List Mgmt. 2020 Trade Thread - Part III

[BrutThough]

They don't need Treloar though Bailey Smith

6

Bailey Smith

Age

23

Ht

185cm

Wt

86kg

Pos.

M/F

Career

Season

Last 5

D

18.3

5star

K

8.5

3star

HB

9.8

5star

M

2.3

2star

T

3.8

5star

CL

2.7

4star

D

19.8

5star

K

9.6

4star

HB

10.2

5star

M

1.8

2star

T

3.2

4star

CL

3.2

4star

D

14.8

4star

K

7.6

3star

HB

7.2

5star

M

2.0

3star

T

3.4

5star

CL

1.6

4star

is a younger version and still have too many mids. They should ask for Draper and pick 6 and the VFL ruck we wanted last year.

They should ask for the future first instead.

Huge chance they finish bottom 4 and the pick won't be affected by their NGA bid

 

[Therealsaint]

If the dogs are smart. Ask for 2 first rounders in 2021.

they can land Treloar without burning a first this year. But gives them huge currency to get further deals done next year

Hope not,I won't treloar

 

[Moquo]

Think there's two. One definitely up the road from me.

Actually maybe that's Harold Holt.

Anyway can go any swimming pool

Harold Holt no go

 

[Sainter88]

Does he even have to?

I was under the impression FA you had to nominate, for trading you can simply say you want to be traded to another club but it’s not nominating

 

[Mat Mann]

Wait for it... wait.. .for it


97 will come up

your about 300 pages to late on that one

 

[HunterClarksHeadband]

Get the feeling this trade season I'll be more interested to see who we trade out rather than trade in.. think it'll be a lot more noise for the outs than the ins haha.

 

[Mstr Strokesman]

Weak and shallow???

Mate, they invented the POWER STANCE.

View attachment 1002504

Flamingo heads would be very funny too.

 

[austinnn]

I'd say Higgins tells RFC he wants to be a Saint, RFC open negotiations with us, we try to sell our fringe players to get the picks that will satisfy and Jacks our boy. I'd say Lonie will get done first, then Higgins with his pick plus one of our late ones. Might even be a three way.

Oh all right...

 

[Sarcoidevo]

The real story in these trade threads is how the Flamer has missioned himself to make out that he is one step ahead of the action before it unfolds.

I applaud his commitment

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Get the feeling this trade season I'll be more interested to see who we trade out rather than trade in.. think it'll be a lot more noise for the outs than the ins haha.

You're one of those who think players gone will make us better?

 

[Sainter88]

I'd say Higgins tells RFC he wants to be a Saint, RFC open negotiations with us, we try to sell our fringe players to get the picks that will satisfy and Jacks our boy. I'd say Lonie will get done first, then Higgins with his pick plus one of our late ones. Might even be a three way.

Oh all right...

Still love this one

 

[HunterClarksHeadband]

You're one of those who think players gone will make us better?

Just expressing that I'm curious to see who we trade out bruz, that's all

 

[dogs105]

Do you think St Kilda waited until Sunday to get an overlap with the trade period? If the clubs have to agree on a trade, creating 815 points out of nothing with the compo would help.

Something like:

Adelaide trade 22 and 49 to St Kilda for 17 and next years 2nd and 3rd

Adelaide take 23 compo. ST kilda get Crouch.

Adelaide lose Crouch and 49. Gain 17 and next years second and 3rd

St Kilda pay next years second and 3rd and a five pick downgrade for Crouch and 49.

If saints finish 8th say, picks 29 and 47 next year.

Adelaide out: crouch and 1132 points
In: 2780 points

St Kilda out: 1965 points
St Kilda in : Crouch and 1132 points

Adelaide receive net 1648 points - pick 7 for crouch

St Kilda pay net 833 points - pick 22 for crouch

Might look complicated, but St Kilda pay ~22 for Crouch, with upside if you finish higher than 8th.

 

[SaltnVinegar]

If Carlisle goes, who replaces him? Carlisle is a very imposing presence in our backline.

 

[triggering bro]

Do you think St Kilda waited until Sunday to get an overlap with the trade period? If the clubs have to agree on a trade, creating 815 points out of nothing with the compo would help.

Something like:

Adelaide trade 22 and 49 to St Kilda for 17 and next years 2nd and 3rd

Adelaide take 23 compo. ST kilda get Crouch.

