Autopsy AFL 2019 Round 15: St Kilda v Richmond, 1:10pm AEST Marvel Stadium

[TheShardMan]

You wrote this before you lost to Carlton at home didn’t you?

Lol no. Was only a 3 leg multi and tiges was last leg. Would be in tears if my multi came down to that murphy goal. Hahaha. Thats gambling for ya.

 

[juss]

Lol no. Was only a 3 leg multi and tiges was last leg. Would be in tears if my multi came down to that murphy goal. Hahaha. Thats gambling for ya.

Freo were the last leg of my multi and cost me $250

 

[dean33]

Don’t you check team changes prior to betting, we made 7 changes this round. Only a fool would think we would win by 40+ coming off the bye with those changes. Bet smarter next time

We were 2 metres off winning by 39points, I don’t think it was a bad bet.

 

[TheShardMan]

Don’t you check team changes prior to betting, we made 7 changes this round. Only a fool would think we would win by 40+ coming off the bye with those changes. Bet smarter next time

We were 2 metres off winning by 39points, I don’t think it was a bad bet.

You won by 33 points without getting out of 1st gear. Saints are terrible. It wasn't a stretch to see them get blown out. It was expected. Like I said, thats gambling.

 

[TheShardMan]

Freo were the last leg of my multi and cost me $250

If i could sack Ross for you I would. Hate that prick.

 

[Grin]

No team loves junktime more than Richmond

You really know very little about our game do you.
Perhaps stick to commenting on soccer and netball

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

You really know very little about our game do you.
Perhaps stick to commenting on soccer and netball

I wouldn’t want to embarrass you on the netball board.

 

[Tiger2709]

So he's struggled to kick 30 goals in 15 games, but he's now going to kick 20+ in 7 games with 5 of those against top 8 teams.

That's a quite a Johnny Bigballs call there, Tommy.

He has kicked 31 goals in 14 games so 2.2 per game, 8 games to go at 2.2 is nearly 18 goals so only needs to add an extra 1 or 2 goals more than his current average in a team where the delivery will improve as we get our players back to make 50.

You need to review your numbers champ.

 

[Scanlens Man]

Really liked the kid Marshall, moves well, sold candy to Cotchin which I loved.

Chol's interesting, not sure where that's going to go.

Umpiring after half time terrible - Richmond caught holding the ball plenty (does Martin have his own rules?) and St Kilda constantly infringed in marking contests. At least they didnt have to do a real score review

Not sure the market for Rising star but this kid Stack must have some chance.

 

[Macpotata]

You are very pro Tigers and it's quite concerning. I don't feel comfortable with this on Bigfooty.

How can you not be. I was also going to put Stack along with Bolton, look at the game he played. The guys a gun. Stuck it to the cry babies who bagged him after hugging Betts, which was a great gesture anyway.


Good win by your boys after being up against it early. 4 points are invaluable these days and going into next week it relieves the pressure.

What's the news on the injury front?

 

[Macpotata]

I think it’s time to actually consider Richmond 2017 as an anomaly.

Their midfield is absolutely **** really...

Finishing top of the ladder last season and making the Prelim was a failure.



Get off it.

 

[juss]

What's the news on the injury front?

Still a few good ones out, but getting back there. Rance is the only one who probably won't get back this year, but it's gonna take them all a few weeks to be match fit and find touch again.

 

[dean33]

Still a few good ones out, but getting back there. Rance is the only one who probably won't get back this year, but it's gonna take them all a few weeks to be match fit and find touch again.

Think the number 18 might be a sneaky chance as well...

Redirect Notice

www.google.com.au

 

[juss]

Think the number 18 might be a sneaky chance as well...

Redirect Notice

www.google.com.au

Won't. You couldn't rush him back into a final with no match prep.

 

[dean33]

Won't. You couldn't rush him back into a final with no match prep.

If we are looking like contenders and he’s ticked all the boxes... he could play a vfl game or 2 before the finals start. Rance is a freak and could be the difference between a semi final exit and flag.

 

[juss]

If we are looking like contenders and he’s ticked all the boxes... he could play a vfl game or 2 before the finals start. Rance is a freak and could be the difference between a semi final exit and flag.

That's the only scenario we would have to be a big chance for a flag. If we are looking at multiple away finals in a row and are out of form I wouldn't risk it. If the draw falls our way and we look a genuine chance for a flag with Rance in then go for it if he's passed all the tests.

Just a very tough call because it's either genius or bust. Not to mention if he did it again and missed 2020, that's career over probably. I'm leaning towards it's very unlikely.

 

[dean33]

That's the only scenario we would have to be a big chance for a flag. If we are looking at multiple away finals in a row and are out of form I wouldn't risk it. If the draw falls our way and we look a genuine chance for a flag with Rance in then go for it if he's passed all the tests.

Just a very tough call because it's either genius or bust. Not to mention if he did it again and missed 2020, that's career over probably. I'm leaning towards it's very unlikely.

Our medical guys wouldn’t take risks with him but if they felt he was right to go and we are contenders I reckon we’d play him. Very unique player Alex rance.