List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread III

[LETSGOKANGAS]

We got pick 3 and F15 for JHF.

So we traded pick 1 in 2022 for pick 2, 40 and 43 essentially?

 

[LETSGOKANGAS]

Yep, only half those kicks hit a player… the other ones sailed through for goals.

The goals were shanked passes

 

[LB2Snake]

Ok…he looks like a complete gun. Serious wheels and utterly dynamic.

I think there’s a possibility WC will take him at 1. We could just hold here.

 

[LB2Snake]

Just a quick observation - I appreciate that you people have been welcoming on your board. When you wander into the other side during times like this it can be a bit testy. You folks are alright. Cheers

The pick 1 thread on main board has quite a few WC 5-star tools on it.

 

[Mop]

The pick 1 thread on main board has quite a few WC 5-star tools on it.

I agree. I got a bit annoyed with the echo chamber like nature and ventures over here in truth

 

[jaspers_barber]

3, 15, 18 for 1 & 22

Wait, that should read 2, 15, 18, for 1 & 22.

We draft with 1, 3, 17, 22

I’d happily do that. About as close as it’d go I’d say but they’d want 2 instead of 3. Reid and Duursma/sanders/Curtin is still good going. Maybe they can add the darling dump?

 

[GS WARRIORS]

So we traded pick 1 in 2022 for pick 2, 40 and 43 essentially?

We got the same player @ 2 that we would have @ 1. We moved from 1 to 2 so we could get 3.

 

[kangaanth]

I can understand. Tongala just goes OFF on a Saturday evening.

Exactly my point if he is writing himself off every weekend there how will he go in the big city?

 

[Jimmac31]

So with the West Coast Brockman trade, it leaves them with only 3 picks in the draft (1, 23, 37). You get the feeling they are splitting pick 1. It'd almost be negligible not to, after the season they had.

And unless they give up future picks, they can't live trade on draft night because their biggest currency would be gone first pick.

The contrast to what North have (2, 3, 15, 17, 18, 57, 65). I think a trade between North and West Coast will be done in the coming days.

 

[Psicosis]

Anyone noticed the Reid & uncle relationship? Whilst I’m not suggesting it’s anywhere near as toxic as the JHF & Fabian dynamic, it is a point of interest…

 

[R00StaR]

Anyone noticed the Reid & uncle relationship? Whilst I’m not suggesting it’s anywhere near as toxic as the JHF & Fabian dynamic, it is a point of interest…

I refuse to call him Uncle-Reid
Uncle Chop Chop yes, but not Uncle-Reid

 

[Masked Avenger]

I refuse to call him Uncle-Reid
Uncle Chop Chop yes, but not Uncle-Reid

Well, there are other warning signs here too. The lad's old man is named Mark who named his son after a motorcycle.

 

[Mr north man]

Just wait 12 months
Let the Eagles draft Reid at 1 then we take Curtain at 2 or 3 then after the 2024 season Reid will want to comeback to Victoria and Curtain May want to go back to WA .
But if for some reason Cutain wants to stay here we can still trade with the Eagles maybe our 1st pick next year and maybe a player or 2 thrown in.
Or we can suggest to them a straight swap for both players with draft picks thrown in.
As a club the NMFC we hold all the cards why risk doing something stupid by giving away a draft haul of picks which I still can’t believe the AFL has given us by putting all the eggs in 1 basket by selling the farm to get Reid.
We might even get lucky and the Eagles might call out Curtain name 1st.
Then Reid is all ours.

 

[R00StaR]

Well, there are other warning signs here too. The lad's old man is named Mark who named his son after a motor cycle.

More like Dusty every day

 

[Mop]

If your club thinks the same way, then a trade could only we be us or keep the pick…So how far apart do you have Reid above McKercher..?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Not my own opinion, I'm stealing the opinion of the AFL club affilitated scout on our board.


It's close in his books.

 

[FootySmartSimpson]

I think the main appeal for us with Reid is his ability to play other positions, not just an all out mid. Personally i dont think theres much difference between he, Sanders and McKerch other than that utility factor. We've got a good young group of mids already but there are question marks around how we manage them when not in their preferred positions.
I wouldnt be surprised one bit if we went Duursma and Curtin for that utility factor.

2 of the three (ZD, DC, HR) would be ideal. I think our best result would be something like the 2017 draft where -from the outside - Freo seemed uncertain leading up to the draft then selected Brayshaw at 1 over LDU.

Pick 1: WC pick the safe option in McKercher

Pick 2: North bid on Walter

Pick 3: North select Reid

Pick 4: North select Duursma.

 

[Dingster]

Not my own opinion, I'm stealing the opinion of the AFL club affilitated scout on our board.


It's close in his books.

All the more reason not to pay overs from a North pov.

 

[shinboner magic]

Just wait 12 months
Let the Eagles draft Reid at 1 then we take Curtain at 2 or 3 then after the 2024 season Reid will want to comeback to Victoria and Curtain May want to go back to WA .
But if for some reason Cutain wants to stay here we can still trade with the Eagles maybe our 1st pick next year and maybe a player or 2 thrown in.
Or we can suggest to them a straight swap for both players with draft picks thrown in.
As a club the NMFC we hold all the cards why risk doing something stupid by giving away a draft haul of picks which I still can’t believe the AFL has given us by putting all the eggs in 1 basket by selling the farm to get Reid.
We might even get lucky and the Eagles might call out Curtain name 1st.
Then Reid is all ours.

If Reid decides to come back to Melbourne- he won’t be coming to a bottom side.
He’ll pick a top side and the weagles will get 2 picks in the 15-20 zone.

 

[R00StaR]

If Reid decides to come back to Melbourne- he won’t be coming to a bottom side.
He’ll pick a top side and the weagles will get 2 picks in the 15-20 zone.

We wont be a bottom side in 2 years

 

[Fish Sticks]

That's not what I'm saying. We were always going to trade it, but for a straight pick swap you don't expect to come out ahead given that everyone knows we had to trade it. That's why I think that we may have given the Suns something extra that is hidden from view.

GC were in the same boat essentially, as pick 18 was going to be swallowed up in matching bids & they already have enough picks/points to match all bids in this draft, so it was an obvious trade & win/win for both clubs.
We surely bid on Walter at 2 as he would be who we would be taking in an open draft (we wouldn’t even be entertaining trading up for Reid if he was)
I doubt we get bid on Read out of some kind of spite unless we genuinely rate him at 4/5

 

[shinboner magic]

We wont be a bottom side in 2 years

Can’t remember any prize interstate recruits picking smaller clubs over bigger clubs

 

[The Anvil]

Says to me WCE are certain we'll take who they want at 2 or 3. Good job Brady

Or simply that the Eagles will look at pick swaps all the way up until live trading but player movement needs to be complete next week.

If I was the Eagles, I'd look at who is picked up at 2 and 3 and live trade with someone like the Dees if who they want is still on the board.

 

[ChopChopDigDig]

I don’t think we’ll be bidding on Walter after GC swapped their 18 with our next years 20 (+ bids)

 

[JGreezy]

I hate the Judas as much as the next guy but he has all the attributes to be greater than Dangerfield.

HR has nothing on Judas.

Judas was ripping games apart against men as a 17 year old.

Once his tank improves he will be unstoppable.

Sent from my CPH2197 using Tapatalk

His issue is between his ears. He needs to get that straightened out.

 

[pupstar]

Can’t remember any prize interstate recruits picking smaller clubs over bigger clubs

Judd to Blues. In my eyes no were near as big as the NMFC.