Rumour 2024 Hypothetical trade and FA Thread

[Strapping Young Lad]

2024 Picks



2025 Picks

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

The lack of common sense in here is absolutely bewildering.

 

[Yardie]

Let’s wait and see, but he has a far superior strike rate than the supposed ‘ITKs’ in here…

Page after page of people saying don't be a dick to ITKs.....and then this......

 

[Since 2001]

Apparently saints in for thomlinson or however tou spell it from melb, sign that battle on the way out?

 

[Judd2Sewell]

I am not sure you are thinking this through or perhaps it is what you want us to do?

This is why you would be a crap List Manager.
Imaging approaching a player getting them to commit and nominate, then say. oops, our bad, forget it.
No one would trust the club again.

Clearly he was responding to the post he quoted.

 

[TheFourPillars]

Clearly he was responding to the post he quoted.

I realise that, but given Barrass has nominated us as the team he wants. Do you think that is actually possible.

 

[cryptor]

I’ve got a question for people, if Petracca came out and said he wants to join the Hawks what would people be happy to give up to get him, remembering that out 1st this year will likely go for Barrass.

I can't think of a single trade that I'd be happy with that is also something Melbourne would go for.

The fact he's on well over a million a year for 5 more years, and we have no idea how well he'll return from one of the most traumatic injuries I've seen in modern football is enough for me to think he's not for us under the current circumstances.

 

[Bedi]

I’ve got a question for people, if Petracca came out and said he wants to join the Hawks what would people be happy to give up to get him, remembering that out 1st this year will likely go for Barrass.

i'd give them Wingard but only very reluctantly. If they were playing hard ball i'd throw in a fourth round draft pick too

 

[butlers hawks]

I realise that, but given Barrass has nominated us as the team he wants. Do you think that is actually possible.

are people actually asking if the Hawks are even 1% chance of pulling out of the Barrass trade if Battle nominates as well?

Have I missed something or is that the question?

If it is and you are legitimately asking, no they wont, the only reason teams ever pull out of potential moves is due to asking price by the current team. If West Coast were unreasonable then the team might say sorry but they will still do everything they possibly can to get it done. This has happened before, Bobby Hill tried to get to Essendon the year before going to Collingwood for example.

If Battle does come over then it is about pairing them. If anything, they might be able to say to Josh's agent no we wont be adding to our offer since we now have Barrass coming in rather than anything else.

Imagine having an agent advocating for his client, the contract offer being agreed to, the client asking for a trade to the team, that becoming public only for the team to then say sorry we got someone else so we are pulling out

would annoy the player, the agent and the oppo team.

If you are asking because you are hoping thats the case, see above answer

If you are asking as a joke...lol good one

 

[hawkinoz]

I can't think of a single trade that I'd be happy with that is also something Melbourne would go for.

The fact he's on well over a million a year for 5 more years, and we have no idea how well he'll return from one of the most traumatic injuries I've seen in modern football is enough for me to think he's not for us under the current circumstances.

I can, we have a player who will return from injury in 2025 for Hawks. He is even 2 yrs younger than Trac & under contract for 2 more yrs.

Swap players and add F1. That is a fair trade and addresses need for both clubs and balances risks.

It is upto Demons to court Mitch Lewis for this if Trac nominates us. We can tell everyone is on market for right price if Demons can persuade them.

Our untradables will have a prohibitive 3+ first round pick price.

I read mustang reply to the below

Yep I get the strong feeling that we are aiming to land one of either Barrass or Battle here and not both after all.

As a rhetorical one to say we are NOT aiming to land just one

We will be fine if we land only one or none.

 

[butlers hawks]

i'd give them Wingard but only very reluctantly. If they were playing hard ball i'd throw in a fourth round draft pick too

Chad is a free agent, not saying that he cant be traded, however it limits his value in a trade

 

[Judd2Sewell]

I realise that, but given Barrass has nominated us as the team he wants. Do you think that is actually possible.

There's no chance we would do that to Barrass. Tony's reply in particular insinuates that this is what Mustang thinks though, when it seems he was just responding to another post with a question.

 

[KermitJagger]

Apparently saints in for thomlinson or however tou spell it from melb, sign that battle on the way out?

Jeez Tomlinson has been stealing a living for a number of years now

 

[butlers hawks]

I’ve got a question for people, if Petracca came out and said he wants to join the Hawks what would people be happy to give up to get him, remembering that out 1st this year will likely go for Barrass.

This is an interesting question, the likely answer is that their asking price will be too much for us without the first going to WC.

Reality is if we are comfortable with it, they wont be

Would need a best 23 player, and not a fringe guy like Maginness, likely a starter level guy, probably younger

Mitchell isnt going to force a Ryan Burton level guy out the door.

If Pickett is trying to get to Port, Dees arent doing their jobs right if they arent trying to get into Butters ear

 

[Ned Ryerson]

specifically? I did a little search no such username.

x.com

x.com

 

[Ned Ryerson]

The lack of common sense in here is absolutely bewildering.

You say that like that's an uncommon thing in these threads.

 

[Lickmesocks]

If the Eagles are going to try and screw us over Barrass then we are out of there quick smart. Even 1 first round pick for a 29 year old is a massive price to pay.

I really hope both clubs have already agreed to some sort of deal or this will become another drawn out shit fight.

 

[Judd2Sewell]

Jeez Tomlinson has been stealing a living for a number of years now

Professional backup, not a bad gig at all.

 

[Yardie]

Me neither. I always knew god was though

Regardless of where they sit on the spectrum neither are stupid.......

 

[JZedd]

I don’t think we have enough, the only way I think we. Hold manage it is if we pulled the pin on Barrass which we won’t do.

I have no idea what you're talking about.

 

[mustang]

0% chance that happens, if we did that imagine how bad we’d look. Would almost ruin any other player wanting to come in the future

I agree that's why I questioned it.

 

[Braidz]

The lack of common sense in here is absolutely bewildering.

It’s like you’re surprised. It’s the same every year

 

[mustang]

This is why you would be a crap List Manager.
Imaging approaching a player getting them to commit and nominate, then say. oops, our bad, forget it.
No one would trust the club again.

I was a asking question to the post, it wasn't a statement maybe read what was posted not just quote what I posted.

I agree why would we do that it's dumb, it would destroy all the credibility we have in the industry, that why I asked it as they can't be serious.

 

[Flukey!]

Sam Edmund said on SEN that the expectation is that Battle is still coming to us and is likely just waiting for the exit interview to happen first.

Around 4:40

 

[unitedhawk]

So he's a coin grabber?

heck, I can't win either way in here.

I can only put down what I'm told. He wants the Saints looked after. Believe what you want.

It's gonna be a long 5 weeks...

If this starts getting messy, I trust Sam will walk away. No point risking compromising well-earned culture for someone who may not be as committed to the cause.

Of course, I could be jumping at shadows, in which case I apologise to Battle in partcular.

 

[triple treat]

It’s like you’re surprised. It’s the same every year

Not sure you’re gonna get a whole lot of common sense in a hypothetical thread! There are other threads youse can go to if that’s what you crave!