Adelaide lose Crouch and 49. Gain 17 and next years second and 3rd

St Kilda pay next years second and 3rd and a five pick downgrade for Crouch and 49.

If saints finish 8th say, picks 29 and 47 next year.

Adelaide out: crouch and 1132 points
In: 2780 points

St Kilda out: 1965 points
St Kilda in : Crouch and 1132 points

Adelaide receive net 1648 points - pick 7 for crouch

St Kilda pay net 833 points - pick 22 for crouch

Might look complicated, but St Kilda pay ~22 for Crouch, with upside if you finish higher than 8th.

The AFL would not approve such trade. The points need to be closer to equal. Something like 17 & 65 for 22 & 50 might work if that’s part of the arrangement where Adel don’t match.

 

[BrutThough]

Do you think St Kilda waited until Sunday to get an overlap with the trade period? If the clubs have to agree on a trade, creating 815 points out of nothing with the compo would help.

Something like:

Adelaide trade 22 and 49 to St Kilda for 17 and next years 2nd and 3rd

Adelaide take 23 compo. ST kilda get Crouch.

Adelaide lose Crouch and 49. Gain 17 and next years second and 3rd

St Kilda pay next years second and 3rd and a five pick downgrade for Crouch and 49.

If saints finish 8th say, picks 29 and 47 next year.

Adelaide out: crouch and 1132 points
In: 2780 points

St Kilda out: 1965 points
St Kilda in : Crouch and 1132 points

Adelaide receive net 1648 points - pick 7 for crouch

St Kilda pay net 833 points - pick 22 for crouch

Might look complicated, but St Kilda pay ~22 for Crouch, with upside if you finish higher than 8th.

Lethlean has indicated that we aren't interested in trading for Crouch and our first pick is off limits.

With that in mind, why would we then trade our first rounder and then out of next years draft for a player we have said we dont want to trade for?

 

[Barrels]

Who ate all the pies?

It was iso, I needed the money, and some people pay to watch it, OK?!

 

[dogs105]

The AFL would not approve such trade. The points need to be closer to equal. Something like 17 & 65 for 22 & 50 might work if that’s part of the arrangement where Adel don’t match.

Why? We might expect you to finish 1st next year.

 

[lewdogs]

We got him.

Mate please stop. You have NFI if Crows have matched but you're taking a punt on a very likely outcome that we get Crouch. Just stop.

 

[gringo2011]

Draper is the VFL ruck we wanted

It is too, I meant Ridley, I must have had it in my subconscious and done the switch.

 

[dogs105]

Lethlean has indicated that we aren't interested in trading for Crouch and our first pick is off limits.

With that in mind, why would we then trade our first rounder and then out of next years draft for a player we have said we dont want to trade for?

You'd have a 1st rounder in both drafts with this deal. Just a thought anyway.

 

[triggering bro]

Why? We might expect you to finish 1st next year.

Read your trade proposal back to yourself aloud & ask yourself if it sounds like a fair & reasonable trade.

 

[BrutThough]

You'd have a 1st rounder in both drafts with this deal. Just a thought anyway.

Pick 22 is a 2nd round pick, so that would prevent us from doing anything with our first round pick next year.

If a trade is happening between the clubs, it will likely have to include a player because we don't have the picks to work.

 

[gringo2011]

Why? We might expect you to finish 1st next year.

Now there is one Crows poster we don't find irritating any more.

 

[Captain Paddy]

Do you think St Kilda waited until Sunday to get an overlap with the trade period? If the clubs have to agree on a trade, creating 815 points out of nothing with the compo would help.

Something like:

Adelaide trade 22 and 49 to St Kilda for 17 and next years 2nd and 3rd

Adelaide take 23 compo. ST kilda get Crouch.

Adelaide lose Crouch and 49. Gain 17 and next years second and 3rd

St Kilda pay next years second and 3rd and a five pick downgrade for Crouch and 49.

If saints finish 8th say, picks 29 and 47 next year.

Adelaide out: crouch and 1132 points
In: 2780 points

St Kilda out: 1965 points
St Kilda in : Crouch and 1132 points

Adelaide receive net 1648 points - pick 7 for crouch

St Kilda pay net 833 points - pick 22 for crouch

Might look complicated, but St Kilda pay ~22 for Crouch, with upside if you finish higher than 8th.