Snuffaluphagus
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 10, 2015
- 25,399
- 87,997
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Thanks for making this an awesome trade period peeps. Will be locking this thread later tonight
Game Day 2022 Trade Period Match Thread
- Thread starter freo_leo29
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Except when a side decides to go man on man and actually defend Cox, then the only other option is to go long to Darcy and 6 people jumping at the footy. Unfortunately Sean just doesn't win enough of those contests and it's unfair to expect him to even when its clearly not working. The Collingwood game was a great example of how predictable we are at kick ins
Having Jackson on the otherside of the field and possibly Corbett as options makes us less predictable and harder to defend against. It will draw defenders away from Sean and create more even contests across the defensive 50 that we might actuallywin rather than turning it over allowing the opposition repeat inside 50s.
- Dec 6, 2020
- 3,687
- 7,828
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Regardless of the Logue situation, Freo were never going to trade Lobb for a 3rd round pick. Reckon Young has misled the dogs on that front, the way he misled GWS last year. The whole thing is very poorly put together. If Lobb really wanted to get to Victoria next year, surely Young would be shopping him around to all the Victoria teams, not just the dogs.
If you're going to make accusations let's at least lay all the cards out there hey? Below is my '5 hours' of insults.
Context - I had an overly optimistic view towards games. You were overly negative. You thought we'd lose to Brisbane by 50. I called you out before and after the result. You then kept having a go at me on various threads after the game. I simply PM'd you as to not clog the threads with back and forth. You may not have replied to my PMs, but it didn't stop you from still having a go at me on threads at that time. My messages via PM would make that seem clear to anyone with a brain... not 5 hours of insults as you allege.
Yep that's me........offended when my team wins, not happy, but offended, you got me sir.
Let's get back on topic before you inbox me again all night, would you trade Lobb under any circumstances? Personally I wouldn't
That's one incredibly inaccurate and biased side of the story, but sure.
I'm happy you felt the need to share your messages with me, doesn't exactly paint you in a good light.....
So again, would you like to get back on topic?
Haha so the dogs are only offering a third round pick for Lobb?!
Bit of a reality check for a lot of posters around here.
30 year old hit and miss key forwards don’t go for first round picks.
As was the case all along, Lobb is worth about pick 29, if he was OOC.
Having a year to run probably gets his value up to around pick 25.
That’s a fair valuation without purple tinted glasses on. Talk of first rounders or future firsts is just wishful thinking. The dogs aren’t that silly. The fact that they are being absolutely pantsed by brisbane in the Dunkley negotiations doesn’t help us either.
We could of course keep him and lose him for a token pick in the 50s next year. I still think he will be gone on Wednesday night but I guess we’ll see what happens.
Bit of a reality check for a lot of posters around here.
30 year old hit and miss key forwards don’t go for first round picks.
As was the case all along, Lobb is worth about pick 29, if he was OOC.
Having a year to run probably gets his value up to around pick 25.
That’s a fair valuation without purple tinted glasses on. Talk of first rounders or future firsts is just wishful thinking. The dogs aren’t that silly. The fact that they are being absolutely pantsed by brisbane in the Dunkley negotiations doesn’t help us either.
We could of course keep him and lose him for a token pick in the 50s next year. I still think he will be gone on Wednesday night but I guess we’ll see what happens.
Darcy Jones is 175cm and 63kg. He’d have to be next level elite to even be considered in the second round tbh.
Some on here would say Thorne from Peel is pretty damn good at footy yet he’s a similar height and weight to Jones and AFL clubs never show any interest.
Some on here would say Thorne from Peel is pretty damn good at footy yet he’s a similar height and weight to Jones and AFL clubs never show any interest.
You brought up the '5 hours of PM' comments. I was just laying out the facts of the 'All night PMs'. There's 3!
