List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading Part 2

[arrowman]

This looks most likely.
It's stupid to lock yourself up like that. Should have had one spot available. That way if a player you love falls and is unexpectedly available, you can still grab them.

I think at least part of the issue is that the ANB & Peatling trades were always going to damage our 2024 draft hand in particular, so there wasn't any point in keeping a list spot open that would have to be filled with a very late draft pick.

 

[1970crow]

I think at least part of the issue is that the ANB & Peatling trades were always going to damage our 2024 draft hand in particular, so there wasn't any point in keeping a list spot open that would have to be filled with a very late draft pick.

Berry, Crouch, Laird & Schoenberg should all have been told that their future lies solely in the SANFL. Surely 2 of them would have been shaken loose and we could look at covering their salary to maximise trade value. And even if what we got was a pittance, there's a chance that we get to our pick at 5 and there's 3 players we rate equally and someone's offering us 6,7 or 8 plus their second to move to 5 because they're desperate for a certain player. Even using our remaining 3rd if Welsh isn't bid upon by then could end up being a player that makes our contending team better.

Without Peatling we've got enough mids to run through the rotations - Dawson, Rankine, Soligo, Rachele, Taylor, Pedlar, Dowling, Edwards, Pick 4-7 plus 2 of the above and Keays in a pinch.

 

[NTRabbit]

Looking like pick 4 and 2 rookie upgrades to make the ND numbers, and Welsh in the rookie draft

 

[Vader]

Looking like pick 4 and 2 rookie upgrades to make the ND numbers, and Welsh in the rookie draft

Based on what?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

This looks most likely.
It's stupid to lock yourself up like that. Should have had one spot available. That way if a player you love falls and is unexpectedly available, you can still grab them.

Absolutely we should have delisted someone like Burgess to give us the option of trading back in if someone we liked was sliding.

Worst case scenario is we re-list them after.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Looking like pick 4 and 2 rookie upgrades to make the ND numbers, and Welsh in the rookie draft

Doubt it.

Pick 4 midfielder, Welsh & Keane upgrade more likely imo.

 

[SLOWNE]

Why aren't clubs allowed to have as many list spots as they want provided every player wage fits under the salary cap?

Do you really want to play against a Geelong list of 119 players?

 

[Eddie Murphy]

Looking like pick 4 and 2 rookie upgrades to make the ND numbers, and Welsh in the rookie draft

We’ll take Welsh at pick 64 if there hasn’t been a bid yet I imagine.

 

[Shifty Crow]

Berry, Crouch, Laird & Schoenberg should all have been told that their future lies solely in the SANFL. Surely 2 of them would have been shaken loose and we could look at covering their salary to maximise trade value. And even if what we got was a pittance, there's a chance that we get to our pick at 5 and there's 3 players we rate equally and someone's offering us 6,7 or 8 plus their second to move to 5 because they're desperate for a certain player. Even using our remaining 3rd if Welsh isn't bid upon by then could end up being a player that makes our contending team better.

Without Peatling we've got enough mids to run through the rotations - Dawson, Rankine, Soligo, Rachele, Taylor, Pedlar, Dowling, Edwards, Pick 4-7 plus 2 of the above and Keays in a pinch.

Taylor, Peds and Rachelle don’t yet have the tank for large midfield minutes and Edwards is yet to debut

Until that group become more established we are still thin


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[1970crow]

Taylor, Peds and Rachelle don’t yet have the tank for large midfield minutes and Edwards is yet to debut

Until that group become more established we are still thin


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

It’s ok to be thin whilst rebuilding, you need to be rotating through your options rather than locking in your current best 5 to grind away to 10th.