List Mgmt. 2019 Draft and Trade Hypotheticals Thread
- Thread starter Old Kenny
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
just don't see us trading pick 5.
What if we are all way off the mark & the guy is seriously considering retirement or sitting out of footy & not coming to the Swans at all?
How's this hypothetical?
What if Joe really was just catching up with Harley for genuine advice on what he should do as his body is truly stuffed & he needs another year out of footy? Dr Peter Larkin pretty much said yesterday that he was in big trouble needing the surgery he had & that he would have big question marks over his ability to play going forward.
So let's say that Daniher is not part of any conversation in becoming a Swan.
What is it we are doing? Who is it we are after?
I have been speculating for a month now that it can't be just Daniher if Paps & Jones are on the table.
Daniher, based on the above from Larkin, is a cheap as chips recruit for anyone other team other than us.
I will go out on a limb & say we are & have been into some one else...........big.............for a long time in the planning.
If we have picks 5 & 9(Paps) & Beatson has gone on record as saying we don't rate the draft.
Other than Daniher of 2017, who wouldn't have wanted a bar of the Swans when he was flying, what player that is currently being discussed in trade circles would pick 5 & 9 get us & be worth the effort?
BRODIE GRUNDY!
How's this hypothetical?
What if Joe really was just catching up with Harley for genuine advice on what he should do as his body is truly stuffed & he needs another year out of footy? Dr Peter Larkin pretty much said yesterday that he was in big trouble needing the surgery he had & that he would have big question marks over his ability to play going forward.
So let's say that Daniher is not part of any conversation in becoming a Swan.
What is it we are doing? Who is it we are after?
I have been speculating for a month now that it can't be just Daniher if Paps & Jones are on the table.
Daniher, based on the above from Larkin, is a cheap as chips recruit for anyone other team other than us.
I will go out on a limb & say we are & have been into some one else...........big.............for a long time in the planning.
If we have picks 5 & 9(Paps) & Beatson has gone on record as saying we don't rate the draft.
Other than Daniher of 2017, who wouldn't have wanted a bar of the Swans when he was flying, what player that is currently being discussed in trade circles would pick 5 & 9 get us & be worth the effort?
BRODIE GRUNDY!
SSwans2011
Hall of Famer
We're not getting Grundy.
Teddy chester
All Australian
If Damien Barrett’s article regarding the price for Daniher is correct than the swans are mad to consider it. If Carlton want papley for less than pick 9 they can go FO. I will be very worried in our decision makers, if this article is remotely correct
Fair point, but we've got nothing else to talk about so we may as well give our opinions on the hypothetical.
Now, if it actually happens, THEN you'll see the nuffies come out to play!
I'm not saying we will but he is wanting 7 years from Pies & he would be the only player worth giving picks 5 & 9 for.
We along with others would be asking the question.
Hypothetical discussion, that's all. We have cap space.
- Jun 16, 2012
- 25,857
- 27,227
- AFL Club
- Sydney
We are always going to pay a premium for a key forward especially a top 5 one...they simply dont get traded.. id suspect danihers contract will be heavily incentive based to lesses the risk or the bombers will be paying a significant portion
scaryness
Premium Platinum
- Oct 19, 2008
- 14,863
- 23,335
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Trail Blazers / Cowboys
Wait I thought 9 years $10M was our most incompetant list management moment?
Guess we forget about that one now
- Jun 16, 2012
- 25,857
- 27,227
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Id happily take the risk on 5 +9 for daniher...get him fit and he is unstoppable. Poor draft this year aswell. Very slim chance we take anyone with half his talent at those picks anyway
- Oct 2, 2016
- 12,637
- 26,366
- AFL Club
- Sydney
So is Bennell already delisted or is it not official yet? Free agency starts tomorrow, could we see a new Swan?
That is how the governance and oversight process works at a club.
The board (with all available information from their football department) will have to sign it off.
If they are steadfast against it, it is going to take Carlton two first round picks to do it.
It’s a 25% chance at best that the deal does get done.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Picks 5 and 9 for a 25 year old with chronic injury troubles.
This stinks. I am going to spew up. This is Tippet 2.0. Will we never learn?
This stinks. I am going to spew up. This is Tippet 2.0. Will we never learn?
We should get Bennell imo.
We should have got Ellis Yolmen as well.
Holy shitballs
I just watched Brodie Kemp highlights.
See for yourself
Draft Prospect Brodie Kemp
www.espn.com.au
A dead set gun. Tall, fast, skillful, athletic, smart.
Are we going to let this bloke go and go and get Daniher?
FFS.
I feel ill thinking about it.
Imagine Kemp, Dawson and Blakey running around together in a few years. Wed be unstoppable.
I just watched Brodie Kemp highlights.
See for yourself
Draft Prospect Brodie Kemp
Shades of 'the Bont' as Brodie Kemp continues to rise
Brodie Kemp has transitioned from key position player to midfielder and the tall midfielder is rising quickly in the race to be crowned the likely No. 1 pick, writes Chris Doerre.
A dead set gun. Tall, fast, skillful, athletic, smart.
Are we going to let this bloke go and go and get Daniher?
FFS.
I feel ill thinking about it.
Imagine Kemp, Dawson and Blakey running around together in a few years. Wed be unstoppable.
Last edited:
Teddy chester
All Australian
From what I have heard: Next years draft is apparently weaker than this year which is meant to be alright, just not as good as last years which was perceived as really strong. It will all probably be viewed differently in a few years anyway. I prefer not to throw valuable picks at someone who can’t get on the park. I can’t remember having non academy top 10 picks
- Oct 2, 2016
- 12,637
- 26,366
- AFL Club
- Sydney
We got Tippett for free. This would be the worst trade
Reported that we won’t trade Papley. Trading Papley is a prerequisite for Barrett’s proposed deal. Ergo, someone is full of shit and if I had to guess, it’s Barrett.
Chaisa
Brownlow Medallist
- Jun 2, 2013
- 15,003
- 14,898
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- The Exers
I don't get why 75% of the forum was willing to trust Barrett. He's not really a trustworthy journalist and loves to spew shit for clicks.
Because that deal made little sense. Hogan went for 6 + 23 and he was two years younger and had actually played in his trade year....
Because that deal made little sense. Hogan went for 6 + 23 and he was two years younger and had actually played in his trade year....
SwansProudly
Moderator
- Sep 5, 2016
- 9,453
- 26,554
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Sydney Swans AFLW
- Moderator
- #10,947
Safe travels
Because we remember Tippett.
- Oct 27, 2007
- 11,471
- 13,227
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Delisted
SSwans2011
Hall of Famer
Some Essendon board gold.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Poll
