List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread

[King Corey]

Edit: will update if ppl happy for this to sticky

Ok starting the hit list of names mentioned in any rumour as linked to us for 2023 trade period.

• Mac Andrew
• Hunter Clark
• Zac Fisher
• Sam Flanders
• Mitch Georgiades
• Liam Henry
• Dougal Howard
• Lewis Melican
• Jack Silvagni
• Dylan Stephens
• Adam Tomlinson

 

[Shermanator]

I’m fine with it if u think taking Curtin at 2 is a better option
In 2 contracts time eagles and dockers will be doing better and he’ll be gone

That’s a fair point.

We”re all fake tough like we’re calling the shots by telling the Eagles we’re taking Curtin at pick 2 so no deal to 1 & 16.

The Eagles would be thinking ‘no problems Norf we’ll take Reid at 1 (set him up for life with some HJ franchises and HJ’s from the Cottesloe beach babes) and we’ll take our boy Curtin next year or the year after when he gets the JHFF ‘homesickness’..

In two years we’re left holding our knob thinking why didn’t we just give pick 19-20 (after academy bids) to West coast and Harley would be dominating for us in his 3rd year?..

 

[Blightys Barrel]

It won’t be big money

Please don’t trade for this kid. If Carlton don’t want him and are contending atm, then surely that’s all you need to know. We need key backs and a decent ruckman to support X if Goldy does not go for another year.

 

[Blightys Barrel]

Bit of a tangent. He's an absolute knob but I wouldn't mind having Jack Silvagni on the list on cheap money as depth or to plug a hole in defence next season. I'll probably be crucified for this haha

This is an excellent suggestion as we get to see his Mum in the crowd. Still going well as a young Sale of the Century Fan

 

[Shermanator]

Please don’t trade for this kid. If Carlton don’t want him and are contending atm, then surely that’s all you need to know. We need key backs and a decent ruckman to support X if Goldy does not go for another year.

Crazy Vossy has him playing all over the show and he hasn’t settled.

Would be beautiful playing a link up role for HBF through our midfield. Silky skills and has a good IQ.

Would free Sheezel up to play more forward of the ball where he could seriously hurt teams more on the scoreboard.

Fisher can play.

 

[Blightys Barrel]

Dodo would ask for pick 2

And a future 1st rounder

 

[see see]

 

[Masked Avenger]

That’s a fair point.

We”re all fake tough like we’re calling the shots by telling the Eagles we’re taking Curtin at pick 2 so no deal to 1 & 16.

The Eagles would be thinking ‘no problems Norf we’ll take Reid at 1 (set him up for life with some HJ franchises and HJ’s from the Cottesloe beach babes) and we’ll take our boy Curtin next year or the year after when he gets the JHFF ‘homesickness’..

In two years we’re left holding our knob thinking why didn’t we just give pick 19-20 (after academy bids) to West coast and Harley would be dominating for us in his 3rd year?..

We need to start somewhere Shermy - might as well be Curtin.

Personally, I don't care if Curtin is a flight risk. Might as well shut the joint if we're intimidated by an 18 year old who may or may not want to return home in a few years time.

Horne Francis is not a precedent. The kid had home issues. Not all kids do.

Anyway, If it wasn't for him leaving, we wouldn't have the one two punch that is Wardlaw and Sheezel - and watch that pay off in about 60 games.

Curtin will be a good investment one way or another.

Truth is, if we really want Reid then we have to force them to pick Curtin at 1 - because giving them Port's pick ain't gonna work if Reid's that good.

 

[Sphynx]

This would be the biggest boneheaded move from us if we did chase this.

He’s a good young player, but plays a position we are absolutely stacked in, especially with George fit now.

He’s not a massive upgrade on Eddie Ford and Dodo will want the world for him.

 

[Shermanator]

We need to start somewhere Shermy - might as well be Curtin.

Personally, I don't care if Curtin is a flight risk. Might as well shut the joint if we're intimidated by an 18 year old who may or may not want to return home in a few years time.

Horne Francis is not a precedent. The kid had home issues. Not all kids do.

Anyway, If it wasn't for him leaving, we wouldn't have the one two punch that is Wardlaw and Sheezel - and watch that pay off in about 60 games.

Curtin will be a good investment one way or another.

Truth is, if we really want Reid then we have to force them to pick Curtin at 1 - because giving them Port's pick ain't gonna work if Reid's that good.

I appreciate that mate and was saying the exact same thing only a week ago, but who knows what the brown paper bags are conjuring up with Curtin in the background already.

If we really rate Reid that high I would be filthy in 2 years time if we lost him and Curtin for the sake of a pick in the 20’s, especially this year if we get The Colonel as a freebie..

