But the club themselves could rate that player 15-25, but still feel pressured to take them early because of our KPF deficiency.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. 2021 Young Talent Time
- Thread starter Purple_Turtle
- Start date
- Tagged users None
But the club themselves could rate that player 15-25, but still feel pressured to take them early because of our KPF deficiency.
Steven Hill Squad sounds like a great initiative.
We seem to have our fingers in a few pies in this state.
Here’s hoping the intel pays off.
We seem to have our fingers in a few pies in this state.
Here’s hoping the intel pays off.
Pls explain.
Check out the Dockers website.
Wobbly Punt
All Australian
- Feb 24, 2020
- 654
- 2,848
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
I’ve been lucky enough to see a few of the boys we might grab a few times watching my nephew play colts and PSA etc the last couple of years. I’ve seen each of the guys below at least 4 times live, some more.
I say this because I’ve formed a view on the floor/ceiling comparisons that me and my brother have come up with.
With that, here’s my worthless opinion (floor/ceiling);
Erasmus - Blakely/Petracca
Amiss - Tony Notte/J Reiwoldt
Johnson - Dal Santo/Mundy
JVR - M.McGovern/Pavlich
Williams - Bandy/Lobb+
Hough - McManus/McLuggage
Dittmar - Tom Swift/Brock McLean
Motlop - Dahlhaus/Papley
Benning - Strnadica/Marshall
My nephew - Fyfe/Leigh Matthews
I’ve only listed those of likely interest to Freo at our picks and who I’ve seen a min 3 times.
If it were me I’d go Johnson, JVR with 6 & 8 and see what happens with 19 at the end of night 1.
I’d do this knowing that Erasmus will likely be very, very bloody good and hoping like hell he’s already gone by our pick or goes before the clowns up the road get their pick.
I say this because I’ve formed a view on the floor/ceiling comparisons that me and my brother have come up with.
With that, here’s my worthless opinion (floor/ceiling);
Erasmus - Blakely/Petracca
Amiss - Tony Notte/J Reiwoldt
Johnson - Dal Santo/Mundy
JVR - M.McGovern/Pavlich
Williams - Bandy/Lobb+
Hough - McManus/McLuggage
Dittmar - Tom Swift/Brock McLean
Motlop - Dahlhaus/Papley
Benning - Strnadica/Marshall
My nephew - Fyfe/Leigh Matthews
I’ve only listed those of likely interest to Freo at our picks and who I’ve seen a min 3 times.
If it were me I’d go Johnson, JVR with 6 & 8 and see what happens with 19 at the end of night 1.
I’d do this knowing that Erasmus will likely be very, very bloody good and hoping like hell he’s already gone by our pick or goes before the clowns up the road get their pick.
Pretty accurate and interesting comparisons. Erasmus is going to be hard to match as a forward, and in time play midfield minutes.I’ve been lucky enough to see a few of the boys we might grab a few times watching my nephew play colts and PSA etc the last couple of years. I’ve seen each of the guys below at least 4 times live, some more.
I say this because I’ve formed a view on the floor/ceiling comparisons that me and my brother have come up with.
With that, here’s my worthless opinion (floor/ceiling);
Erasmus - Blakely/Petracca
Amiss - Tony Notte/J Reiwoldt
Johnson - Dal Santo/Mundy
JVR - M.McGovern/Pavlich
Williams - Bandy/Lobb+
Hough - McManus/McLuggage
Dittmar - Tom Swift/Brock McLean
Motlop - Dahlhaus/Papley
Benning - Strnadica/Marshall
My nephew - Fyfe/Leigh Matthews
I’ve only listed those of likely interest to Freo at our picks and who I’ve seen a min 3 times.
If it were me I’d go Johnson, JVR with 6 & 8 and see what happens with 19 at the end of night 1.
I’d do this knowing that Erasmus will likely be very, very bloody good and hoping like hell he’s already gone by our pick or goes before the clowns up the road get their pick.
Only one missing is Bazzo, thoughts?
Wobbly Punt
All Australian
- Feb 24, 2020
- 654
- 2,848
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
I actually started with Swift as his ceiling but my brother wouldn’t cop that!
