List Mgmt. 2024 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals

[Ticky009]

 

[caesar88]

 

[Cadsky]

I don't want to know

 

[Bloods86]

First 504 nominations for the draft:

AFL draft player list 2024: Every player nominated for the upcoming National Draft | Sporting News Australia

www.sportingnews.com

Sam Frost (former GWS academy) and Kobe Ryan, 2 young inside mids (22 and 20) who made SANFL team of year. Wouldn't be surprised if Frost gets another crack at it in particular, he's a bigger unit than Ryan.

 

[Bloods86]

James Bell

32

James Bell

Age

25

Ht

183cm

Wt

84kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

7.0

2star

K

4.5

2star

HB

2.5

2star

M

3.5

4star

T

2.5

4star

G

0.5

3star

No current season stats available

D

7.0

2star

K

4.5

2star

HB

2.5

3star

M

3.5

4star

T

2.5

4star

G

0.5

3star

has nominated, been very good at Glenelg. Just to put that thought into your minds.

 

[dosser]

First 504 nominations for the draft:

AFL draft player list 2024: Every player nominated for the upcoming National Draft | Sporting News Australia

www.sportingnews.com

I love that there's a Lucas Snowball.

 

[Kiama Chris]

James Bell has nominated, been very good at Glenelg. Just to put that thought into your minds.

Playing on a wing I believe. Good athlete and endurance runner. Always has been. Decision making lets him down. Be surprised if he gets picked up, even as a rookie or SSP, but wish him well, like every ex-Swan.

 

[caesar88]

I don't want to know

"Worst: 2021 – Sydney gets: 2022 R1 (tied to Melbourne), Adelaide gets: Jordan Dawson

This trade was covered off as a win for the Crows earlier but it’s worth revisiting for the disappointment it ended up being for the Swans.

Sydney lost Jordan Dawson, then used the future pick in a trade in 2022 for pick 27 – Cooper Vickery, who was delisted without playing a game – and future second and third rounders from Hawthorn.

The Swans offloaded those two futures in minor deals, while the Hawks used the pick gained to grab Josh Weddle.

The Swans got little return, while two other players are forging strong careers elsewhere."

Big yikes.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

"Worst: 2021 – Sydney gets: 2022 R1 (tied to Melbourne), Adelaide gets: Jordan Dawson

This trade was covered off as a win for the Crows earlier but it’s worth revisiting for the disappointment it ended up being for the Swans.

Sydney lost Jordan Dawson, then used the future pick in a trade in 2022 for pick 27 – Cooper Vickery, who was delisted without playing a game – and future second and third rounders from Hawthorn.

The Swans offloaded those two futures in minor deals, while the Hawks used the pick gained to grab Josh Weddle.

The Swans got little return, while two other players are forging strong careers elsewhere."

Big yikes.

We did however get the resources by offloading those picks to get Grundy etc last season. It’s not a win but it’s a slightly better loss

 

[Kbroome]

"Worst: 2021 – Sydney gets: 2022 R1 (tied to Melbourne), Adelaide gets: Jordan Dawson

This trade was covered off as a win for the Crows earlier but it’s worth revisiting for the disappointment it ended up being for the Swans.

Sydney lost Jordan Dawson, then used the future pick in a trade in 2022 for pick 27 – Cooper Vickery, who was delisted without playing a game – and future second and third rounders from Hawthorn.

The Swans offloaded those two futures in minor deals, while the Hawks used the pick gained to grab Josh Weddle.

The Swans got little return, while two other players are forging strong careers elsewhere."

Big yikes.

Weren't those picks part of the deal that enabled us to get Grundy and still match Cleary?

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Weren't those picks part of the deal that enabled us to get Grundy and still match Cleary?

Correct mainly the Grundy deal.

 

[Bloods86]

Playing on a wing I believe. Good athlete and endurance runner. Always has been. Decision making lets him down. Be surprised if he gets picked up, even as a rookie or SSP, but wish him well, like every ex-Swan.

Yeah, don't see him being picked up.

But hope he has lots of further success at premiers Glenelg (alongside Gould), though would like him to share that with Ling (runners up) and Mattner at Sturt to coach a few (more) flags.

 

[Cadsky]

"Worst: 2021 – Sydney gets: 2022 R1 (tied to Melbourne), Adelaide gets: Jordan Dawson

This trade was covered off as a win for the Crows earlier but it’s worth revisiting for the disappointment it ended up being for the Swans.

