List Mgmt. 2020 Trade and List Management Thread II

[giantroo]

He may have been pushed out because he is extremely bad at football

And the Saints netted a second and third round pick. And we'll be lucky to get a second for Brown?

 

[Flawed Genius]

What are folks thoughts on trading pick 2 & Brown for pick 6 & 7?

I reckon it's worth serious consideration, if Phillips dropping down the order is the expectation from the clubs.

6, 7, 9 & 25 to the draft.

That's possibly Phillips + Bruhn/Henry + Cox/Reid

I am gun shy on getting rid of #2. It's the equal highest pick we've ever had. I want to take it to the draft and pick a great young player with it. I don't know if quantity is greater than quality in this case, even if you are getting three top 10 picks

 

[Flawed Genius]

And the Saints netted a second and third round pick. And we'll be lucky to get a second for Brown?

Difference of course being that Bruce (not to my memory at least) wasn't publicly pushed off a cliff by his club a month before the trade period actually started

 

[New_Roo]

So Saad is worth Pick 7 as a nice to have HB flanker from a non finals team but Brown isn’t worth anything inside pick 30 after kicking more goals than anyone in the three years pre Covid?

Riiiiiight.

It doesn't say he is worth pick 7, says worth first rounder and 7 is the only one they have.... so they need to go and split it somewhere


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Snake_Baker]

And the Saints netted a second and third round pick. And we'll be lucky to get a second for Brown?

The murky factor is the cost of Ben's contract and the viable field of candidates at that price.

 

[scooby1279]

Who do we blame if we seriously get a shit return for Brown? Which it looks like it may be heading that way.

 

[Only Forwards]

He may have been pushed out because he is extremely bad at football

Except against 1 side in particular.

then the man is a giant.

 

[Snake_Baker]

Who do we blame if we seriously get a sh*t return for Brown? Which it looks like it may be heading that way.

This "showing our hand" stuff has been overblown.

Sooner or later clubs will have known that Ben was available for a pricey contract.

 

[bazza10 devils]

And the Saints netted a second and third round pick. And we'll be lucky to get a second for Brown?

Why don’t north say to adel we will pay crouch enough to get them band 1 we get crouch and they give us pick one we get McDonald then they get our picks 2 and get pick 3 Comp done

 

[the flying ham]

Was Josh Bruce pushed out by the Saints?


Josh Bruce's move to the Western Bulldogs has been described as "an absolute bargain" after a last-minute trade on Wednesday night. Bruce will move from St Kilda to the Bulldogs in exchange for picks No. 32 and 51.

He was not well liked by staff or players and they wanted him gone.

On SM-G950F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[WD Roo]

Who do we blame if we seriously get a sh*t return for Brown? Which it looks like it may be heading that way.

I have said it before Brady wasn't going to have the wool pulled over his eyes with Rama extorting more money for BB. The other clubs have seen this as well. What Rama hasn't factored into his plan is that BB may have to go to the draft, which means he will have to accept whatever deal he is given, which could be a hell of a lot less than what NM was offering in the first place. In this environment, this is an absolute balls up by Rama.

 

[giantroo]

Josh Bruce says St Kilda weren’t looking to extend his contract beyond 2020, which led to him looking away from the club and eventually securing a move to the Western Bulldogs.

The security of a long-term contract was something St Kilda couldn’t guarantee the 27-year-old which is ultimately the reason he opted to depart Moorabbin for The Kennel.

“They (St Kilda) weren’t necessarily open to trading me, but they weren’t also looking to extend my contract which was something that I was obviously really keen to do,” Bruce told SEN’s Time On.

The determining factor that led to Josh Bruce’s St Kilda departure

Bruce joined the Western Bulldogs late in the trade period.

www.sen.com.au

 

[giantroo]

I have said it before Brady wasn't going to have the wool pulled over his eyes with Rama extorting more money for BB. The other clubs have seen this as well. What Rama hasn't factored into his plan is that BB may have to go to the draft, which means he will have to accept whatever deal he is given, which could be a hell of a lot less than what NM was offering in the first place. In this environment, this is an absolute balls up by Rama.

This is spot on.

 

[scooby1279]

I have said it before Brady wasn't going to have the wool pulled over his eyes with Rama extorting more money for BB. The other clubs have seen this as well. What Rama hasn't factored into his plan is that BB may have to go to the draft, which means he will have to accept whatever deal he is given, which could be a hell of a lot less than what NM was offering in the first place. In this environment, this is an absolute balls up by Rama.

Yes i agree but now Brown is out the door i couldn't care less what Brown's contract may or may not be, i am concerned for what we will get for him.

 

[Clarke is King]

Who do we blame if we seriously get a sh*t return for Brown? Which it looks like it may be heading that way.

We blame the mods.

 

[Snake_Baker]

Why don’t north say to adel we will pay crouch enough to get them band 1 we get crouch and they give us pick one we get McDonald then they get our picks 2 and get pick 3 Comp done

Maybe we don't want McDonald?

 

[bazza10 devils]

Then we put together pick 9 hope say pick 10 for brown and we give up pick 25 and higgings to cats for pick 13 sopicks 9 /10/13. For Sydney pick 4

 

[scooby1279]

This "showing our hand" stuff has been overblown.

Sooner or later clubs will have known that Ben was available for a pricey contract.

To an extend yes but we are going to get shafted for one of the better forwards in the game.

 

[Snake_Baker]

To an extend yes but we are going to get shafted for one of the better forwards in the game.

Mate, if they're going to keep playing him in the goals square dropping the ball on his head, then he's not as valuable to us either.

It's not my preferred way to go about things, but that's how it's looking.

 

[Passmore]

Okay, the fact that they are an old list also tells me that they would shoehorn anything they saw as capable talent on their list in to their starting 22, yet at 21 years of age thay haven't included Constable, nor are they looking to consider him as an option for the foreseeable future.

It's not as if it's a physical development thing either, he's bigger than Selwood, Stevens and Simpson.

Beware the overhyped Geelong reserves player.

Not saying I wouldn't take him, but given he went in the 30's in his draft, can't crack more than a sniff after 3 years and they are looking to bring in other mids when they could play him......it'd be a 4th round trade for mine.

 

[scooby1279]

Maybe we don't want McDonald?

early reports that we were interested but then denied we have zero interest. (thank ****)

 

[bazza10 devils]

Maybe we don't want McDonald?

I think we might

 

[Le Grille]

early reports that we were interested but then denied we have zero interest. (thank fu**)

Logan not Tom


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[WD Roo]

Yes i agree but now Brown is out the door i couldn't care less what Brown's contract may or may not be, i am concerned for what we will get for him.

That's a risk that Brady will have considered, it wouldn't have been a blatant off the cuff conversation.

 

[bazza10 devils]

Logan not Tom


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Logan