WaynesWorld19
Moderator
- Moderator
- #826
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
The only reason to play him as a tagger is if the selector continue this crazy path of picking him whenever possible, its the position of least harm to the side and hopefully he'd never have a shot for goalHe's not strong enough tackler to be a tagger to be honest.
I love Matty Crouch and the Rat but I'd trade both for Petracca, he is that good. Should have been picked at number 1 that year.
I've heard it mentioned quite a few times that Petracca is a real FIGJAM type character, apparently thinks he's pretty special himself....I love Matty Crouch and the Rat but I'd trade both for Petracca, he is that good. Should have been picked at number 1 that year.
Don't get me wrong, if he improves his attack on the man and ball, and maintains his composure under pressure throughout the season, he'll be a very handy player. But in this comparison, still not a contest on talent and ability alone.On the Rat he is my pick to have a ripper of a season
I love Matty Crouch and the Rat but I'd trade both for Petracca, he is that good. Should have been picked at number 1 that year.
To quote the ancients.I think this shows how difficult it is translate AFL into statistics. There so many different variables and context that need to be factored in. You have to which statistics correspnd to team success, but then undoubtedly there'll be a team with completely different style and strengths that causes an outlier.
Essentially there's more than 1 way to skin a chicken.
In AFL there's only one ultimate statistic and that is the score at then end of the game and it doesn't really matter how you got there. You could have the most dominant midfield and defense in the comp, But if your forwards convert at 30% you're stuffed.
They probably haven't done a horrible job, the top 3 mate midfields rate in the top 5 and on paper Collingwoods midfield is pretty decent. Richmonds midfield also probably isn't their weak point.
I think those words are from the Gold Coast induction."We're going to steal your children, wreck both their knees and then delist them in shame and give them back to you in pieces with no education or future job prospects"
Maybe a good idea for a thread to pick one player who you believe will have a major impact in 2017.On the Rat he is my pick to have a ripper of a season
Maybe a good idea for a thread to pick one player who you believe will have a major impact in 2017.
I would go with Curtly with Gov as a back up. .
"I like this idea"Maybe a good idea for a thread to pick one player who you believe will have a major impact in 2017.
I would go with Curtly with Gov as a back up. .
What you're saying wouldn't be out of the question but I personally would only play Viney in our midfield on past performance. Some of their younger guys would possibly get a game on potential but we are talking about the quality of their midfield at present so that isn't really relevant. I haven't seen a lot of Petracca but from what I have seen he looks a good prospect. He certianly isn't a star yet though. That's a bit like saying our midfield is good because we have Gallucci.That only Viney and maybe Lewis would get a game for us comment is ridiculous Imo.
Vince would take D Macs wing any day, Oliver would have been in the guts for Lyons or Thommo (alot of potential), both Lewis and Jones are comparable in experience to Thommo and far less cooked. Petracca is an absolute bull who can play both in the guts and forward. Like Sydney's Kennedy but with more polish...
We hold onto the Crouch bros and Sloane and tbh I'd replace the majority of our inside mids with Melbourne's best in the blink of an eye.
Edit: If anything, surely Petracca really jumps out at you.
Jordan Lewis overrated because he was an inside mid on a good teamWhat you're saying wouldn't be out of the question but I personally would only play Viney in our midfield on past performance. Some of their younger guys would possibly get a game on potential but we are talking about the quality of their midfield at present so that isn't really relevant. I haven't seen a lot of Petracca but from what I have seen he looks a good prospect. He certianly isn't a star yet though. That's a bit like saying our midfield is good because we have Gallucci.
Jones and Lewis are overrated in my opinion. Although I like the way Jones goes about it, he was for years the best inside mid in a struggling team. These types often get found out once they are surrounded by better players which is starting to happen already. Lewis is naturally overrated because he was the main inside mid in a team that won 3 premierships in a row. In reality though Hawthorns midfield was their weakest area of the ground - especially the contested stuff which was what Lewis was in the team for.
Vince wouldn't be playing for us, especially on a wing. The reason his form has turned around is because he has been able to play as a mid at Melbourne. He wasn't getting a game in the midfield at Adelaide and as a wingman/half forward he was told that he would be delisted and as a result was traded.
