Certified Legendary Thread 4th Test Border Gavaskar Trophy December 26-30 1000hrs @ the MCG

[Cmarsh]

Watching it now. What deflection? Maybe by 1 mm. Your eyes are playing tricks

Thanks Sunny.

 

[Pakenhamsaint]

lololol that line is more bent the bumrahs armView attachment 2195497

That ball is off to Swan Street

 

[Skull Face]

Pff watching the same replay a green line on the same trajectory as hawkeye wow.

There is a 25 degree turn in the green line as it passes the bat and it isn't curved, even the most delusional 1 eyed indian fan would come to accept he hit the cover off it by now what is your problem?

 

[The hands of stone]

Well one of the great test matches .

Credit needs to go to Konstas to begin with . Didn't love some of his batting but it worked, got Australia ahead in the game and simple rattled India .

Kohli's shoulder charge ,Bumrah the only time we have been on top of him and the rest seemed more worried with him then the game for 90 minutes. Was a game/series changer.
Smith back in town , Marnus gutsy not pretty and in short Cummins a worthy MOM .....what a star .

India will rue not making the tough call of dropping Rohit and bringing Gill in.
Reddy is a high talent and will be a thorn for teams around the world .
Jaiswal has a bit of the 'entitled' top order bat about him at the minute .
Rohit is bbqd , Virat not far behind .
Pant well he just opened the door up .

Cracking game bring on Sydney

 

[Black Diamond]

A small part of me is willing to give Jaiswal the benefit of the doubt for questioning the reversal.

He could legit have not seen the deflection in the screen and wondered given no snicko.

In the same situation the Australians are obviously hoping to see deflection. Confirmation bias.

The Akash argument was absurd though.

He knew he hit it.

 

[adogsfan5]

Not a bad result for a side that’s supposedly cooked! Well done lads, one of the best test matches ever.

 

[Run n Spread]

Well one of the great test matches .

Credit needs to go to Konstas to begin with . Didn't love some of his batting but it worked, got Australia ahead in the game and simple rattled India .

Kohli's shoulder charge ,Bumrah the only time we have been on top of him and the rest seemed more worried with him then the game for 90 minutes. Was a game/series changer.
Smith back in town , Marnus gutsy not pretty and in short Cummins a worthy MOM .....what a star .

India will rue not making the tough call of dropping Rohit and bringing Gill in.
Reddy is a high talent and will be a thorn for teams around the world .
Jaiswal has a bit of the 'entitled' top order bat about him at the minute .
Rohit is bbqd , Virat not far behind .
Pant well he just opened the door up .

Cracking game bring on Sydney

Absolutely set momentum and smith and Labaschagne benefited. Twists and turns and went deep into day 5 great cricket

 

[ABAB]

A small part of me is willing to give Jaiswal the benefit of the doubt for questioning the reversal.

He could legit have not seen the deflection in the screen and wondered given no snicko.

In the same situation the Australians are obviously hoping to see deflection. Confirmation bias.

The Akash argument was absurd though.

He knew he hit it.

Provided he didn't tell Head before the decision that he hit the ball.......

 

[HK_Hawk]

Was a strange looking lineup, but really Reddy and Washington were chosen as batsman ahead of Gill. They barely bowled more than Marsh and Head and to be fair to them, they were two of their best batsman in the first innings.

Their biggest issue is the guy who should have been dropped is their captain. And the guy who should have been next in line to be dropped is seen as a god.

And long may they keep their captain and god in the team… lol

 

[Run n Spread]

He deserved to be out for even trying that shot in the circumstances.

For the record he smashed it - clearly out

Makes no sense that comment

 

[Borisdog]

I'd love to know what Jaiswal said to Head before the decision came back. Head seemed even more confident he was out after that conversation.

"I will have to go off now anyway and get my broken finger attended to"

In an Indian accent.

You're welcome.

 

[jmac70]

Makes no sense that comment

Ironic.

 

[Run n Spread]

Next you will be telling us N.Daicos is not terrified of physical contact.

Now I really know your full of shit lol

 

[adogsfan5]

Well one of the great test matches .

Credit needs to go to Konstas to begin with . Didn't love some of his batting but it worked, got Australia ahead in the game and simple rattled India .

I know Bumrah played another amazing test match but even his celebration getting Konstas out in the second innings suggests that Konstas was in their heads massively.

 

[tigs2010]

Just got home and watching the replay.
That Jaiswal dismissal in slo mo was not out. A ridiculous decision on review. This test was plagued by non lbw calls of which Jaiswal was a beneficiary today but no way could you over turn that. Cost India the series. Shameful umpiring/ not that bit icc processes.
No way that was conclusive and if a flatline snicko and no hot spot it's simply a not out going with umpires calll
Indian fans at the ground every right to be pissed off

Are your eyes painted on?

 

[Westend]

A small part of me is willing to give Jaiswal the benefit of the doubt for questioning the reversal.

He could legit have not seen the deflection in the screen and wondered given no snicko.

In the same situation the Australians are obviously hoping to see deflection. Confirmation bias.

The Akash argument was absurd though.

He knew he hit it.

Yeah no problem with Jaiswal heaps of players don't know if they hit the ball and question the decision.....f**k me marsh walked off couple of tests ago and he thought he hit it

But for people to question the decision when it was clearly hitting his bat/glove and there was a clear deflection well...you are the biggest Indian shills or something is wrong with your eyes and you need medical advice

it was clear as day

 

[Cmarsh]

A small part of me is willing to give Jaiswal the benefit of the doubt for questioning the reversal.

He could legit have not seen the deflection in the screen and wondered given no snicko.

In the same situation the Australians are obviously hoping to see deflection. Confirmation bias.

The Akash argument was absurd though.

He knew he hit it.

He would have felt that deflection off the face of his bat through his hands.

 

[Borisdog]

Now I really know your full of shit lol

Yeah, needs more data points than that one.

 

[TazHawk15]

Makes no sense that comment

Can I just repeat “You are a ninja in irony”

 

[Black Diamond]

Provided he didn't tell Head before the decision that he hit the ball.......

Yes, so my question for Jaiswal is were you questioning the procedure or questioning the facts?

If procedure, then I can cop that.

 

[Andrew Mc]

Makes no sense that comment

You forgot to quote your comments I think.

 

[Grumpyshades]

Konstas going to silly point and irritating Jaiswal kind of changed the game.

I'm not sure if you're joking, but there was a small period where Jaiswal seemed more intent on trying to hit Konstas than survive..

 

[TazHawk15]

Now I really know your full of shit lol

 

[Orange crush]

Bad angle and super imposing again. Non conclusive shouldn't have been over turned.
Outrageous.

C’mon, man, you’re not even trying now. Lift your game

 

[Run n Spread]

western royboy Adelaide Hawk PhatBoy can a decent cricket poster watch the replay of the Jaiswal dismissal.
it was given not out and over turned on review
your verdict not out/inconclusive and umpires call/ overturned and out?
I'll happily accept their call