Rumour 2024 Hypothetical trade and FA Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Brant said:
No need to continue the discussion.
You're correct.
Others can think what they want.

*in saying this, HAD WE BEEN IN POSITION TO SELECT ONE OR THE OTHER, it was the wrong decision & almost certainly will prove to be the wrong decision.
Click to expand...
No to McDonald. He’s just not that good. We need a key defender not a key forward.
 
earthworms said:
I'm not directly attacking any valuable itks I'm just mentioning how easy it is for people to make stuff up. It went from battle is coming to hawthorn, to he's staying at st kilda, to he's coming to hawthorn in the span of a week.
Click to expand...
No offense, but you have seemingly been here for 5 minutes.

I’ve been here for 20 years as have others.
A lot of us know who has good info. When they post what they’ve heard we know it’s based on something that they’ve heard from within the industry that they are/were a part of.

There’s also some posters here might look like your every day Joe blow but they’re connected a lot more than they let on.

It’s why some posters can say something and others immediately take note.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

jenniferHAWKinS said:
No to McDonald. He’s just not that good. We need a key defender not a key forward.
Click to expand...
I am not sold he is going to be an out and out star but a 3rd year key forward kicking 30+ goals and is on track for close to 40 this year. They are really solid numbers for a developing tall.
 
If I had to guess (which I am) I assume our name has been thrown into the McDonald ring by either us, his manager or both to pump up his $$$ value. Either way the chances of getting him would likely be low.

Just say we were to secure McDonald would that spell end of one of Lewis or Chol? You can never have too many KPF but Lewis, Chol, Dear and McDonald feels like one too many.
 
Bugs1977 said:
If I had to guess (which I am) I assume our name has been thrown into the McDonald ring by either us, his manager or both to pump up his $$$ value. Either way the chances of getting him would likely be low.

Just say we were to secure McDonald would that spell end of one of Lewis or Chol? You can never have too many KPF but Lewis, Chol, Dear and McDonald feels like one too many.
Click to expand...
You can add Scaife to that list as well.
 
kazzooka said:
Most if not all the ITK posters here are in the know with Hawthorn which is not a reliable or knowledgeable organisation on their recruitment targets.

You will have ITKs from 4 clubs thinking a player is coming and all have received information from good sources in clubs.

But unless your Bailey Smith's mum, they don't really know.

I remember I had strong information regarding Tom Lynch yet 3 club were confident they had him secured. The media were on the money stating Richmond but I think they decided before Tom did as he was very open to Collingwood and Hawthorn offers late and even had his manager approach Geelong but they weren't able to arrange a competitive deal. Was very undecided even when many of those clubs were certain they had him or that different rival did.
Click to expand...
Correct. Lots of people know people at clubs. Clubs get told what the player and their management want them to think. Reporting that Hawthorn is into a player and is confident is useful information and appreciated, but often several clubs feel the same way based on the representations made to them. Thats the managers doing their job.
 
Bugs1977 said:
If I had to guess (which I am) I assume our name has been thrown into the McDonald ring by either us, his manager or both to pump up his $$$ value. Either way the chances of getting him would likely be low.

Just say we were to secure McDonald would that spell end of one of Lewis or Chol? You can never have too many KPF but Lewis, Chol, Dear and McDonald feels like one too many.
Click to expand...
You can't rely on Lewis so I'd be seeing what you can get for him (only if we were lucky enough to get McDonald to nominate us though).
 
Last edited:
Strapping Young Lad said:
No offense, but you have seemingly been here for 5 minutes.

I’ve been here for 20 years as have others.
A lot of us know who has good info. When they post what they’ve heard we know it’s based on something that they’ve heard from within the industry that they are/were a part of.

There’s also some posters here might look like your every day Joe blow but they’re connected a lot more than they let on.

It’s why some posters can say something and others immediately take note.
Click to expand...
As an example. If I say something it's 99% based on nothing (I don't know anyone). But if RnL says something you stand up and take notice.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Strapping Young Lad said:
No offense, but you have seemingly been here for 5 minutes.

I’ve been here for 20 years as have others.
A lot of us know who has good info. When they post what they’ve heard we know it’s based on something that they’ve heard from within the industry that they are/were a part of.

There’s also some posters here might look like your every day Joe blow but they’re connected a lot more than they let on.

It’s why some posters can say something and others immediately take note.
Click to expand...
Word ✅
 
I find it odd that people take their disappointment out on ITKs. Blame the weatherperson etc.

I also ponder the conflation of information and source and the reductive anger and distrust directed to same. Information is no longer seen as a communal and societal tool - it’s seen as something that immediately arouses suspicion. It’s kind of depressing actually. All sources are equal and therefore meaningless.

Anyway Go Hawks
 
Mr Meeseeks said:
This thread isn't fun any more.



Sent from my SM-G990E using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Go Away Stop GIF by Phantom Thread
 
Billyc said:
Correct. Lots of people know people at clubs. Clubs get told what the player and their management want them to think. Reporting that Hawthorn is into a player and is confident is useful information and appreciated, but often several clubs feel the same way based on the representations made to them. Thats the managers doing their job.
Click to expand...

My family were chatting to Hodge's family and they were 100% sure Buddy was staying. And they werent just guessing.

So connected people definitely dont always know everything because (the good) managers play every game imaginable to extract maximum dollars for their players.

Its why those of us who know nothing are happy posting away about our desires while the ITK people dontpost often because they know they have inside info but inside info doesnt always equal the truth.

Its also why people shouldnt get angry at the ITK. We had the entire club, media, and even other clubs sure a couple of GWS players were coming our way then mystically the AFL found a way to keep them at GWS.

Weve also seen a couple of GWS players definitely coming to us but ending up going somewhere else. Thst said, I dont think we have missed any of them.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

Dixie Flatline
  • Locked
News AFL free agent and trade tracker 2024
Replies
22
Views
1K
Dixie Flatline
Dixie Flatline
streetspirit
Strategy AFLW post season Trade, FA & Draft Talk 2024
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
132
Views
7K
streetspirit
streetspirit
Strapping Young Lad
  • Locked
News 2024 Hawthorn trade targets, News and tidbits...
Replies
9
Views
9K
Strapping Young Lad
Strapping Young Lad
rdhopkins2
2024 HFC AGM
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
152
Views
10K
paddington
P
H
Do we have any 2024 NGA's melt thread extravaganza
2 3 4
Replies
94
Views
9K
kazzooka
K
Strapping Young Lad
Game Day Hawthorn PCM 2024
2 3 4
Replies
90
Views
6K
lyger
L
Strapping Young Lad
Autopsy Round 17, 2024 : Hawks fall in a hole in Geelong
15 16 17 18 19
Replies
465
Views
23K
CHUBBSS
CHUBBSS

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top