaches and opposition coaches gave him, isn't getting that this year with Elliott being back in and de goey being twice the player he was this...

This aged like a bottle of Grange

Not really, as good as Cox was on the weekend all he has done all year is make a contest and we haven't needed much more from him. We have had 5 other forwards kick more goals than him this season. Cox not kicking goals won't be a problem.

Sit down, means very little if we get smashed next week

This is one of the worst posts I've seen on bigfooty. And I've seen some bad ones

Howe Goldsack and Treloar are all in. Moore could be too but I’m not sure. The first three definitely are though

And the rhetoric coming from most Melbourne fans is that Gawn is the best ruckman, surprise surprise.

So I just watched the Beams interview on Fox and it got me thinking how good he was in the back half of 2012. I was born in 97 so only started following footy seriously in about 05-06 so I probably missed the absolute best of Buckley. As much as I love Swan and Pendlebury I'm pretty happy with...

Yep, that’s what I’m advocating for!

This serves no purpose at all though. Whilst yes this is just a Bigfooty thread and really has almost no impact on anything at all, the idea to just dismiss anyone who doesn't agree with you on these sorts of issues as "racists or "idiots" has no benefit at all. Of course some people in the...

Whatever makes me happy? I'm sure the poll is flawed but the idea to label one side of the debate as just "wrong", when in this case it seems like a large number of people are from that side of the debate serves no purpose at all.

It’s amazing though that you make such a comment but yet Sam Newmans’s side appears to be the majority based on the poll, despite ridiculous levels of outrage in the comments.

hypothetically if we finish 3rd would most likely scenario be we play Thursday night in perth? and if 4th we play Richmond on Friday night?? This seems the most likely schedule wouldn't it be?

Very odd take. Stephenson is a first year player who is having the same or similar output to a much more mature and experienced Hoskin-Elliot. Stephenson you would expect to become more of a midfielder as he gets older and the way he has started his career you would expect him to pass...

I know this isn't what the thread is about, but surely abusing these players for these defects is well and truly out of bounds? A pathetic group of opposition fans at a recent pies game yelled out on a number of times things like "don't have a heart attack Stephenson" "It's about to pop...

I apologise if this has been done to death, But why the hell is Daicos or even Sier in the team over Brown? Surely Brown showed stronger form? Heck even Murray would offer more than Greenwood, no?

It appears the two parties couldn't come to a mutual agreement. I can confirm discussions were had though.

Hey guys, just heard some shock news that you have offered pick 8+dunstan for Marcus bontempelli catching everyone by surprise. Anyone else hearing this and is this a deal you want?

Huge late news coming out of trade central on the last day of trade period, saints have just produced a shock offer for Marcus bontempelli. Offering pick 8+Luke dunstan. Anyone else hearing this?

Based on how they've assessed things this year I think the only way cotchin gets off is if they go easy based on it being a grand final. Every decision this year has been based on result purely, and unfortunately that goes against cotchin. Saying that I think the afl will let him off because of...

Tough poll, off what we have seen I think Beams is better, but he has been injured a lot since leaving us and probably not hit the form he has when he was at his peak with us yet. I also think we are yet to see Treloar's best. Think I'd say Treloar. But give me Beams 2012-14 back please.

Yeh you're missing a bit here

Got me!!

If Scharenberg isn't selected the MCC will be one $5 childs ticket poorer

Will Hoskin Elliot has been a revolution since shipment from blacktown, he deserves a mention