List Mgmt. 2019 Trade Thread - Part II

[Mowman]

If he wants to come to us , pick 5 gets it done

Really rather take pick 5 to the draft. I think lol
But if thats what it takes so be it

 

[plugger66]

If he wants to come to us , pick 5 gets it done

It’s to much. Far to much.

 

[Mikka84]

I don’t really believe the noise, but if Ollie Wines is available, you simply have to chase him. Had a year to forget, but we forget quickly how good he is. Still young, only 24.

 

[Premium]

It’s to much. Far to much.

yes it is , I'd rather Crouch but when a player like Hill names you - take it , maybe attempt adding something to the mix so we still have a hand in the draft.
I don't know.

 

[Premium]

I don’t really believe the noise, but if Ollie Wines is available, you simply have to chase him. Had a year to forget, but we forget quickly how good he is. Still young, only 24.

Totally agree - Wines is a star - wait till next year

 

[plugger66]

yes it is , I'd rather Crouch but when a player like Hill names you - take it , maybe attempt adding something to the mix so we still have a hand in the draft.
I don't know.

We have to add something. That is an ordinary deal. Crouch suits us so much better.

 

[VDS66]

It’s to much. Far to much.

too too

 

[Mowman]

I don’t really believe the noise, but if Ollie Wines is available, you simply have to chase him. Had a year to forget, but we forget quickly how good he is. Still young, only 24.

Is he an A grader ? What have his better years been like ?

 

[VDS66]

I don’t really believe the noise, but if Ollie Wines is available, you simply have to chase him. Had a year to forget, but we forget quickly how good he is. Still young, only 24.

Just a hunch..

This year's first for Hill.

Next year's might go for Crouch or Wines if possible.

If not, we go hard at Bing.

If Hill has committed, it would be poor form to drop him in favour of Wines IMO.

So we take him regardless.

Everything else is up in the air.

 

[Keg on legs]

too too

Too for twenty too Richie

 

[Mikka84]

Just a hunch..

This year's first for Hill.

Next year's might go for Crouch or Wines if possible.

If not, we go hard at Bing.

If Hill has committed, it would be poor form to drop him in favour of Wines IMO.

So we take him regardless.

Everything else is up in the air.

Oh, 100% taking Hill this year. You never pass up an opportunity from an A grade player that has shown commitment to join. He’s been number 1 target for weeks as you know. He’ll help us win games next year and attract more players then. Was just if we could structure a deal on top of Hill this year.

 

[Mikka84]

Is he an A grader ? What have his better years been like ?

Wines absolutely an A grader. Inside bull that runs all day.

 

[tomjoad]

View attachment 730618

That is f*cking hilarious.

 

[VDS66]

Oh, 100% taking Hill this year. You never pass up an opportunity from an A grade player that has shown commitment to join. He’s been number 1 target for weeks as you know. He’ll help us win games next year and attract more players then. Was just if we could structure a deal on top of Hill this year.

You can call me Derryn if you want...

 

[VDS66]

Too for twenty too Richie

Marvellous...

 

[Keg on legs]

That is f*cking hilarious.

Wish i could claim at as my own creation but just like my jokes I stole it from someone else

 

[Mikka84]

You can call me Derryn if you want...

 

[Premium]

Wines absolutely an A grader. Inside bull that runs all day.

2019 - 24.6
2018 - 26.1
2017 - 27.3
2016 - 26.2
2015 - 24.5
2014 - 24.4
2013 - 18.8 - possessions / first season played 24 games

Can turn a game on his own - smashes packs and opens up play - current Ports captain so will come at high price.

 

[VDS66]

View attachment 730892

You look stunning in that dress BTW...

 

[Saintos The ITK]

Lose Stuvvy get Constable
Split pick 5 get Hill and Bing
Cogs fa
Done dinner
Premiers 2020 and beyond

 

[Keg on legs]

And now ladies and gentlemen, allow me to unveil the 2021 AFL Premiers, the St Kilda Football Club.

Geary Battle Webster

Clark Bing Wilkie

Billings Crouch Hill

Gresham Ming Hind

Lonie Bruce Membrey


Roma Wines Hanners


Bytel Coffield Steele White ( )

 

[The Cavalry]

Any interest in Sier, showed something last finals series and I really rated him.

 

[Mikka84]

You look stunning in that dress BTW...

Thanks. I originally thought it was a bit hugging. Whites not a slimming colour you know.

 

[x_les_x]

Sorry for the intrusion i just watched the video of sam rowe but was more interested in ex port fella Logan Austin. He looked real promising with us and had a real purple patch against north/collingwood a few years back. I think he moved to be closer to Jack Steele. Question is he hadnt played an AFL game this year where is he at? injured, poor form or potential delistee?

 

[Parkysp]

Yep and I guess my point stands that extremely highly rated talls often don't make it, if we're referencing the 2006 draft then the moral would be - go for mids with your early picks.

Patton, Boyd, McCartin, Schache - two of which we often talked about trading in with a first rounder, another we used the #1 pick.

It was only 5 years ago that we burnt 2 first rounders chasing this dream.

Proceed with caution IMO.

Very true and agree but my point is the one not already with us we have seen an initial body of work for that looks very promising.