Autopsy AFL 2023 Round 20 - Collingwood v Carlton Fri July 28th 7:50pm EST (MCG)

[Toump Ass]

Didn't see Yankee Doodle Dandy gobbing off after the siren, maybe he's learned some manners and decorum the big dumb flog.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Wonder if Brayden Maynard is going to keep talking up how great Collingwood is. How they're the best team.

I absolutely hated that and it has come back to bite very quickly

Win a flag before you talk like that

 

[Aphrodite]

 

[Hippster]

Walsh
Cerra for most of game
Mckay
Kennedy
JSOS
Boyd
Durdin
Williams

Almost half a side. All best 22.

No way.
Durdin comes in you lose an Otties or Martin. He’s ok but he’s not automatic.
Same Boyd.
Williams has been pretty bad.
Silvagni is always dropped. So he can’t be mentioned.
Who are the 8 you take out? If you can show me that I might concede.

 

[Hippster]

Walsh
Cerra for most of game
Mckay
Kennedy
JSOS
Boyd
Durdin
Williams

Almost half a side. All best 22.

And..if 8 is almost half a side, it’s also almost quarter a side.

 

[Robertio]

No way.
Durdin comes in you lose an Otties or Martin. He’s ok but he’s not automatic.
Same Boyd.
Williams has been pretty bad.
Silvagni is always dropped. So he can’t be mentioned.
Who are the 8 you take out? If you can show me that I might concede.

Wrong on Boyd he's best 22 every day of the week.

 

[Hippster]

Wrong on Boyd he's best 22 every day of the week.

Ok.
I’m just looking to see the 8 that miss.
It’s easy to say you are missing 8 of your best 22 (saying it’s almost half a team) but that means you need to name the 8 players who aren’t best 22.
I know and you know he won’t do this as there aren’t 8 guys to name. You say Durdin is best 22 then Otties or Martin aren’t. You say Williams is best 22 then a Newman or Saad need to go.

 

[bourbons]

Lay a finger on Curnow free kick

Most disgraceful umpiring I’ve ever seen

Was owed a few from the 1st half.

Ruck frees were the ones the got me, both ways. Genuine chook lotto

 

[jooce8891]

Didn't see Yankee Doodle Dandy gobbing off after the siren, maybe he's learned some manners and decorum the big dumb flog.

nah but we can all laugh at him for this, while he gets subbed off and newman runs rampant

 

[Magruder]

Get off it. Cerra was BOG before pinging his hammy and he was going at 65%. Acres was your best midfielder in the second half and he went at 65%. Stop acting like Daicos was atrocious tonight. You’re talking about a second year player. What is it exactly you expect of him if you were to call his game average or good?

He played mainly inside, that’s why he had our highest contested possession numbers. Crippa gets criticised constantly for his DE when it’s completely natural for the inside mids to have lower DE%s.

What’s sad is you guys won and you’re sitting here trying to pot a second year player who was close to our best for the whole game. He actually did well considering his quiet first half, which is a credit to the kid.

Ok, so the ‘best player in the comp played well’, you had no injuries and you still got done by an under strength ‘mid table side’

Not sure what your point is.

 

[Robertio]

Ok.
I’m just looking to see the 8 that miss.
It’s easy to say you are missing 8 of your best 22 (saying it’s almost half a team) but that means you need to name the 8 players who aren’t best 22.
I know and you know he won’t do this as there aren’t 8 guys to name. You say Durdin is best 22 then Otties or Martin aren’t. You say Williams is best 22 then a Newman or Saad need to go.

It's a week by week proposition, we've had heaps of injuries in the last two seasons and that's why we call it a best 30 instead of best 22.

 

[jooce8891]

twice in a row for murphy, surely he's due for a week ban? kane was not wrong about it.

 

[bourbons]

Collingwood off a 6day break is the reason they’re losing.

Yep they played a whole 5 hours later than Carlton

 

[bourbons]

Win with grace *head without the umpires there’s about 3 points in this game right now!

Missed the first half?

 

[SC_Power]

Yep they played a whole 5 hours later than Carlton

Agree, it was a sarcasm post.

Port were undefeated through 3 successive 6 day breaks, no comment in media at all.

 

[melbun]

From someone who dislikes both clubs, I thought the umpires were very nice to Collingwood.

 

[Hippster]

From someone who dislikes both clubs, I thought the umpires were very nice to Collingwood.

Agreed. Curnow frees were there.
For the rest of the game Pies were kissed in the di..ck

 

[chickenonachain]

twice in a row for murphy, surely he's due for a week ban? kane was not wrong about it.

That is not a good look will they make an example of him for flopping I don’t think so

 

[Corn Cobbers]

twice in a row for murphy, surely he's due for a week ban? kane was not wrong about it.

Hopefully Maynard is taking notes, in case a block like that happened in a GF

 

[CCurnow3votes]

Would have been nice to see a shot of papa Daicos as the siren went …if he hadn’t left the box already.

 

[Bollox]

Very strong win.
3. Newman superb.
2. Weitering v v good
1. Curnow best target going around at the mom.

 

[Fadge]

Reality is you got smashed, just got over the line against Port, lost to Melbourne and also Lions early in the year. You’re not that good, not against the teams around you anyway.

And by the way, you were at full strength and we were nowhere near it.

So Collingwood have lost 3 games this year, therefore they're 'no good'...

That is genius.

 

[lilJeffyG]

Would have been nice to see a shot of papa Daicos as the siren went …if he hadn’t left the box already.

Yeah, I think they should be consistent when they show him. For example they should have also showed him when Nick had a shot at goal in the last and kicked it out on the full.

 

[The Fantom]

So Collingwood have lost 3 games this year, therefore they're 'no good'...

That is genius.

I said “not that good”… the way you blokes carry on you’d think you’re in the middle of some sort of dynasty.

You haven’t won a thing yet and your one wood is trying to come back from behind.

 

[RAPPA]

twice in a row for murphy, surely he's due for a week ban? kane was not wrong about it.

That’s three opposition players that have floored him. Mustn’t be all that likable.