It’s my own bias towards players who can use the ball. He’s a great kid and great at getting the ball. I just think he’s very blinkered rather than thoughtful and wasteful when he should be precise but I don’t think he has the skills to be precise.
Wobbly Punt
All Australian
- Feb 24, 2020
- 654
- 2,848
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
I’ve only seen the Bazzo lad twice so won’t offer any thoughts other than to say he makes a very good first impression as a player.
Purpellian Anchor
Purple Admiralty
gee that would be something...four west Aussies under pick 13. Unlikely though even two given the overall talent available.
On flip side Johnson - Del Santo/Mundy
Johnson should be going at pick 2.
Interesting analysis Wobbly. I say we select your nephew at pick 19 - it around the pick Fyfe was selected.
I saw Erasmus play for Hale and it is etched in my brain and hence I want him wearing purple.
I saw Bazzo quite a few times at PSA level for Guildford and if you were using your range of players they remind you of / could develop it would be somewhere between .....Polak / Rance ?
SHill Shall
Club Legend
It’s not something that comes about from our instigation. Only from GWS’s, and that presumably because they somehow conclude they can benefit by getting a better 2nd pick while still claiming their preferred first. If it was our idea there’s zero chance.
Yes and it only works if the clubs know who the other clubs are taking. Which apparently they do for the first 10 or so at least
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I really think it will come down to Gold Coast and whether GWS are willing let Callaghan go to Gold Coast and whether GWS are comfortable picking up Gibcus /Andrew and being rewarded with a F2 and change in the process. I really doubt Adelaide have the draft capital to make it happen and even then there is no guarantee they get their preferred man because Gold Coast are dire need of key position backs and ruck/forward.
We are very low chance and it would only be because GWS think there is great value in having pick 10 instead of 15. We have nothing else to offer other than wait till the bid matching at 2 and 3 and see pick 61 move up to around 55.
https://www.sen.com.au/news/2021/09/29/sheehans-two-smokeys-in-this-years-national-draft/ kevin Sheehan's 2 smokeys and he put them on par with JHF and Daicos. And Knightmare picked both of them for us in his phantom draft.Sheehan says Brown can play half forward.. then I am all for it.
On SM-A205YN using BigFooty.com mobile app
On SM-A205YN using BigFooty.com mobile app
I don’t get the lack of love for Bazzo.
Swans win the flag with Bazzo was the best player on the team all year.
In SA game, he destroyed the SA tall forwards.
We have enough key backs and shouldn’t draft him but another club should look at him in the late first round.
Swans win the flag with Bazzo was the best player on the team all year.
In SA game, he destroyed the SA tall forwards.
We have enough key backs and shouldn’t draft him but another club should look at him in the late first round.
He will be picked by WC to replace McNugget
Basso would be great to get, but we don’t have enough spare list spaces.
Bailey Banfield should not have been resigned (if at all) until after the trade period.
Now we will have to let a number of possible guns go elsewhere.
- Jul 13, 2012
- 1,948
- 3,989
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Some different Video of Rachele.
I see a fair bit of Medhurst in the way he plays.
I see a fair bit of Medhurst in the way he plays.
Sorry I don’t get how Bailey Banfield on the rookie list in any way impacts our ability to select Bazzo.
We are a very good chance to select Bazzo or Williams if we downgrade our pick 21. A club like Richmond who have 26,27,28 would be one option who may jump at a slider and offer one of their two F2nds along with say 27 or 28 and then Bazzo or Williams will come into play. He has played some good games forward with Guildford, but his best across all formats has been at CHB.
Baily Banfield is taking up a rookie list spot. Bazzo will be long gone before the rookie list. We currently have 5 list spots available (not incl. Cat-b). We will likely go 4+1 but we will have the option of passing or trading our last pick which is currently pick 69. Bailey Banfield aside if Sumich comes out and says Bazzo is a big sook and no one should touch him and he is still available at 69 (which would have likely pushed up into the 50’s) then we can still add him as fifth selection in the ND and go without a live selection in the Rookie Draft. Again I have zero idea how Bailey Banfield prevents us selecting Bazzo with either of our third fourth or even fifth ND selections.
In saying all this I’m not a massive advocate for Bailey Banfield just wondering how you came to that conclusion.
