Game Day 2021 Finals Matchday Supernova End of days thread

Who will you be barracking for in the grand final?


  • Total voters
    31
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

And here I was thinking you’d pick him up for calling Clurey a KPD.
You know basic football knowledge and all…
What? I already said Clurey isn't a KPD, read my other posts and why their "need" is actually a KPD and not Dawson. That post was more about Howard I wanted to respond too and Port Power not losing players they wanted to keep.
 
What? I already said Clurey isn't a KPD, read my other posts and why their "need" is actually a KPD and not Dawson. That post was more about Howard I wanted to respond too and Port Power not losing players they wanted to keep.
That’s the problem, he is a KPD for them. I’m not sure why you’d think otherwise.
 
That’s the problem, he is a KPD for them. I’m not sure why you’d think otherwise.
No they don't, why do you think they went and got Aliir who is 3cm taller and then didn't play Clurey in place of McKenzie (you seriously think McKenzie is a KPD you really have no football knowledge). Clurey got exposed on tall forward in the finals last year.
 
No they don't, why do you think they went and got Aliir who is 3cm taller and then didn't play Clurey in place of McKenzie (you seriously think McKenzie is a KPD you really have no football knowledge). Clurey got exposed on tall forward in the finals last year.
So you even defeat your own argument.
Once again your turning your opinion of him being a poor defender into a fact that he’s not a KPD.
Even port think so.
ED3A0344-4F1B-4EAA-B0DB-FCABE0DBCF66.jpeg
 
So you even defeat your own argument.
Once again your turning your opinion of him being a poor defender into a fact that he’s not a KPD.
Even port think so.
View attachment 1234122
You really lack football knowledge.....this call is worst than what Sanders have every posted, 193cm aren't KPD. Go to their forum and say Clurey is a KPD.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

The trade I struggle to understand is letting Dougal Howard make his way to St Kilda.

To leave Jonas (1.88m), McKenzie (1.91m) and Clurey (1.93m) as your KPDs was a really strange list management decision which is coming back to bite them. They simply cannot handle a forward line with 2-3 talls, particularly one getting good supply.
Its got to do with Wines they were Best Uber Mates buddies until something happened I was told by some pear supporters
 
You really lack football knowledge.....this call is worst than what Sanders have every posted, 193cm aren't KPD. Go to their forum and say Clurey is a KPD.
You’re a genuine idiot.
The All Australian Full back is 193cm.
So you reckon before Aliir, port didn’t play a key defender?
Height isn’t everything.
 
You really lack football knowledge.....this call is worst than what Sanders have every posted, 193cm aren't KPD. Go to their forum and say Clurey is a KPD.
Why would I need to go there, PAFC have him
listed as that and everyone knows that’s what he is.
Whether he is a good one or not is a completely different argument.
He’s play on Tex plenty of times, but he’s not a key defender that’s for sure.
 
There are people in the autopsy thread who think Port lost because the ball didn't bounce their way. 🤣
To be fair they aren't wrong. Just missing a bit of pretty important context.

Like who was marking and kicking it beforehand
 
You’re a genuine idiot.
The All Australian Full back is 193cm.
So you reckon before Aliir, port didn’t play a key defender?
Height isn’t everything.
May is unique in that he can play one on one and as an intercepting defender. Clurey can't play one on one on the taller forward, why do you think they got Aliir? No doubt height isn't everything but the taller you are as a defender the better chance you have playing on the taller forward, hence you need basic football knowledge about these things.
 
No they don't, why do you think they went and got Aliir who is 3cm taller and then didn't play Clurey in place of McKenzie (you seriously think McKenzie is a KPD you really have no football knowledge). Clurey got exposed on tall forward in the finals last year.
McKenzie played last night as a key defender & Clurey has played pretty much all of his games as a key defender.

The fact they are not good enough as key defenders is another issue, but to claim they have not playing as key defenders really goes to show your limited understanding of the game... & why many on this forum get frustrated by many of your posts being inaccurate.
 
Why would I need to go there, PAFC have him
listed as that and everyone knows that’s what he is.
Whether he is a good one or not is a completely different argument.
He’s play on Tex plenty of times, but he’s not a key defender that’s for sure.
So you can gain knowledge of how Clurey plays.
 
McKenzie played last night as a key defender & Clurey has played pretty much of of his games as a key defender.

The fact they are not good enough as key defenders is another issue, but to claim they have not playing as key defenders really goes to show your limited understanding of the game... & why many on this forum get frustrated by many of your posts being inaccurate.
KPD on the tallest forward, not a tall defender on tall forward.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Game Day 2021 Finals Matchday Supernova End of days thread

Back
Top