I'll say it again, hes not a key member of our side in the slightest.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading Part 2
- Thread starter 1990crow
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Floating Doughnut
SuperCrouch 🧦🧦🧦🧢🧢
- Dec 11, 2022
- 673
- 2,198
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Milera : SANFL until a few dominant performances, has had plenty of opportunities.
Cumming : first crack as off HB distribution.
Laird : Sub
Hinge : HB/ Wing.
Would be my preference
- Aug 30, 2021
- 18,766
- 36,915
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Happy with that but Nicks ain’t making Laird sub, so he’s either defence or midfield, issue is he doesn’t fit in either.
NTRabbit
Brownlow Medallist
Flip the dates, and the Scouse boom-bust cycle adapts really quite well to Adelaide
- Sep 23, 2012
- 3,936
- 6,070
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Sturt, Ozark Mountain Daredevils
He started as a back pocket. Would be poetic if he finished his career there too.
Should've just posted the Richmond optimism chart from the Bay .. looks a little similar
Vintage Bay - The Monthly Richmond Supporter Optimism Graph **TOTY 2017**
Let's start in the month of October... October: The trade period normally excites Richmond supporters somewhat, I mean, there is only one direction to go from September in terms of optimism and that is up! It is at this time Richmond will lose players (almost always bad ones, which will please...
www.bigfooty.com
Maybe starting on the bench and rotating through both areas as needed?
Probably the best we can hope for at this stage, and hopefully not taking too much game time from other developing players.
That's Port.
We are a horizontal line at mid level until pre season, then if pre season goes well we jump up a lot, if it goes bad it bumps up a little and then, lately, it just drops steadily from there to bottom out in July and Aug with a few late wins usually pushing us back up to mid range ready to sit there for the offseason again.
Slime Roy
Nuclear Gloop
- Mar 13, 2024
- 725
- 975
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Just a random "Ruck" related question.
People always praise the ruckman who is "like an extra midfielder" or even another forward.
Is the any hope for a ruckman who is actually closer to those things to begin with eg, slightly shorter, faster & more aerobic and can actually kick goals
I wonder if someone like Toby Murray could become that.. where winning the tap then disappearing is no longer our prime objective
People always praise the ruckman who is "like an extra midfielder" or even another forward.
Is the any hope for a ruckman who is actually closer to those things to begin with eg, slightly shorter, faster & more aerobic and can actually kick goals
I wonder if someone like Toby Murray could become that.. where winning the tap then disappearing is no longer our prime objective
WaynesWorld19
Moderator
- Moderator
- #3,835
I'm big on Toby Murray ....has developed massively in his first year within a professional programJust a random "Ruck" related question.
People always praise the ruckman who is "like an extra midfielder" or even another forward.
Is the any hope for a ruckman who is actually closer to those things to begin with eg, slightly shorter, faster & more aerobic and can actually kick goals
I wonder if someone like Toby Murray could become that.. where winning the tap then disappearing is no longer our prime objective
I could see a ruck combo of Thilthorpe & Turray .....still not big supporter of your best players crashing into other blokes at CBA's ...what with all the knee clashes & injury risks
Slime Roy
Nuclear Gloop
- Mar 13, 2024
- 725
- 975
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Yeah agree, maybe that's why ROBs such a "good" foil..I'm actually pretty surprised he's so durable, he looks like he could injure himself getting out of bed.
I'll be keeping a close eye on T-Muz this year.. with my fingers crossed.
It is as if you are buying a new phone for the camera.Just a random "Ruck" related question.
People always praise the ruckman who is "like an extra midfielder" or even another forward.
Is the any hope for a ruckman who is actually closer to those things to begin with eg, slightly shorter, faster & more aerobic and can actually kick goals
I wonder if someone like Toby Murray could become that.. where winning the tap then disappearing is no longer our prime objective
- Oct 16, 2011
- 16,398
- 42,277
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
I'm not saying he is crap, he is one of my favourite players but I guess when we are discussing a player being "elite" then what are the parameters of being elite?
Is it top 2% of the comp (top 20 players)
Is it top 50 player, top 100?
For me it is the first one, top 20 players and I just do not think Soligo will get there, at this stage we have one player on our team who could get there and that is Rankine.
Once again, that is not a sledge on Soligo but on this board we routinely over rate our players ( sadly our coaching box is worse for it, probably still think Laird is on the cusp of elite) and calling Soligo a prospect of being elite is one of them.
Why did that dickhead Geelong supporter have to post this at the start of the 2017 season?! I've never quite known who exactly to blame for losing the 2017 GF but now we've got a clear scapegoat!Should've just posted the Richmond optimism chart from the Bay .. looks a little similar
Vintage Bay - The Monthly Richmond Supporter Optimism Graph **TOTY 2017**
Let's start in the month of October... October: The trade period normally excites Richmond supporters somewhat, I mean, there is only one direction to go from September in terms of optimism and that is up! It is at this time Richmond will lose players (almost always bad ones, which will please...
View attachment 2161552
Unfortunately, there are multiple definitions of "elite" and so it gets a bit confusing. Particularly if different definitions are used in the answer to the question.
I tend to stick to the AFL's definitions
- Elite - top 10% of players that year (about 55ish)
- Above average - top 33%
- Average - 34% to 67%
- Below average - last 33%
Ie the top 6 and bottom 6 players in the team determine whether you can win it or not.
Soligo could be a top 55 player in the league at some point during his prime years. This would help us with a premiership tilt.
- Oct 16, 2011
- 16,398
- 42,277
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Top 55 I can see that.
To be fair though, AFL definitions are a low bar, their definition of "AFL superstar" is anyone with more than 3 games
Or Brian Taylor's Calder Cannons Footy Factory etcTop 55 I can see that.
To be fair though, AFL definitions are a low bar, their definition of "AFL superstar" is anyone with more than 3 games
- Sep 3, 2018
- 5,295
- 6,976
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
I don’t think the competition is nearly as strong as it used to be. Look at the Port team now - which is generally around the mark - and compare that to their early 2000’s team
Depth of player is not what it once was since the expansion
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Top 55 I can see that.
To be fair though, AFL definitions are a low bar, their definition of "AFL superstar" is anyone with more than 3 games
That’s (on average) the top 3 players at each club - seems fair.
Given the 2024 draft is with us next week, who do we all think the Crows should pick at Pick 4 which will most likely become Pick 5 with a bid on Levi Ashcroft? I dare say a number of people would be picking Sid Draper in a heartbeat. For me, I would personally be picking Harvey Langford; the highlights put together by Noobermensch below provide ample justification as to why. Interested in everyone's thoughts.
There another thread already discussing this
www.bigfooty.com
Resource - 2024 AFL Draft discussion thread (Wed Nov 20 to Fri Nov 22)
lol look at the Northern Academy list, the AFL is a farce Most of those aren’t much good this year outside of Ashcroft Marshall and Lombard Next year is a different story , expect 8-10 in top 30
www.bigfooty.com
Similar threads
- Poll
