List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread

[King Corey]

Edit: will update if ppl happy for this to sticky

Ok starting the hit list of names mentioned in any rumour as linked to us for 2023 trade period.

• Mac Andrew
• Hunter Clark
• Zac Fisher
• Sam Flanders
• Mitch Georgiades
• Liam Henry
• Dougal Howard
• Lewis Melican
• Jack Silvagni
• Dylan Stephens
• Adam Tomlinson

 

[The Nostradamus]

Who is everyone’s pick to play the main distributor off HB role this year?

Question marks over Hall. (can he stay injury free? Are there more dependable kicks / decision makers available?)

TT too. (still not confirmed he’s gonna be switched down back? Will he defy his critics and become a solid week-in week-out contributor?)

Or is there anyone else we reckon could play the role well?

The Goat and Perez to be our half back flanker distributors next year

B: McDonald McKay Corr
HB: Goater Logue Perez

 

[roos 10]

I

The Goat and Perez to be our half back flanker distributors next year

B: McDonald McKay Corr
HB: Goater Logue Perez

I think hall will be hbf
will be wing

 

[Wonderdog]

16. Bon

32 games in 5 years indicates the problem. He can’t stay on the park for prolonged periods. When he is fit he is a developing medium defender with good speed & skills. Can play on smalls but has mainly been used on taller types even though he is only 188cms. There is a fair bit of competition for medium defenders so will need a better run with injuries to nail down a spot.

 

[king of the road]

Who is everyone’s pick to play the main distributor off HB role this year?

Question marks over Hall. (can he stay injury free? Are there more dependable kicks / decision makers available?)

TT too. (still not confirmed he’s gonna be switched down back? Will he defy his critics and become a solid week-in week-out contributor?)

Or is there anyone else we reckon could play the role well?

Perez.

 

[Le Grille]

16. Bon

32 games in 5 years indicates the problem. He can’t stay on the park for prolonged periods. When he is fit he is a developing medium defender with good speed & skills. Can play on smalls but has mainly been used on taller types even though he is only 188cms. There is a fair bit of competition for medium defenders so will need a better run with injuries to nail down a spot.

Speed, skills and athleticism is the word on him but I simply haven’t seen it. I have no qualms picking him up for the cost but for mine he is way way back in the pecking order

I’d argue Jackson Archer will go past him by end of the year

 

[zoomba23]

Who is everyone’s pick to play the main distributor off HB role this year?

Question marks over Hall. (can he stay injury free? Are there more dependable kicks / decision makers available?)

TT too. (still not confirmed he’s gonna be switched down back? Will he defy his critics and become a solid week-in week-out contributor?)

Or is there anyone else we reckon could play the role well?

If I had my way Stephenson would do that role. But by all reports he's training as a forward, so there goes that idea I guess

 

[shinboner magic]

My early early call for delisting

Ziebs , hall to retire
Bonar , mahony

Speed, skills and athleticism is the word on him but I simply haven’t seen it. I have no qualms picking him up for the cost but for mine he is way way back in the pecking order

I’d argue Jackson Archer will go past him by end of the year

He’s an athlete that seconds guesses himself when he gets the ball - needs to be more instinctive but you’re either born with that or you’re not.

 

[hellas_johnny]

My early early call for delisting

Ziebs , hall to retire
Bonar , mahony

He’s an athlete that seconds guesses himself when he gets the ball - needs to be more instinctive but you’re either born with that or you’re not.

Spicer delist also

 

[king rising]

16. Bon

32 games in 5 years indicates the problem. He can’t stay on the park for prolonged periods. When he is fit he is a developing medium defender with good speed & skills. Can play on smalls but has mainly been used on taller types even though he is only 188cms. There is a fair bit of competition for medium defenders so will need a better run with injuries to nail down a spot.

He’s just not good enough. Injuries aside too.

 

[leighlee13]

He’s just not good enough. Injuries aside too.

I don't like to criticise players but i have to agree with you going on what I have seen of him so far. Maybe Clarko will be the difference and if he earns his chance, he needs to take it with both hands.

 

[Wonderdog]

17. Lachie Y

A quiet achiever who at 23 & 43 games should now take his game to the next level. 10th in Syd shows he has improved a fair bit. A good size & not slow so has some athletic gifts. His decision making improved in 2022 hence less turnover. He seems the dependable under rated guy that all premiership sides have but who also is the first delisted when the side has a downturn like Liam Shiels.

