List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread - Part II

[Disco Dew]

Who would we choose De Koning or Clarry?

De Koning.
But I don’t believe he’s gettable at all.
It’s made up and poor hanners has gone with it.

 

[DuckYeah]

De Koning.
But I don’t believe he’s gettable at all.
It’s made up and poor hanners has gone with it.

Sdk is not going anywhere. TDK is getrable by geelong

 

[My Left Foote]

99.99% of "ITK" is made up. Stevie's just getting in on the act.

The only one I had any faith in his info has gone and ****ed off....

Sent from my SM-A908B using Tapatalk

Who was the one person you had faith in?

 

[Waynesworld]

Curtis would be lucky to hold a spot in some of the top teams

Ya kidding aren’t ya? I wonder how good him and some of our other players would be in a gun side.

Wondering how good he could be in a gun side is purely hypothetical and therefore redundant really, in reality the top teams have better small forwards - Papley, Cameron, Green, Bolton, Miers, Elliott, Rankine, Bailey which he would be behind.

 

[Makeshift Park]

Parker's exit meeting was today

Shouldn't be long now

 

[Disco Dew]

Wondering how good he could be in a gun side is purely hypothetical and therefore redundant really, in reality the top teams have better small forwards - Papley, Cameron, Green, Bolton, Miers, Elliott, Rankine, Bailey which he would be behind.

Curtis being lucky to hold a spot in a top side is also hypothetical tbh

 

[Shinboner1]

the nutters are out in force today

 

[Waynesworld]

Curtis being lucky to hold a spot in a top side is also hypothetical tbh

Maybe, but out of all those I have listed above, if you had the choice, who would you take Curtis over?

 

[Disco Dew]

Maybe, but out of all those I have listed above, if you had the choice, who would you take Curtis over?

I can’t be ****ed. I was just pointing out that it’s all hypothetical lol

 

[Waynesworld]

I can’t be ****ed. I was just pointing out that it’s all hypothetical lol

It's really not that much effort

 

[DocSholl]

Id do next years first for picks 9 and 27 from Fremantle in this years draft is a good trade

I know they may want ammo for Warner but id be surprised if we got much more than pick 9 for the F1.

 

[kool kangas]

Who would we choose De Koning or Clarry?

 

[FootySmartSimpson]

Geelong in many ways is like Collingwood they think every player on their list is worth a 1st round pick

And that every recruit out there has the honour of putting on their colours.

 

[bengrina]

Crack pipe clarry would be a hard NO

 

[HBFlanker]

I know they may want ammo for Warner but id be surprised if we got much more than pick 9 for the F1.

Then we shouldnt do it, but who knows.

 

[BlueandWhiteinmyBlood]

Says who how much of him have you actually seen of him. couple of high lights on big footy Explain in detail why he is not a top 10 pick.

Yeah, unfortunately I’m not in the AFL or recruitment industry as much as I’d love to be. I’m like most of us here, I read the match reports, the draft forums, the phantom drafts, the power rankings and every article I can find on the draftees over a plethora of different media outlets and using all those as a reference point I have found he isn’t in many of any top 10s. Just today I read rookie me central had him ranked at #12 - if I am expected to do more then that please let me know.

Say we had pick 8 and he was expected 10-12 - I’d be happy to reach but not with pick 2, best available thanks.

 

[kool kangas]

Is Melbournes pick#5 to much to ask for to take Oliver and his contract..

 

[King Corey]

Crack pipe clarry would be a hard NO

Bunker in. We'll soon hear from the no-nuance army proposing recruiting him because "He's a gun" like there's absolutely no caveats or risk.

 

[kool kangas]

Bunker in. We'll soon hear from the no-nuance army proposing recruiting him because "He's a gun" like there's absolutely no caveats or risk.

What about if he comes with Melbournes pick#5 ?

 

[Tiberius]

If I have to watch 2 weeks of Sam DeKoning running around for us then suddenly Kangalotto will start to look like a much better idea.

 

[Jello_B]

He’s less important than Butters, JHF, Wines, Bergman (he’s an absolute gun) and Drew (takes opponents to the cleaners weekly).

He’s a very good player no doubt.

He’s not close to being worth that amount of money and/or what Port will be asking for in a trade.

Probably not far off, although he’s a lot better than Drew. His onfield leadership would also be on part with Butters. So in a team that finished second (let’s apply some escapism here and forget we have Hinkley as a coach and we suck in finals) you would be getting one of our top 5 players and one of our best leaders. Houston doesn’t get injured (touch wood) and would likely be a-class for another 5 years.
Surely in the next 5 years with the young group you have coming through you would be expecting to have a go at top 4.
I’ll disclose my bias, but wouldn’t a single pick in this draft at pick 2 be a risk worth taking? In a draft where there is a pretty even spread of talent over the first 8-10 picks?
I can’t see us accepting a pick next year, so it’s probably a ball in your court deal, if you offer pick 2 you can have him, if not he stays. For the record I’d be happy with either.

 

[remfan101]

Crack pipe clarry would be a hard NO

I'd do it if the price is pick ~20. Having one of his best mates (Jy) as captain would surely help him keep his head in the game- he's the perfect age demographic and plays like a Shinboner.

 

[FootySmartSimpson]

If I have to watch 2 weeks of Sam DeKoning running around for us then suddenly Kangalotto will start to look like a much better idea.

I hate kangalotto and am all for personal expression, but headbands (especially en-mass) are for the tip.

 

[shinboner magic]

Probably not far off, although he’s a lot better than Drew. His onfield leadership would also be on part with Butters. So in a team that finished second (let’s apply some escapism here and forget we have Hinkley as a coach and we suck in finals) you would be getting one of our top 5 players and one of our best leaders. Houston doesn’t get injured (touch wood) and would likely be a-class for another 5 years.
Surely in the next 5 years with the young group you have coming through you would be expecting to have a go at top 4.
I’ll disclose my bias, but wouldn’t a single pick in this draft at pick 2 be a risk worth taking? In a draft where there is a pretty even spread of talent over the first 8-10 picks?
I can’t see us accepting a pick next year, so it’s probably a ball in your court deal, if you offer pick 2 you can have him, if not he stays. For the record I’d be happy with either.

How about you watch pick 69 sound and go **** yourself

 

[shinboner magic]

This guy gets it:

Good work
Hope the top 4 next year is the 2 qld and 2 nsw sides - need this Rort to stop asap