Mega Thread 2019 List Management, Free Agency & Trade thread #2

[purplerunsdeep2]

I’m ok with Aish, just concerns me about his reliability, can’t stay on the park


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Wizard]

He is in the Pies best runners, put him on the wing.

I'd like him off half back an then move Wilson up the ground.

He has a better defensive game then Wilson so is a better option further back and Wilson more damaging with ball in hand so would like hi delivering the ball I50.

 

[GreatPurpleShark]

I would do 12, 18 future 1st for 22, b.hill and a future 2nd.

We can then use our 5 1st rounders to position ourselves in both drafts.

Even 18 has a lot of value to other clubs.

 

[purplerunsdeep2]

I’d get rid of our next years first for the right price. Assuming we think our NGA kids are going to be first rounders

Then load up completely in this draft and hope they all come on quick enough to give fyfe 1 or 2 seasons so have s shot at the premiership


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[wayToGo_]

I’m ok with Aish, just concerns me about his reliability, can’t stay on the park

Nah we have an excellent record of taking players with injury histories and getting them out on the field

 

[freodog]

Aish reminds me of a limp lettuce leaf

 

[Taylor]

I'd like him off half back an then move Wilson up the ground.

He has a better defensive game then Wilson so is a better option further back and Wilson more damaging with ball in hand so would like hi delivering the ball I50.

Aish would be very familiar with the coach's expectations for the defense too.

 

[beetz]

Hey guys, just thought I'd stop by and say congratulations on Ben King re-signing with the Suns, I can see how much it means to all of you and along with getting pick 6, another ripping trade period for you guys.

Obviously Freo haven’t had the best run over the years but wow, imagine being a Saints supporter. Sad existence.

 

[Okinakashi]

I have a sneaky feeling Hill will stay now.

We haven't had any Colin Young leaks to the media pleading Hill's case like many other CYoung antics.

In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if Hill signs an extension very soon.

*either this OR there's a massive deal being qorked out behind closed doors and we'll get side swiped from left field.

 

[beetz]

I’d be surprised if Saints turn over next years first for Hill. As we know, from our own traitor, contracts don’t mean much. Still every chance King wants out next season and Suns will want that first at a minimum.

 

[Kapow!!!]

Having watched quite a bit of Aish over the years I can safely say he's comfortably in the "Do Not Want" category. Is the very definition of depth player/list clogger. Again I'd rather develop Bailey Banfield as he has the same tools at his disposal.

 

[Arkhitect]

Ben King re-signs for another 3 years hahaha. You can't make this stuff up! Thank god I'm not a Saints supporter.

St Kilda publicly state that they're chasing Ben King, then stall on trading their 2020 first round pick to Freo based on the belief that they'll secure him is the biggest example of arrogance & putting the cart before the horse if I've ever seen one.

Any other club chasing Brad Hill with 2 years left on his contract gets that trade done as a priority and coughs up the required compensation to Freo. I hope we bend them over even further now. They have no leverage whatsoever over keeping their 2020 first round pick.

They spilt pick 6 for 2x picks between 10-20. I'd be demanding 2x top 20 picks this year and their 2020 first. If they can't pony up then I'd tell them to get stuffed.

 

[kingswood71]

TBH I would prefer Hilly to go to the Cats if he indeed is traded. The jumper would suit him better than the Saints one

 

[mayne iac]

Fairly bleak reading on the saints board, they seem lost.

 

[Docker82]

TBH I would prefer Hilly to go to the Cats if he indeed is traded. The jumper would suit him better than the Saints one

The Saints jumper should only be seen in the MCG museum next to Fitzroy and University.

 

[Hogwild]

Saints fans are finally realising what's coming. Either :
1. Hill stays
2. They are going to pay Freo more than the original St Kilda offer.

Here come the lame interpretations to try and justify that Bell "caved".
Geelong will not get Hill.

 

[Hogwild]

Having watched quite a bit of Aish over the years I can safely say he's comfortably in the "Do Not Want" category. Is the very definition of depth player/list clogger. Again I'd rather develop Bailey Banfield as he has the same tools at his disposal.

Go for Phillips from Collingwood

 

[FreoRicci]

Ha. St Kilda fans.. oh dear. King just re-signed. All these players they thought they were guaranteed.
12, 18 and next year’s first please...

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Aish would be almost free as a salary dump, nowhere near a 2nd I wouldn’t think. Would happily do 22 for Phillips, instantly replaces Langdon but I think they are comparable players so I wonder if 22 would get us both

 

[Docker82]

Go for Phillips from Collingwood

I’ve got the feeling Aish may come as a genuine salary cap dump - ie. we take his salary, we hand over a pick we won’t use just to satisfy the AFL.

Phillips is just so much better than Aish. If someone gets him it ain’t for peanuts.

 

[Hogwild]

So salty, i love it, can taste the tears from here

It will be - give it another few days. Belly is pulling the pineapple out of his shopping bag as we speak.

 

[Carnthedockers]

Fairly bleak reading on the saints board, they seem lost.

No different to the last 100 years.

 

[Superkoops]

Ha. St Kilda fans.. oh dear. King just re-signed. All these players they thought they were guaranteed.
12, 18 and next year’s first please...

The pieces of the puzzle coming together.

I’d be happy with 10 + 2020 1st. How many of them have been coming on here saying it’s a definite Bing (really crap nickname) will come home in 2020 trade period and absolutely no way in the world 2020 1st will be traded - as that cob is for Bing. Doubt we’ll see that 4X troll lurking today.

Perhaps we trade 2020 3rd to Richmond for McIntosh and get some late change to pass back. Probs not Bell is a Korean Dictator.

 

[Bring back Drum]

I suppose with King resigning at GC it makes it harder to see Bhill in purple next year, which despite all the current melts at Shit Kilda, is a slightly disappointing thought.
But on a positive it possibly gives us an extra pick to pull off of recruiting coup of a ready made quality replacement along with pick 79 for Menadue who I think given opportunity will be a very useful player.

 

[Docker82]

Everytime I see Bing I think of Brett Lee.

McGrath, Warne, Gillespie. Those were the days.