Mega Thread 2014 FA, Trades, Rumours and Facts (pre-draft thread).

[MyManLynch]

Our season has even finished yet and already there's rumours of everyone coming to Collingwood.

It's going to be a long 5 weeks

 

[Seedsfan]

I would do it in a heartbeat, u think its fair? I am bias afterall

Well, if we look at it this way Stewart was taken 27 in a year were about 5-6 players were taken in the mini draft that puts him at about 33 so giving them 25 for that part of the deal is a win. Downgrading O'Rouke's draft rating with the mini draft players and Joe Daniher who would have gone before him if not father son, puts him to about 9th best overall in his year. Also the fact he has had his injuries and not until the end of this year play consistent footy to the end of the year he would have slide a bit more. SO saying that I think that is a fair deal

 

[SApies]

Our season has even finished yet and already there's rumours of everyone coming to Collingwood.

This! Is there ANY player that hasn't been linked to a move to the pies?!

 

[ksardog]

Well, if we look at it this way Stewart was taken 27 in a year were about 5-6 players were taken in the mini draft that puts him at about 33 so giving them 25 for that part of the deal is a win. Downgrading O'Rouke's draft rating with the mini draft players and Joe Daniher who would have gone before him if not father son, puts him to about 9th best overall in his year. Also the fact he has had his injuries and not until the end of this year play consistent footy to the end of the year he would have slide a bit more. SO saying that I think that is a fair deal

Ok enough talk, lets get this done !!!

 

[Bay Pie]

This! Is there ANY player that hasn't been linked to a move to the pies?!

Dayne Beams He's off to Brisbane apparently.

 

[toxic]

Devon Smith would be the player on GWS' list that would suit us the most, I think. Would just about take him before Cameron, Boyd, Treloar, Shiels, etc. at this stage.

Haven't seen anyone else reply and I'm kinda new on this forum but WTF are you on...I want some
All listed are 25% minimum better than devon
Treloar will be elite mid
Cameron is an all Australian at 20
Boyd could be absolutely anything
Shiels has elite skills

 

[SApies]

Dayne Beams He's off to Brisbane apparently.

Haha close but still involves us!

 

[ksardog]

Haven't seen anyone else reply and I'm kinda new on this forum but WTF are you on...I want some
All listed are 25% minimum better than devon
Treloar will be elite mid
Cameron is an all Australian at 20
Boyd could be absolutely anything
Shiels has elite skills

Yeh, thought it was too silly to reply to.

 

[TradeDraft]

It's going to be a long 5 weeks

be a Long 2 months with all the Rumors and Talk

 

[Anzacday]

be a Long 2 months with all the Rumors and Talk

Mate I don't know you, but I'm gathering you're going to need some assistance to cope

 

[TradeDraft]

Mate I don't know you, but I'm gathering you're going to need some assistance to cope

True - Well I am going to Noosa Middle of October

 

[KJpie]

According to a reliable source for mine The Broom has agreed to terms on a new 2 year deal with the pies.

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Could have offered a player or a latter pick.

Could have traded Pendlebury too

 

[shizzle]

True - Well I am going to Noosa Middle of October

This is the best thing I have read in this thread

 

[MyManLynch]

True - Well I am going to Noosa Middle of October

Oh no not again! Has Noosa been warned?

 

[Matz]

Well we have been linked to him but also the Saints have been too

Have we been linked to him?

 

[SApies]

Can we get anything for trading Kmart at seasons end? Or is he a rookie therefore not able to trade?

 

[loki04]

Haven't seen anyone else reply and I'm kinda new on this forum but WTF are you on...I want some
All listed are 25% minimum better than devon
Treloar will be elite mid
Cameron is an all Australian at 20
Boyd could be absolutely anything
Shiels has elite skills

You forgot Hampson, Kelly, Whitfield....

 

[toxic]

You forgot Hampson, Kelly, Whitfield....

Didnt forget anyone. .just compared the 4 offered vs devon

 

[loki04]

Didnt forget anyone. .just compared the 4 offered vs devon

I was adding the etc

 

[Reykjavik]

It's going to be a long 5 weeks

Rumours strongly suggest that [everyone] from [everyclub] has been linked with Collingwood. This could come about in a trade for [everyone] or [anyone] or even [not even anyone] and a swap of pick [random number from 1-120] for [random food item from McDonalds breakfast menu].

As heard on SEN.

 

[TradeDraft]

Rumours strongly suggest that [everyone] from [everyclub] has been linked with Collingwood. This could come about in a trade for [everyone] or [anyone] or even [not even anyone] and a swap of pick [random number from 1-120] for [random food item from McDonalds breakfast menu].

As heard on SEN.

Then do come back here unitl after Trade Period Then.

You see many more

 

[Rorzza]

Rumours strongly suggest that [everyone] from [everyclub] has been linked with Collingwood. This could come about in a trade for [everyone] or [anyone] or even [not even anyone] and a swap of pick [random number from 1-120] for [random food item from McDonalds breakfast menu].

As heard on SEN.

Not anyone and everyone, a filter has been put in place 2014 draft/trade period and beyond. They must be able to kick the ball to a team mate under pressure plus kick seven out of ten goals thirty metres out directly in front at training as a minimum.

 

[frizzle]

James stewart and o'rourke will do me. Do it pies, gives us moore and stewart as key forwards/backs and a big bodied mid. Not sure what it will take to make GWS happy, 2nd round pick plus player/players?

Continued development of broomhead and kennedy, with the addition of a fit freeman helps our pace in the front half of the ground

Hine has already passed up the opportunity to select Stewart as a father/son pick. What makes you think he would go back on that decision now & trade for him? Not having a crack at you. Just curious. I don't see Hine going down that road. He would basically be admitting he screwed up.

 

[Seedsfan]

Hine has already passed up the opportunity to select Stewart as a father/son pick. What makes you think he would go back on that decision now & trade for him? Not having a crack at you. Just curious. I don't see Hine going down that road. He would basically be admitting he screwed up.

Yeah they may have seen him as not a priority as we had Jack Paine at the time coming through, the read I got on it at the time was we would have taken him latter on in the draft if he was avaliable but we didn't want to nominate him then pass him up