Position 2024 Rookies

[King_Steele]

Bulldogs must have the most "players worth less than 124k who are probable to make an early appearance" of any club.

Coffield
Bedendo
Darcy
Khamis
Busslinger (?)

Garcia/Clarke as well

Thoughts Northernsoul74

 

[faible]

Bulldogs must have the most "players worth less than 124k who are probable to make an early appearance" of any club.

Coffield
Bedendo
Darcy
Khamis
Busslinger (?)

But also, Bevo. Every chance they all get named in round 1 then play 5 games for the season spread across 4 months.

 

[The_General#1]

Yeah I’ve heard Tsatas has been terrible. Apparently they’ve had kicking coaches working with him and it kinda just sounds like it’s made the problem worse, and probably more mental.

From the 2022 ND only Phillipou, Tsatas and Clarke (Geelong) have not resigned. I'm not convinced Tsatas will get one. His kicking is not even at VFL standard. He's never been a good kick, even at NAB League his efficiency was very very low.

 

[marcmurphy3]

From the 2022 ND only Phillipou, Tsatas and Clarke (Geelong) have not resigned. I'm not convinced Tsatas will get one. His kicking is not even at VFL standard. He's never been a good kick, even at NAB League his efficiency was very very low.

He will get an extension for sure. Getting picked top 10 pretty much guarantees you a 4-6 year career. Even if he completely flops at essendon, someone would take him.

Also, even if his kicking remains poor he could still make it an an inside ball winner. Has the right build and can burst from packs.

That said, not all top 10 picks end up guns. Going by averages a top 10 might produce 3 stars, 5 solid players and 2 busts. Tsatas and Clarke looking the least impressive at the moment though they haven't had much of a go to be fair. Scheezel the only guy I would lock in as a star. Will be much clearer by the end of this year.

 

[Mofra]

Bulldogs must have the most "players worth less than 124k who are probable to make an early appearance" of any club.

Coffield
Bedendo
Darcy
Khamis
Busslinger (?)

Coff and Darcy very likely.
Sanders pretty much locked, killing it this pre-season

Clarke & Gallagher having very good PSs too but forcing their way in might be a challenge. I'd rule out Khamis personally

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Coff and Darcy very likely.
Sanders pretty much locked, killing it this pre-season

Clarke & Gallagher having very good PSs too but forcing their way in might be a challenge. I'd rule out Khamis personally

Where will Darcy jnr play?

 

[Mofra]

Where will Darcy jnr play?

Everywhere. Making the Lobb acquisition look silly. Played ruck, forward and back in match sim. Not quite a need positionally but he's just playing too week too leave him out. Scoring might be an issue though.

We need a small forward so if Clarke is named he could well get an extended run at it

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Everywhere. Making the Lobb acquisition look silly. Played ruck, forward and back in match sim. Not quite a need positionally but he's just playing too week too leave him out. Scoring might be an issue though.

We need a small forward so if Clarke is named he could well get an extended run at it

Interesting, just need 60+ from Darcy. Hopefully he can manage that.

Bulldogs have the R15 bye so it would be handy if they have a few rookies.

 

[The_General#1]

He will get an extension for sure. Getting picked top 10 pretty much guarantees you a 4-6 year career. Even if he completely flops at essendon, someone would take him.

Also, even if his kicking remains poor he could still make it an an inside ball winner. Has the right build and can burst from packs.

That said, not all top 10 picks end up guns. Going by averages a top 10 might produce 3 stars, 5 solid players and 2 busts. Tsatas and Clarke looking the least impressive at the moment though they haven't had much of a go to be fair. Scheezel the only guy I would lock in as a star. Will be much clearer by the end of this year.

Im not so confident, but you would think he will get at least a 1 year extension. As for being an inside mid i'm not so sure as he doesn't like contact. However, he could make a decent HHF with his speed and power. Gryan Miers was the worse kick in the comp but has reinvented himself as the best HHF in the comp.