Sydney lost Jordan Dawson, then used the future pick in a trade in 2022 for pick 27 – Cooper Vickery, who was delisted without playing a game – and future second and third rounders from Hawthorn.

The Swans offloaded those two futures in minor deals, while the Hawks used the pick gained to grab Josh Weddle.

The Swans got little return, while two other players are forging strong careers elsewhere."

Big yikes.

I said I didn't want to know

 

[Bloods86]

Weren't those picks part of the deal that enabled us to get Grundy and still match Cleary?

Yeah, without Grundy we may not have been good enough to get humiliated in a grand final.

 

[BloodySwan]

"Worst: 2021 – Sydney gets: 2022 R1 (tied to Melbourne), Adelaide gets: Jordan Dawson

This trade was covered off as a win for the Crows earlier but it’s worth revisiting for the disappointment it ended up being for the Swans.

Sydney lost Jordan Dawson, then used the future pick in a trade in 2022 for pick 27 – Cooper Vickery, who was delisted without playing a game – and future second and third rounders from Hawthorn.

The Swans offloaded those two futures in minor deals, while the Hawks used the pick gained to grab Josh Weddle.

The Swans got little return, while two other players are forging strong careers elsewhere."

Big yikes.

This is why I don't care about draft picks for established players. Absolutely no guarantee you'll get anything in return

 

[bedford]

James Bell has nominated, been very good at Glenelg. Just to put that thought into your minds.

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

 

[LukeParkerno1]

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Way too many bad memories bring back Foote while we are at it if the GF isn’t bad enough let’s go worse

 

[caesar88]

This is why I don't care about draft picks for established players. Absolutely no guarantee you'll get anything in return

I don't disagree, but there generally aren't other options. The days of trading a player for a player seem in the past, so there's not much you can do except taking picks. If you can turn those picks into established players via another trade then that is ideal as at least you know what you're getting for the picks, unlike at the draft. But even if you take it to the draft, it is swings and roundabouts.

 

[anotherletdown]

Ough sounds kinda like what we need

Late birthday too... we love that unseen development

 

[anotherletdown]

I'm just assuming we'll live-trade our first pick, like we did back in 2022 with Hawthorn

Richmond? Picks 23 and 24 for 19 and 44. That would give us a block of three picks in a row and give them another double block in the 1st round. They could probably let both go for future 1sts, 23 and 24 might not be high enough to get future 1sts

 

[SeanM]

Video with 46-60 rankings.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Richmond? Picks 23 and 24 for 19 and 44. That would give us a block of three picks in a row and give them another double block in the 1st round. They could probably let both go for future 1sts, 23 and 24 might not be high enough to get future 1sts

Richmond wouldn’t do it. They are likely going to send one to next year. They’d ask for our f1, we won’t do it.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

"Worst: 2021 – Sydney gets: 2022 R1 (tied to Melbourne), Adelaide gets: Jordan Dawson

This trade was covered off as a win for the Crows earlier but it’s worth revisiting for the disappointment it ended up being for the Swans.

Sydney lost Jordan Dawson, then used the future pick in a trade in 2022 for pick 27 – Cooper Vickery, who was delisted without playing a game – and future second and third rounders from Hawthorn.

The Swans offloaded those two futures in minor deals, while the Hawks used the pick gained to grab Josh Weddle.

The Swans got little return, while two other players are forging strong careers elsewhere."

Big yikes.

This is going to catch up to us eventually

 

[Caj]

This is going to catch up to us eventually

The trade was fine (or the best we could do for an uncontracted player nominating one club) until we overlooked Weddle and pissed the rest of the picks away

 

[LukeParkerno1]

The trade was fine (or the best we could do for an uncontracted player nominating one club) until we overlooked Weddle and pissed the rest of the picks away

Everyone gets up and arms about the Weddle thing it was a terrible draft go through the first round there’s probably 5 decent blokes in the first 25 picks. Yes the Hawks lucked out it happens. The trade allowed us to have the picks for Grundy

 

[Caj]

Everyone gets up and arms about the Weddle thing it was a terrible draft go through the first round there’s probably 5 decent blokes in the first 25 picks. Yes the Hawks lucked out it happens. The trade allowed us to have the picks for Grundy

Might’ve been a terrible draft but we had a free hit at one of the best out of it and chose to overlook him for some inexplicable reason

Also we got Grundy for junk picks, the trade would’ve proceeded regardless, we just would’ve used other junkier picks