List Mgmt. 2019 Draft and Trade Hypotheticals Thread

[Membling]

View attachment 750865

Sigh.

Good player but wwwwaaayyyyy too many question marks for the likely price we will pay.

 

[dosser]

Sigh.

Good player but wwwwaaayyyyy too many question marks for the likely price we will pay.

If he really wants to come here, then maybe he can help us do it.

 

[David C]

Strong draft next year apparently and almost guaranteed that these two won’t be anywhere near the top. Bidding on 2nd rounders is dumb so why use points if you don’t have to?

I've heard the exact opposite, next years draft is worse than this years which isn't real strong after the top end.

 

[Ticky009]

Would we be interested in Aiden Bonar for the mids?

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

Wants to return home to Vic.

 

[mikey_san]

Are we not delisting anyone this year?
Or does it all depend on who we nab in the trade period? We must be looking at midfield, KPD depth as well as the big fish.

 

[Tedeski]

Bunyip friend reckons Paps wants to stay

He mustn't have liked their facilities after touring them.

 

[dosser]

It's quite refreshing to read all of these posts about Mills. Has anyone ever thought of making any comments about the Tom Mitchell trade?

 

[mikey_san]

He mustn't have liked their facilities after touring them.

They only have instant coffee and the toilets weren't cleaned.
Case closed.

 

[BloodySwan]

I have to disagree.

Crouch is a decent player in a pretty weak midfield. He’s no star & not worth a 5 year risk.

You'd expect him to play until he's 30 and he'd be our number 1 midfielder the whole time. Only question is around injury

 

[Jewelsbon]

It's quite refreshing to read all of these posts about Mills. Has anyone ever thought of making any comments about the Tom Mitchell trade?

Don't even joke about it

 

[dosser]

Don't even joke about it

Ok, but how good was Tippett?

 

[Jewelsbon]

Ok, but how good was Tippett?

Your going to make my head explode!!!!!

 

[Jimbo OZ]

Sorry to be that guy but can the Mills chat be re-routed to the Callum Mills thread? I came on here on a quiet Sunday arvo to read more about us trading for Daniher, Crouch, and Constable while keeping both Paps and Jones.

 

[Banyo Bloods]

Bennell getting himself in the media commenting on relevant topics. Seems a real push to get to a third club. Maybe a bit desperate to still make it at AFL level but also can look at it as a real desire to commit and get his body right. At no risk to recruit he is certainly worth a chance, I hope this is one rumour that has some legs (pun intended) would like to see him a chance at the Swans.

 

[Mick Oxlong]

I've heard the exact opposite, next years draft is worse than this years which isn't real strong after the top end.

Then you have misheard.

 

[ashep]

I'm late, but you can't read anything into Woosha's comments. Daniher hasn't publicly asked for a trade so there's nothing he can say other than he's a contracted player and will be there next year.

And by "holding all the cards" he's referring to the fact that we may have some interest, but again until Daniher asks for a trade, they have 100% of the leverage.

If he eventually does so, that changes things dramatically.

 

[Donza]

Sorry to be that guy but can the Mills chat be re-routed to the Callum Mills thread? I came on here on a quiet Sunday arvo to read more about us trading for Daniher, Crouch, and Constable while keeping both Paps and Jones.

I've downloaded a chrome extension where you can filter(ignore) forum posts by a keyword . "mills" "Mitchell "
This thread is currently 17 pages only.

 

[caesar88]

In an attempt to get this train back on the tracks... how about a hypothetical... let's say our big fish was Crouch rather than Daniher. How would we get him to the club?

If Essendon's insistence that Daniher is staying put is legitimate, then no reason our insistence that Papley's staying put isn't just as legitimate. So if the Daniher/Papley scenario was scratched, which meant we didn't have Carlton's top 10 pick to offer, and we didn't offer up our pick 6... how do we get Crouch?

 

[Ticky009]

In an attempt to get this train back on the tracks... how about a hypothetical... let's say our big fish was Crouch rather than Daniher. How would we get him to the club?

If Essendon's insistence that Daniher is staying put is legitimate, then no reason our insistence that Papley's staying put isn't just as legitimate. So if the Daniher/Papley scenario was scratched, which meant we didn't have Carlton's top 10 pick to offer, and we didn't offer up our pick 6... how do we get Crouch?

Start with understanding what he wants from Crows.
Which is a 5 yr deal
Then what do the Ctows want. Draft picks or players or s combo?

I’m honestly not sure they actually know what they want right now.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

In an attempt to get this train back on the tracks... how about a hypothetical... let's say our big fish was Crouch rather than Daniher. How would we get him to the club?

If Essendon's insistence that Daniher is staying put is legitimate, then no reason our insistence that Papley's staying put isn't just as legitimate. So if the Daniher/Papley scenario was scratched, which meant we didn't have Carlton's top 10 pick to offer, and we didn't offer up our pick 6... how do we get Crouch?

Rather not bother there’s better targets.

 

[caesar88]

Rather not bother there’s better targets.

Enlighten me?

 

[Punts]

you would think that to get Daniher and crouch in we would have to give up our first and the papley pick as apart of the deals

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Enlighten me?

A genuine ruck for one if not take the picks and head to the draft

 

[mtooler]

It's quite refreshing to read all of these posts about Mills. Has anyone ever thought of making any comments about the Tom Mitchell trade?

I don't ever not think about referring to the Tom Mitchell trade!

 

[mtooler]

Yup, I see him as the next generation McVeigh in many ways. Of course, there were people around here that piled s**t on McVeigh too...

Mcveigh was on point!