I never said that my messages were pleasant. There's clearly a sarcastic tone. Doesn't change the fact you got offended when we beat Brisbane and came after me in different threads because I said something along the lines of 'OUT - supporters calling 50 point losses'. It was literally something like that, that triggered you.
But, ok. Back on topic. Keep Lobb. Use the F2 to pick up anyone... they will be a better investment than the player that left for that compensation...
Wouldn't call it a reality check, it's the reality of contracts.
Dogs aren't going to get fair value because Dunkley is out of contract. Same reason GC are asking for a second round not best 22 but contracted Sharp.
Same reason we want overs for a contracted Lobb. We're not being unreasonable, we're playing business
Contracted it not they aren’t going to pay much in draft capital for a guy that will do well to play 60 more AFL games.
They have Bruce, JUH, Darcy and Naughton as forward options.
So they don’t need him enough to give up half the bounty from Dunkley, one of the best mids in the league.
- Apr 25, 2011
- 8,056
- 18,911
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
'He ran 7.70 seconds in the agility test at Margaret Court Arena, eclipsing the previous record held by former Fremantle star Stephen Hill, who ran 7.77 seconds in 2008.
Jones was also the joint winner of the standing vertical jumps test, leaping 75cm'
Pretty impressive for a little fella.
As Lobb is in contract, we’re not obliged to trade him, right? If he decided to sit out next year, we would still be paying his contract to do nothing?
Just why would you pick a club that doesn’t need you? Why not bombers or saints?
He won't sit out a year, Lobb wants to get paid more than anything, his next contract will be his last and if he doesn't play he will be getting sweet **** all offers from clubs.
Assuming they get done we'll have a win on the Lobb and Meek deals. We're not getting a win on the Jackson deal if we're currently offering 2 x first rounders and Melbourne has said no thanks. IMO it'll be 13 +F1 + F2 (Hawthorn for Meek) for Jackson and a pick around 40 this year.
I like the look of old ‘potato’ Keeler off limited research
Dunno why he’s so low
Looks like he’s in thilthorpe kind of areas too me
Van_Dyke
Moderator
- Moderator
- #4,346
Six clubs, 14 picks, three players: The mega trade AFL knocked back
The full details of a proposed mega trade involving six clubs that fell through on Saturday when the AFL declined to give Port Adelaide an exemption
www.afl.com.au
PROPOSED MEGA DEAL DETAILS
NORTH MELBOURNE
Trade out: Jason Horne-Francis, pick No.1, 2023 third-round pick (tied to Fremantle)
Trade in: Picks No.2, 3, 33, 53, 2023 future first-round pick (tied to Port Adelaide)
PORT ADELAIDE
Trade out: Picks No.8, 33, 43, 53, 2023 first-round pick
Trade in: Jason Horne-Francis, Junior Rioli, pick No.36
WEST COAST
Trade out: Junior Rioli, picks No.2, 40
Trade in: Picks No.8, 12, 2023 second-round pick (tied to Port Adelaide), 2023 third-round pick (tied to Fremantle)
GREATER WESTERN SYDNEY
Trade out: Picks No.3, 12
Trade in: Pick No.1
BRISBANE
Trade out: Pick No.36
Trade in: Jack Gunston, pick No.43
HAWTHORN
Trade in: Pick No.40
Trade out: Jack Gunsto
If we trade our F1 for Jackson and get the Bulldogs F1 for Lobb surely we keep it? The Dogs limped into the 8 this year and their B&F winner wants out. That could easily end up being a top ten pick in 2023.
How did he do in the 40 ?
If he can jump , cut and get out of the blocks he’s some sort of a chance
Got some intel on Trent Rivers from a relation. He is homesick and will probably want to come home next year after he finishes up his contract. He loves his teammates but misses home and his family. Big Eagles supporter so they are probably in the right part of a rebuild to get him but he is also big mates with LJ and would be ok going to Freo as he just wants to be in Perth.
Lol suck shit Dees.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Poll
- Locked
