List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread - Part II

[kool kangas]

It would be a miraculous turnaround to get anything more than 5-6 wins next year which would still most likely see us in the bottom 4.

Again, someone like Houston would barely move the needle for us. He had a good year but is being severely overrated.

but what about if Houston is combined with Parker, Darling, Konstanty and maybe 1 other coming across as well?

 

[Scottroo]

People seriously over rate draft picks.

For every Sheezal there’s a Tsatas or dare I saw, Will Phillips.

 

[DrZaius]

but what about if Houston is combined with Parker, Darling, Konstanty and maybe 1 other coming across as well?

We brought in Logue, Shiels & Tucker in one off-season and it didn't do much for us. They may improve us somewhat but thinking that adding two players at the end of their careers, a guy who hasn't even played a game yet, and a HBF will jumpstart our performances by a significant amount is wishful thinking IMO.

If we trade a top 3 pick it should be for a match winner.

 

[King Hansen]

We brought in Logue, Shiels & Tucker in one off-season and it didn't do much for us. They may improve us somewhat but thinking that adding two players at the end of their careers, a guy who hasn't even played a game yet, and a HBF will jumpstart our performances by a significant amount is wishful thinking IMO.

If we trade a top 3 pick it should be for a match winner.

Lucky Houston is a match winner then.

 

[tales129]

We brought in Logue, Shiels & Tucker in one off-season and it didn't do much for us. They may improve us somewhat but thinking that adding two players at the end of their careers, a guy who hasn't even played a game yet, and a HBF will jumpstart our performances by a significant amount is wishful thinking IMO.

If we trade a top 3 pick it should be for a match winner.

 

[Junk yard]

We brought in Logue, Shiels & Tucker in one off-season and it didn't do much for us. They may improve us somewhat but thinking that adding two players at the end of their careers, a guy who hasn't even played a game yet, and a HBF will jumpstart our performances by a significant amount is wishful thinking IMO.

If we trade a top 3 pick it should be for a match winner.

The way we've picked for the last ten years I think we should be happy with a dual all Australian at the peak of his powers.

 

[iloveireland]

That’s just your opinion.

So you believe no matter what we finish bottom 3 next year?

Even with a good draft and trade result?

I think it’s likely, and you have to trade future picks based on likely outcomes.

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

 

[bennymate]

Parker is almost certainly joining us!

Excellent source, something would have to change dramatically for it not to.

 

[THE_GUN]

View attachment 2118850View attachment 2118852

You guys would be crazy to not offer Balta crazy overs next year as a free agent
CHB problems solved for the next 6-7 years and could swing foward when required. Would be a perfect fit

was discussing this with a north mate just 2 weeks ago and he said he would love it but North wouldnt do it

 

[justroyal]

You guys would be crazy to not offer Balta crazy overs next year as a free agent
CHB problems solved for the next 6-7 years and could swing foward when required. Would be a perfect fit

was discussing this with a north mate just 2 weeks ago and he said he would love it but North wouldnt do it

Ha. Jokes on you. We are crazy enough.
Does the name CCJ ring any bells??

 

[TruRoos7]

Excellent source, something would have to change dramatically for it not to.

Nekminit. Parker gets a sporting goods company sponsorship but only if he stays in Sydeneee

 

[BlueandWhiteinmyBlood]

View attachment 2118850View attachment 2118852

Boak is cooked.

 

[DuckYeah]

Boak? What a busted unit he is these days. Pass

 

[New_Roo]

Boak? What a busted unit he is these days. Pass

Agree that Boak is done but don't see us into him, more see him retiring

Balta be too expensive this year as would want to match the compo, but next year yes if we can break our FA duck. Be a Corr replacement and set then for 5-6 with Logue chom balta and hopefully WD. Cover with KD.

I still see Chom future is back


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[DuckYeah]

Agree that Boak is done but don't see us into him, more see him retiring

Balta be too expensive this year as would want to match the compo, but next year yes if we can break our FA duck. Be a Corr replacement and set then for 5-6 with Logue chom balta and hopefully WD. Cover with KD.

I still see Chom future is back


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

The longer Will Dawson gets to develop in the scoobs, the better he will be. He is still very raw

 

[koshari]

Ha. Jokes on you. We are crazy enough.
Does the name CCJ ring any bells??

with the obvious exception that balta can actually play... but yes, the point remains, and throw in trading for biggy as well, i think i liked it better when we traded for blokes like nauhaus from the tiggers.

 

[buttox]

You guys would be crazy to not offer Balta crazy overs next year as a free agent
CHB problems solved for the next 6-7 years and could swing foward when required. Would be a perfect fit

was discussing this with a north mate just 2 weeks ago and he said he would love it but North wouldnt do it

The crazy part is the rumour we are trying this year mate.
I have no idea If it's true.
Doubt it tbh

 

[Arthur Cloke]

You can't beat drafting/trading like this:

 

[koshari]

You can't beat drafting/trading like this:


View attachment 2118931

well as meatloaf said, 1 out of 9 aint bad...

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Excellent source, something would have to change dramatically for it not to.

Buckle up then! Me thinks about 6pm on Saturday.

 

[Psicosis]

He was 25 when we took him. Plus we were forced to use that free pick, or lose it.

I don't rate him, but he in no way supports the point you are pushing.

The fact that he is a best 22 lock ahead of some of more talented, younger players, is why he supports the point IMO.

 

[Psicosis]

Houston is going to Carlton. Supported them as a kid. His best mate is there. In deep discussions with Vossy. Carlton posturing to not pay overs, which they eventually will.

 

[Passmore]

Buckle up then! Me thinks about 6pm on Saturday.

He'll be sporting a North polo post game.

The scarf on the premiership dais would have been a touch weird.

Sent from my SM-A908B using Tapatalk

 

[Gasometer]

Ohhhhhh this guy….yeh I know him