List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread - Part II

[Makeshift Park]

SKD should be our main target now. He would fit in perfectly.

I get that we need talls, and I don't mind targeting him, but he's really not the calibre of player that Houston is.

 

[roos 10]

Our F1 being floated for GC's Pick 12...

I would want more then 12

 

[Better Loosen Up]

What's this?

 

[BlueandWhiteinmyBlood]

Our F1 being floated for GC's Pick 12...

Surely something else coming back to us?

 

[The Nostradamus]

This is the only sort of player where I would trade our future first

To get a young gun like SDK not for 27/28 year olds

Allows us to move chom forward

 

[Disco Dew]

Surely something else coming back to us?

Ben king

 

[BlueandWhiteinmyBlood]

Ben king

The steak knives hey.

 

[DesertRoo]

At the Tracs request no doubt. There is a reason he backflipped imo, he gave them an ultimatum. Clarry or me!

Lol if we dangled pick 2, offered the world to Trac to get Melbourne to fret into dumping Clarry, who wants to go play with Jy for pick number 69.

Hats off Mr Brady.

 

[roos 10]

I would want more then 12

Gold coast future 2nd as well

Surely something else coming back to us?

 

[Horace]

I last looked at this thread 127 pages ago. I'm tipping nothing of significance has happened since then.

But if it has please let me know. I might (or might not) have another look in another 127 pages time. (which might even be tomorrow?)

 

[Disco Dew]

I last looked at this thread 127 pages ago. I'm tipping nothing of significance has happened since then.

But if it has please let me know. I might (or might not) have another look in another 127 pages time. (which might even be tomorrow?)

Read the 222 pages. No short cuts!

 

[spurs]

I get that we need talls, and I don't mind targeting him, but he's really not the calibre of player that Houston is.

I'd say Houston will stay so if SDK is available he's the one and he is a better age demographic.

 

[roos_fanatic08]

This makes absolutely no sense at all.

1.He was being highly touted as one of the best up and coming key defenders even at the mid way point of this year.
2. Geelong only have Connor O'Sullivan as an up-and-coming key defender. As a whole list they don't have stacks of developing talls.
3. De Koning is just touching the base of his potential. At 23 years old he has stacks of upside to come.

Alarm bells would be ringing if they decided to move him on. Geelong never let go of anyone decent.

 

[rickety]

This makes absolutely no sense at all.

1.He was being highly touted as one of the best up and coming key defenders even at the mid way point of this year.
2. Geelong only have Connor O'Sullivan as an up-and-coming key defender. As a whole list they don't have stacks of developing talls.
3. De Koning is just touching the base of his potential. At 23 years old he has stacks of upside to come.

Alarm bells would be ringing if they decided to move him on. Geelong never let go of anyone decent.

Dirty in being dropped a couple of times …

 

[Tas]

When is Oliver due to have his baby? :stern look

 

[roos_fanatic08]

Dirty in being dropped a couple of times …

If that's the case, then I'd happily throw a big carrot in front of him.

De Koning would shore up our spine and allow Comben to Settle forward.

 

[Shinboner1]

This makes absolutely no sense at all.

1.He was being highly touted as one of the best up and coming key defenders even at the mid way point of this year.
2. Geelong only have Connor O'Sullivan as an up-and-coming key defender. As a whole list they don't have stacks of developing talls.
3. De Koning is just touching the base of his potential. At 23 years old he has stacks of upside to come.

Alarm bells would be ringing if they decided to move him on. Geelong never let go of anyone decent.

he didnt want to ruck
He had to ruck
Now he dont like them anymore

 

[roos 10]

A

If that's the case, then I'd happily throw a big carrot in front of him.

De Koning would shore up our spine and allow Comben to Settle forward.

nd get his brother next year free agent key fwd darling plays vfl

 

[Merlin007]

At the Tracs request no doubt. There is a reason he backflipped imo, he gave them an ultimatum. Clarry or me!

Petracca 2 - Melbourne 0

First the President, now Oliver

 

[Merlin007]

he didnt want to ruck
He had to ruck
Now he dont like them anymore

Especially when it’s your brother beating you up in the ruck

 

[Merlin007]

If that's the case, then I'd happily throw a big carrot in front of him.

De Koning would shore up our spine and allow Comben to Settle forward.

I think one of our posters relayed Carlton itk that Carlton would use pick 11 for SDK, hence port spitting the dummy over their offer for houston

 

[Waynesworld]

What's this?

Thats a tweet on X (Formally known as Twitter)

 

[The Nostradamus]

he didnt want to ruck
He had to ruck
Now he dont like them anymore

Yep they have seriously mismanaged SDK

Time to pounce and let SDK play every game in his preferred position

They can use the future first they get from us to go get smith

 

[Moti]

I assumed he would end up wing or HFF next year

I have him HF, Wing and in the middle with the very occasional run across HB.

We need his speed in the middle.

 

[chubbspeterson]

Who are you thinking then?

Josh rachele is one I think we should be looking to bring home and after him getting dropped and hung out to dry could be gettable

The guy doesn't know anything, he's just claiming they're up to something big for starters.
And I just don't think we're a chance to get either of them as those teams would be wanting to hold onto them and even if those guys left they'd be nominating Carlton.

SDK has gone backwards as a defender this year, so much so they threw him in the ruck to get him out of a slump.
Cats seem unsure of what his best position is long term. I'd prefer SDK out of the two because he's younger.