 

[sruss]

They can keep him...he wanted to go to the bummers and no one else so they can have him...

100% agree. What’s that saying about making your bed and laying in it?

 

[New_Roo]

This I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again I have no confidence in Rawlings as a list manager I’m hoping Viney and Clarko take over . I don’t know who else is on the recruiting team but Rawlings past history on recruiting has been terrible.

They won't take over, they will merely prove, contrary to some people's belief, that recruitment and list mgmt isn't one man's decision


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[New_Roo]

Please don’t trade for this kid. If Carlton don’t want him and are contending atm, then surely that’s all you need to know. We need key backs and a decent ruckman to support X if Goldy does not go for another year.

Assuming you are talking fisher... Carlton simply don't need him and is surplus to requirements and is being paid relatively well... they have plenty of small fwds, plenty of mids and at hb he is purely warming the seat as they have a 800k player waiting to come back... us on the flipside he could fill a need both fwd and back and the odd inside excursion


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[zoomba23]

Crazy Vossy has him playing all over the show and he hasn’t settled.

Would be beautiful playing a link up role for HBF through our midfield. Silky skills and has a good IQ.

Would free Sheezel up to play more forward of the ball where he could seriously hurt teams more on the scoreboard.

Fisher can play.

Silky skills is very much pushing it. Cerra, Williams and Martin are the only blokes at Carlton I'd bestow the 'silky' label onto, and none of them were developed by the club (lol).

With descriptions like this you're gonna hoodwink all the people on here who know **** all about oppo players into thinking we're getting a gun. He's not a gun, he's just a role player who fits a need. Much more so than someone like Howe, and marginally more than someone like Tucker, as Fisher can actually move

 

[Lomas]

100% agree. What’s that saying about making your bed and laying in it?

Give it a rest, Mum.

 

[BlueandWhiteinmyBlood]

Would we be talking to Perkins incase bombers offer to McKay doesn’t trigger band one and now we are looking at trade options?

 

[kool kangas]

Would we be talking to Perkins incase bombers offer to McKay doesn’t trigger band one and now we are looking at trade options?

l hope not....If band 1 is not received then he stays with us...

 

[The Filth Wizard]

Would we be talking to Perkins incase bombers offer to McKay doesn’t trigger band one and now we are looking at trade options?

Thomas more likely.

 

[BlueandWhiteinmyBlood]

Thomas more likely.

Hope not!

 

[Kanga1996]

Would we be talking to Perkins incase bombers offer to McKay doesn’t trigger band one and now we are looking at trade options?

Started following a few Geelong players so no need to worry.

 

[Harris 10]

Started following a few Geelong players so no need to worry. View attachment 1793098

 

[R00StaR]

That’s a fair point.

We”re all fake tough like we’re calling the shots by telling the Eagles we’re taking Curtin at pick 2 so no deal to 1 & 16.

The Eagles would be thinking ‘no problems Norf we’ll take Reid at 1 (set him up for life with some HJ franchises and HJ’s from the Cottesloe beach babes) and we’ll take our boy Curtin next year or the year after when he gets the JHFF ‘homesickness’..

In two years we’re left holding our knob thinking why didn’t we just give pick 19-20 (after academy bids) to West coast and Harley would be dominating for us in his 3rd year?..

Pick 2 and Ports pick for 1 and a bunch of junk picks for Sanders bidding is a win for both. We have to at the very least get a fair amount of points back which would be long shot drafts for them anyway.

 

[Star]

Started following a few Geelong players so no need to worry. View attachment 1793098

He’s followed Mardi?

 

[The Y Factor]

I didn't need that week of having pick 1.

That was just pure evil.

I know!

Talk about spending it before I had it!!!

 

[Themanbun]

We need to start somewhere Shermy - might as well be Curtin.

Personally, I don't care if Curtin is a flight risk. Might as well shut the joint if we're intimidated by an 18 year old who may or may not want to return home in a few years time.

Horne Francis is not a precedent. The kid had home issues. Not all kids do.

Anyway, If it wasn't for him leaving, we wouldn't have the one two punch that is Wardlaw and Sheezel - and watch that pay off in about 60 games.

Curtin will be a good investment one way or another.

Truth is, if we really want Reid then we have to force them to pick Curtin at 1 - because giving them Port's pick ain't gonna work if Reid's that good.

Nailed it

 

[The Y Factor]

Edit: will update if ppl happy for this to sticky

Ok starting the hit list of names mentioned in any rumour as linked to us for 2023 trade period.

• Mac Andrew
• Zac Fisher
• Sam Flanders
• Mitch Georgiades
• Liam Henry
• Dougal Howard
• Lewis Melican
• Jack Silvagni
• Dylan Stephens

Sean Darcy and Archie Perkins?