Wayne's-World
Inside, outside ......getting a bit sick of this labelling
B.Crouch is a midfielder who plays both .....same Sloane
I think Knight can join that group .......i agree this year maybe premature, but eventually
We have plenty of wing options ......not so midfield ATS
Wayne's-World, Nov 30, 2015
Wayne's-World
Wing players have traditionally been outside predominately .......midfielders need to be both, generally you only carry one inside only
The word "spread from the contest" is frequently used .......players like CEY & Lyons have been criticized for being good inside but poor in spreading to provide that outside option
Just think Knight could be an even better option that Neale Wayne's-World, Nov 30, 2015
Kane McGoodwin
I don't believe we should be using knight as an inside grunt player when we have thommo, Sloane, crouches, Douglas, cey & Lyons more suited to this role.
Knight is a great gut-running player, so let him settle into Afl 1st before redefining his role. Think you may have confused him for Smith, who we are likely to turn into an outside-inside player... Kane McGoodwin, Nov 30, 2015
Yep calling Knight a midfielder is right out there thinking that no one could have predicted.Well, since everyone criticizes my selections on players for midfield roles ......seems i may be right after all
Knight is faster but also stronger and heavier, having put on 2-3kg to his 80kg frame as he eyes more of a midfield role next year.
“It’s been hard for me with my running capacity to put on weight but I’ve put on a couple of kilos and am starting to get up to a more competitive playing weight,” he said.
“The strength and conditioning staff and dietitians are working pretty closely with me to get that up around where it needs to be to compete through that midfield against the Josh Kennedys and Luke Parkers of the AFL.
“Every year, my (running) times are coming down with more training under the belt.
“You can’t do a lot when you’re injured but it’s good to know when I am back on the park all my times and conditioning and weight gains are starting to improve.”
Adelaide captain Taylor Walker said this week it was important for footballers to be able to play in a range of positions, and used Knight as an example.
“I look at a Riley Knight and if he’s to come into our team, he’s going to have to play inside midfield, outside, go forward,” Walker said. “So if you can play different positions in the game then it adds a big string to your bow.
"We're going to steal your children, wreck both their knees and then delist them in shame and give them back to you in pieces with no education or future job prospects"
What issue do you have with my quote?Well, since everyone criticizes my selections on players for midfield roles ......seems i may be right after all
Knight is faster but also stronger and heavier, having put on 2-3kg to his 80kg frame as he eyes more of a midfield role next year.
“It’s been hard for me with my running capacity to put on weight but I’ve put on a couple of kilos and am starting to get up to a more competitive playing weight,” he said.
“The strength and conditioning staff and dietitians are working pretty closely with me to get that up around where it needs to be to compete through that midfield against the Josh Kennedys and Luke Parkers of the AFL.
“Every year, my (running) times are coming down with more training under the belt.
“You can’t do a lot when you’re injured but it’s good to know when I am back on the park all my times and conditioning and weight gains are starting to improve.”
Adelaide captain Taylor Walker said this week it was important for footballers to be able to play in a range of positions, and used Knight as an example.
“I look at a Riley Knight and if he’s to come into our team, he’s going to have to play inside midfield, outside, go forward,” Walker said. “So if you can play different positions in the game then it adds a big string to your bow.
What issue do you have with my quote?
Knight would have played mainly as an outside player this year if he was injury free whilst thommo, m crouch, Sloane & Lyons took most inside minutes.
Like Sloane I think he will develop into an inside/outside player.
Next season he will play the vast majority on the outside, with small stints on the inside.
I agree we are better off developing players who can play multiple roles, including rotating through the midfield.Just on the Bolded section, The One person we forget about is Pyke and the influence he will have , he does not want 1-2 players to getting high 30 in disposals every week, he wants 8 -10 players playing through the middle getting 25 plus, Added to a few of the top liners giving us the X factor and a few more touches. Mention last year I don't expect too many standout players but a more consistent group of players, allowing us to give 100% pressure at the contest no matter who is there.
We did see a bit of his style and he was slowly getting the players to play his way. in 2016 we did not have the death in the type of player he needed, So he had to build some depth and experience.
I agree we are better off developing players who can play multiple roles, including rotating through the midfield.
We know Sloane & Crouches should be our main stays.
But we need Cameron, knight, Atkins, Smith, Hampton, milera, menzel, seedsman, wigg types to rotate thorough multiple positions to give us depth.
We have capable players & positions up for grabs, so I'm looking forward to see who really wants it.
Yeah? Watch everyone analyse the fixture as who has the toughest / easiest run ... every year they get it wrong, and yet every year punters fall back on it in the pre-season.this is where the stat-heads always lose out, to borrow a good line from all the super ads - "past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance"
Is it possible to upgrade Greenwood or one of the other rookies before the season starts or has that ship sailed?