 

[faible]

Im not so confident, but you would think he will get at least a 1 year extension. As for being an inside mid i'm not so sure as he doesn't like contact. However, he could make a decent HHF with his speed and power. Gryan Miers was the worse kick in the comp but has reinvented himself as the best HHF in the comp.

Genuinely not convinced you've watched Tsatas or Miers play.

 

[The_General#1]

Genuinely not convinced you've watched Tsatas or Miers play.

ok

 

[Northernsoul74]

Bulldogs must have the most "players worth less than 124k who are probable to make an early appearance" of any club.

Coffield
Bedendo
Darcy
Khamis
Busslinger (?)

Agreed. All 5 a chance plus Gallagher and Clarke.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Garcia/Clarke as well

Thoughts Northernsoul74

Garcia just had a shoulder clear up. Just cannot stay fit.

 

[JT_the_Man]

From the 2022 ND only Phillipou, Tsatas and Clarke (Geelong) have not resigned. I'm not convinced Tsatas will get one. His kicking is not even at VFL standard. He's never been a good kick, even at NAB League his efficiency was very very low.

He’s shown enough at VFL level that he’ll get another contract.

 

[King_Steele]

My rookie watch list so far:
Curtin
Gibcus
Coffield
Pink
Hore

McKercher
Sanders
Sharp
Clark
Hall

Reid
Watson
Wilson
Cadman
Darcy
Clarke

 

[A Bit Dusty]

I've gone through 6 pages and not one mention of Jaxon Binns. Played 17 games last season in the VFL and Won the Best & Fairest for Carlton averaging 29.8 disposals 7.8 marks & 3 tackles per game. Not sure of his Supercoach scores but he averaged 116 Fantasy points per game. Surely he will play Seniors next season!!!

 

[Deadly6]

I've gone through 6 pages and not one mention of Jaxon Binns. Played 17 games last season in the VFL and Won the Best & Fairest for Carlton averaging 29.8 disposals 7.8 marks & 3 tackles per game. Not sure of his Supercoach scores but he averaged 116 Fantasy points per game. Surely he will play Seniors next season!!!

View attachment 1878354

Nah mate, he's rubbish.

 

[King_Steele]

I've gone through 6 pages and not one mention of Jaxon Binns. Played 17 games last season in the VFL and Won the Best & Fairest for Carlton averaging 29.8 disposals 7.8 marks & 3 tackles per game. Not sure of his Supercoach scores but he averaged 116 Fantasy points per game. Surely he will play Seniors next season!!!

View attachment 1878354

Looking on blues board not many if at all have him in best 22 being a finals contender not sure if he will break through

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Looking on blues board not many if at all have him in best 22 being a finals contender not sure if he will break through

Dusty has a contact at the Bloooooes I reckon, take it to the bank if he's saying that

 

[ArdentEagle]

Isn't Binns kicking that bad that he makes Tsatis look like prime Jarman?

 

[King_Steele]

Isn't Binns kicking that bad that he makes Tsatis look like prime Jarman?

Thoughts on Clay Hall?

 

[marcmurphy3]

Isn't Binns kicking that bad that he makes Tsatis look like prime Jarman?

Not great in juniors but it's actually really good now. Gone from a weakness to a strength.

Doubt he's there round one if all our players are fit but wouldn't take much to happen for him to start getting games.

 

[TryAnHit]

I've gone through 6 pages and not one mention of Jaxon Binns. Played 17 games last season in the VFL and Won the Best & Fairest for Carlton averaging 29.8 disposals 7.8 marks & 3 tackles per game. Not sure of his Supercoach scores but he averaged 116 Fantasy points per game. Surely he will play Seniors next season!!!

View attachment 1878354

If Dow couldn't get a game. Then he's not

 

[marcmurphy3]

If Dow couldn't get a game. Then he's not

Binns will find it easier getting a game then Dow. Less holes in his game and less competition for the spot he's competing for.

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Isn't Binns kicking that bad that he makes Tsatis look like prime Jarman?

Prime Jarman, good marbling, cut off a few nice steaks i reckon.