Certified Legendary Thread 4th Test Border Gavaskar Trophy December 26-30 1000hrs @ the MCG

Who will win?


  • Total voters
    42
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

My theory Mr Meow probably wasn't even at the ground and never watched it and is going by the majority

Can promise you that Rohit Sharma WAS at the ground, he captained the Indian side, and he has stated in the post match press conference that he thinks Jaiswal hit it.

Oddly enough the majority of people agree with him.
 
Two other things happened that day.

Rick McCosker came out to bat covered in bandages.

& John Lever, on the fence, skulled a can in front of Bay 13.

True dinks.

I saw Rick come out and what bravery. Never saw the skull stig. Mum did get KOK auto for me at a sports function:



On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Ok
western royboy Adelaide Hawk PhatBoy
Your decision these been a bit of conjecture on these boards day 5.
Jaiswal dismissal day 5 hooking given not out reviewed.
Your decisions?
A= not out
B= Inconclusive umpires call
C= overturn out
Replays probably up onyou tube or fox by now.
I'll happily shut up.and accept their call
For the record I think inconclusive and should've stayed not out.
I think you should logoff dude and let the non blind people talk about the match.
Love neese
 
Yes, so my question for Jaiswal is were you questioning the procedure or questioning the facts?

If procedure, then I can cop that.

Simon Taufel said if there is clear deviation then that is good enough for evidence and that snicko doesn't have to show any noise.

It looked clear behind the stumps and the side angle showed it touching the glove.
 
Random fact: Joel Wilson is the first umpire to have 100 player reviews successfully overturn his decisions. This was from the India v England series earlier in the year too
View attachment 2195520
Looks good mate. Michael Gough’s significantly low upheld percentage bears out his quality as an umpire as well.

Did you get these stats from an existing third party resource or do you keep your own stats?
 
Looks good mate. Michael Gough’s significantly low upheld percentage bears out his quality as an umpire as well.

Did you get these stats from an existing third party resource or do you keep your own stats?
This was something I found from the cricket board on Reddit
 
western royboy Adelaide Hawk PhatBoy can a decent cricket poster watch the replay of the Jaiswal dismissal.
it was given not out and over turned on review
your verdict not out/inconclusive and umpires call/ overturned and out?
I'll happily accept their call
I’m working on the track at the Trots - I haven’t had a good study of it - i will do asap
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Certified Legendary Thread 4th Test Border Gavaskar Trophy December 26-30 1000hrs @ the MCG

Back
Top