 

[Samsquanch]

Lachie Y

A quiet achiever who at 23 & 43 games should now take his game to the next level.

Annoyingly, a whipping boy but one who was pretty much hung out to dry by the previous coaching staff not having any decent game plans.

 

[Ligma]

Annoyingly, a whipping boy but one who was pretty much hung out to dry by the previous coaching staff not having any decent game plans.

I lachie my boy

 

[JGreezy]

I think that Lachie will be better in a better side. He had moments but really only elite defenders would have looked good in this side last season. He isn't elite but he is good enough and will have more support this season.

I do wonder if he and Archer are competing for the same spot in the backline.

 

[Hazey1977]

Annoyingly, a whipping boy but one who was pretty much hung out to dry by the previous coaching staff not having any decent game plans.

He's shown some underrated hardness in game too.

On SM-G781B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[roos_fanatic08]

I think that Lachie will be better in a better side. He had moments but really only elite defenders would have looked good in this side last season. He isn't elite but he is good enough and will have more support this season.

I do wonder if he and Archer are competing for the same spot in the backline.

I’d say he is probably competing with Corr, Dawson, Ziebell and Bonar for that 3rd tall/intercepting role.

Then you have the likes of McDonald, Hall, Perez, Archer, Scott, Goater, Tucker, Bergman and Turner competing for the mid/small roles.

Corr, McKay, Mcdonald
Hall, Logue, Archer

Then 2 of the above on the bench

 

[The acurate one]

So our last game of season 2022 went like this.




Our team was




I could name three in the backline that probably could be delisted without a concern, all are OOC this year. For mine it's Dawson or Young not both. And Dawson at 194cm offers more I'd suggest.

.

Minus JHFF I probably retain only 13 of the others- good grief no wonder we allowed 34 shots against that day.

oh well indeed.

 

[Wonderdog]

18. Hugh

A good investment given Cunners illness woes. Has the opportunity to form a hard nut ball winning one-two combo with Cunners this year. Came to us with a pre-existing knee injury and was bandaged up early in the year. His mature body and inside craft will protect & educate the younger mids but at 30 years old has to make the most of his opportunities as the young mids will hopefully learn quickly and go past him.

 

[Eggs11]

18. Hugh

A good investment given Cunners illness woes. Has the opportunity to form a hard nut ball winning one-two combo with Cunners this year. Came to us with a pre-existing knee injury and was bandaged up early in the year. His mature body and inside craft will protect & educate the younger mids but at 30 years old has to make the most of his opportunities as the young mids will hopefully learn quickly and go past him.

Enjoying your reviews, thank you.

Don’t think Greenwood and Cunners can play in the same team. Just too slow. I’m hoping Greenwood will spend the majority of 2023 in the VFL (which might be a bit stiff since Noble lured him out of Gold Coast).

 

[Hatchy1992]

Enjoying your reviews, thank you.

Don’t think Greenwood and Cunners can play in the same team. Just too slow. I’m hoping Greenwood will spend the majority of 2023 in the VFL (which might be a bit stiff since Noble lured him out of Gold Coast).

Yep, im thinking Hugh will spend most of the season in the vfl acting as a mentor for the younger fringe mids. Unless of course injuries of course.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

Since Greenwood’s best mate was dumped, his place in the side is tenuous at best.

Even more so with Cunners returning.

 

[Wonderdog]

19. Griff

A 24 year old top ten draft pick is a great pick up for us. He changes the dynamics of the backline with his ability to both intercept & play on a variety of forwards. This allows other defenders to play more natural roles than they have in recent years. This in turn allows the younger defenders to develop with better match ups. Should be a key part of our defence for at least the next 5 years.

 

[The acurate one]

Since Greenwood’s best mate was dumped, his place in the side is tenuous at best.

Even more so with Cunners returning.

Well it's his last yr contracted. A fair chance he's driving a Ford Supercar next season under Nobles, of course.

 

[Themanbun]

Well it's his last yr contracted. A fair chance he's driving a Ford Supercar next season under Nobles, of course.

I thought he triggered his third?

 

[The acurate one]

I thought he triggered his third?

So did Walkers apparently. But I have NFI and cannot see him getting much game time.