List Mgmt. 2019 Trade Thread - Part II

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Pick 5 for Hill
Tomlinson FA
Offer GC next years first & change & see if they bite. If King says he’s out & only to the Saints in 12 months they may cut their losses. Can we add McKenzie?
King would hold all the aces then
 

Log in to remove this ad.

We have king. Bulldogs didn’t have a forward before they got Boyd. And how bad would it be if we became the bulldogs.


Right now I'd swap our lists without blinking, they are just off a premiership and look a lot closer again after a mini rebuild. Mc Crae hasn't had a game under 38 possessions for a month or more, Bont back to elite, English as good as Marshal in prospects, Naughton what we hope king is, Dunkley elite, Hunter not far behind and Bailey Smith looking on track for similar. Still have JJ, Daniel etc as well.
 
I would prefer the club to pay Hill 800 rather than Hall 400. Have you looked at our list? It’s completely cooked yet we are paying our players the same amount as the Giants, Eagles, Pies, etc. Blokes like Jack Newnes are making as much money as Steele Sidebottom FFS.


Urgh. Why did you have to bring that up. God that's just f@#king wrong...and depressing.
 
Right now I'd swap our lists without blinking, they are just off a premiership and look a lot closer again after a mini rebuild. Mc Crae hasn't had a game under 38 possessions for a month or more, Bont back to elite, English as good as Marshal in prospects, Naughton what we hope king is, Dunkley elite, Hunter not far behind and Bailey Smith looking on track for similar. Still have JJ, Daniel etc as well.

Naughton has reinvented the way they move the footy inside 50. Before he went into the forward line they would have 400 possessions, 60 inside 50s & struggle to kick 10 goals.
 
If Polec got 800k x5...

Hill gets every penny of 900k and deserved it, far better player imo


They are both very lucky with the era they are playing in, Riewoldt money for a soft outside runner. I hope we don't do a stupid long term deal that will hamstring our future. North can't afford Kelly any more from desperate shopping.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

If we’re into Bing, it’s time to move Bruce on.

His value is higher than last year and with all due respect to him he’s bang average and if he can net us a second rounder it’s worth it.

Already accounting for Paddy never to play we have Snake, Battle, King, Clav, Austin and Bruce.

Assuming one of Clav or Austin doesn’t make it we still have too many KPP.

I honestly wouldn’t be that opposed to sending Snake and a Pick for Bing either.
 
If we’re into Bing, it’s time to move Bruce on.

His value is higher than last year and with all due respect to him he’s bang average and if he can net us a second rounder it’s worth it.

Already accounting for Paddy never to play we have Snake, Battle, King, Clav, Austin and Bruce.

Assuming one of Clav or Austin doesn’t make it we still have too many KPP.

I honestly wouldn’t be that opposed to sending Snake and a Pick for Bing either.


We would kill the Kings making them Jack Watts like lambs to the slaughter.
 
If we’re into Bing, it’s time to move Bruce on.

His value is higher than last year and with all due respect to him he’s bang average and if he can net us a second rounder it’s worth it.

Already accounting for Paddy never to play we have Snake, Battle, King, Clav, Austin and Bruce.

Assuming one of Clav or Austin doesn’t make it we still have too many KPP.

I honestly wouldn’t be that opposed to sending Snake and a Pick for Bing either.

I just don’t see the value in trading someone like Bruce for pick 30. And he ain’t going to the GC. Carlisle worth similar, maybe closer to pick 20.

Who on our list is worth a first round pick? Billings, King, Gresh, Marshall & Clark & that would be it. Ross maybe? All untouchable.

Best bet to get Bing is to send a first round pick & maybe a player that is keen for greater opportunity. Send DMac & tell him it’s GC or 3 years at Sandy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top