List Mgmt. 2019 Draft and Trade Hypotheticals Thread

[Blacky]

I might head over to the Horse thread to cheer me up.

 

[kickthething]

Would be pretty shocked if GWS doing match for Green. Maybe we're trying to setup a trade with them?

They will match you would think...the point is they are indictating the use of this pick at the draft table rather that trade table

 

[kickthething]

Eh? How would we get him with the number 5 pick if we gave that pick to GWS (If that is what you are suggesting)?
I'd pay a premium for sure, but that one sounds a little metaphysical.
He'd totally be worth a selection at that point in the draft though from all accounts...

Not Toby Greene...Tom Green

 

[mikey_san]

Would be pretty shocked if GWS doing match for Green. Maybe we're trying to setup a trade with them?

Would that be even possible - giving them a pick for not matching our Green bid?

 

[Chaisa]

Because we remember Tippett.

Poor parallel IMO. That's a reason why "the deal seems a dodgy one even if we pay fair value", not "let's hyperventilate because Damian Barrett thinks that we'll pay overs, when in fact the only info he has is his own gut feel of what Carlton and Essendon would want"

 

[mikey_san]

Not Toby Greene...Tom Green

Yes that's one part I did understand. From all reports a total gun mid. Part of their acadamy...99.9% sure they would match our bid at 5 - not that they need him, as he'd be behind a wall of the best mids in the comp...

 

[BloodySwan]

Would that be even possible - giving them a pick for not matching our Green bid?

I mean show we're keen on Green so trade out pick 5 for something like their first round and a second.

 

[Bega Barlow]

I trust the club but in this instance (despite the strong possibility that d barratt’s mail is false) decided to express my dismay at the touted three club mega trade. SURELY we get it done without pick 5 .. surely!!!

 

[sataris]

I trust the club but in this instance (despite the strong possibility that d barratt’s mail is false) decided to express my dismay at the touted three club mega trade. SURELY we get it done without pick 5 .. surely!!!

View attachment 757765

If that actually gets forwarded to anyone of note, I'll eat my own face.

 

[Opts]

I trust the club but in this instance (despite the strong possibility that d barratt’s mail is false) decided to express my dismay at the touted three club mega trade. SURELY we get it done without pick 5 .. surely!!!

View attachment 757765

Well done. Better to complain now rather than complain after the deal is done.

 

[mikey_san]

I mean show we're keen on Green so trade out pick 5 for something like their first round and a second.

Sorry, not following at all.
We have to bid on him at 5 to have any chance of getting him. If we don't someone else will. Are you saying don't bid, give our pick to GWS and have them deal him to us when a pick does come? Can they trade someone immediately after selecting him in the draft?

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

I trust the club but in this instance (despite the strong possibility that d barratt’s mail is false) decided to express my dismay at the touted three club mega trade. SURELY we get it done without pick 5 .. surely!!!

View attachment 757765

LOL thats hilarious and promptly deleted a few seconds later.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

If that actually gets forwarded to anyone of note, I'll eat my own face.

How does one eat their own face tho?

 

[Blacky]

How does one eat their own face tho?

Spend a weekend with Hanner and Buddy

 

[Banyo Bloods]

How does one eat their own face tho?

Start with the top lip you can kind of get that in between your teeth. Finishing the job may be difficult but if you have a scalpel it can be achieved. Sounds painful doubt anyone could complete the task but never say never.

Don’t think this post will have the legs the curry discussion had though.

I’m being a dick

 

[Syd]

Well done. Better to complain now rather than complain after the deal is done.

 

[SSwans2011]

Don’t think this post will have the legs the curry discussion had though.

never say never.

 

[WillHayward]

Draft picks are grossly overrated

D Martin, Fyfe, Riewoldt, B Grundy, De Goey, P Cripps, McLuggage, Bont, Coniglio, C Curnow...

All acquired in the draft.

 

[Tesla Tenet]

Draft picks are grossly overrated

Thats not true. In modern times nearly every good or great player was drafted.

Except forJim Stynes, Tadgh Kennelly etc

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

 

[SSwans2011]

D Martin, Fyfe, Riewoldt, B Grundy, De Goey, P Cripps, McLuggage, Bont, Coniglio, C Curnow...

All acquired in the draft.

Exactly. Literally only 10 out of thousands of draft picks ever have been successful.

We should avoid it at all costs.

 

[BloodySwan]

Sorry, not following at all.
We have to bid on him at 5 to have any chance of getting him. If we don't someone else will. Are you saying don't bid, give our pick to GWS and have them deal him to us when a pick does come? Can they trade someone immediately after selecting him in the draft?

Giants currently have pick 12 & 18 and nothing until 55. If we bid on Green at pick 5 they need to use both their first round picks and then get pushed back until pick 44.

We offer GWS pick 5 for their pick 12 and a 2020 first round pick (probably some other things too). This would ensure they have 2 first round picks in 2019 (pick 5 can match 3 & 4 on it's own) and we still stay in 2019 first round but also have more currency for 2020, but we miss out on Green entirely. We just keep talking about how keen we are for Green stating that we'll bid on if we go to the draft with pick 5

 

[SSwans2011]

If we traded pick 5 and 9 for Daniher, how many Craig Birds would that make him worth?

 

[mikey_san]

Giants currently have pick 12 & 18 and nothing until 55. If we bid on Green at pick 5 they need to use both their first round picks and then get pushed back until pick 44.

We offer GWS pick 5 for their pick 12 and a 2020 first round pick (probably some other things too). This would ensure they have 2 first round picks in 2019 (pick 5 can match 3 & 4 on it's own) and we still stay in 2019 first round but also have more currency for 2020, but we miss out on Green entirely. We just keep talking about how keen we are for Green stating that we'll bid on if we go to the draft with pick 5

Ah, gotcha.

I guess this might be a good idea if both Serong and Flanders are gone. We could drop back and take McCasey at 12 or even Kemp if either still on the board. I sure as S wouldn't be taking Kemp much higher than that given his injury.
If either Serong or Flanders are there I'd take them though.
GWS first next year is likely to be right at the end - can see them making the GF again with Ward, Conigliso and Big Red all in the team.

 

[mikey_san]

Exactly. Literally only 10 out of thousands of draft picks ever have been successful.

We should avoid it at all costs.

Zac Clarke was taken in the draft. Run for the hills !

 

[Millky95]

If we traded pick 5 and 9 for Daniher, how many Craig Birds would that make him worth?

Asking the real questions here