List Mgmt. 2019 Draft and Trade Hypotheticals Thread

[swannyfan]

His value to us is huge!
23yo
leading goal kicker
leadership group
loved by team mates and coaches
inspiration on the field
4 year contract - all things being equal, the best 4 years he has
core of our 3-5 year plan to win a flag

He's worth a lot more than p9 to us - How this trade plays out is an unknown

massive importance.....certainly not a dime a dozen player some seem to believe when looking at his overall impact...and how few there are to this level in the comp..

overly exuberant, eye bulging, mouth gaping, jack jumping mad-man like goal celebrations also spark and energize the team and fans alike...can't put a price on that.

 

[TheMase]

We do? Kennedy has been legendary, but past his prime once 2020 rolls around, Parker is not a #1 mid, he needs 1 or two other ahead of him, jones is gone.
Hewitt, heeney (& mills?) Are emerging, but that group are not top 5 in the league. I don't even know how many midfield are ahead of them... but there are a few

Knowing Caesar’s opinion here I am almost certain he was taking the piss.

 

[Millky95]

I read an interesting point that we may never get a better offer for a small forward than pick 9.

In one of my Premiership Coach 2011 saves I traded Tom Papley for Patrick Cripps from Carlton the year Kennedy retired and he went on to win 8 flags in a row and retired a Swans Legend so you never know

 

[mtooler]

I agree with the sentiments of people here with Papley and his girlfriend. He should dump her.

 

[SwansProudly]

She's a nurse and flat out refuses to move to Sydney

as is her right !

 

[The King!]

buddy moved to us to be with his partner

papley has never not given 100% for us when on the field

agree with calls for respect

 

[tombomb]

I agree with the sentiments of people here with Papley and his girlfriend. He should dump her.

i say this to my dad when he tells me on the phone that mum has gone down the shops.

 

[Old Kenny]

Daniher to the swans confirmed according to the age!

 

[macca84]

Daniher has requested trade to the swans.

 

[Punts]

Boom

 

[The King!]

bang
even if we dont get it done screws essendon

 

[cherub]

Daniher has requested trade to the swans.

That's a like for the precision of your statement, not that I want Daniher, who has expressed doubt that he wants to keep playing, at the Swans.

 

[SSwans2011]

Don't care what all the pessimists say, this is awesome news.

Another generational forward at our club. Just look at his ANZAC Day performance this year with **** all fitness if you're worried about what he can provide us.

 

[Punts]

He told the club the day that I said the other day when I posted and said Thursday

My source was spot on with Daniher

Looking wrong on crouch though

 

[The King!]

That's a like for the precision of your statement, not that I want Daniher, who has expressed doubt that he wants to keep playing, at the Swans.

when did he say that?

 

[Punts]

****ing awesome

 

[The King!]

a key player wants us, not sure how that can be bad

will be great to have an actual second forward to help bud

 

[The King!]

article says essendon will play hard ball, but when its this public does make it hard to keep him

 

[Membling]

Reserving judgement until see cost.

Honestly cannot see him getting near his 2017 form and likely to be paying for that.

 

[SSwans2011]

Reserving judgement until see cost.

Honestly cannot see him getting near his 2017 form and likely to be paying for that.

Why not? He was almost BOG in the ANZAC Day Match after being rushed back. If we're patient, I see absolutely no reason he can't be a bloody good player for us.

 

[The King!]

essendon thinkin they get 5 and 9 is ****ing stupid


I would trade pick 5 thats fine, prefer to hold that, but if it got it done, then do it imo

 

[Parky79]

COme on down JD!!!

 

[SSwans2011]

Friendly reminder this was only 5 months ago and he wasn't fully fit:

essendon thinkin they get 5 and 9 is ******* stupid


I would trade pick 5 thats fine, prefer to hold that, but if it got it done, then do it imo

Yep. In my eyes, he probably has more upside than anyone we could get at pick 5 anyway.

 

[The King!]

I reckon we will trade pick 5

sydney havent pushed any bs articles about draft out etc

only head draft was shallow

 

[The King!]

Friendly reminder this was only 5 months ago and he wasn't fully fit:


Yep. In my eyes, he probably has more upside than anyone we could get at pick 5 anyway.

exactly

his injuries only issue otherwise he is worth it every day and sunday

roll the dice