AFL Round 19: Essendon v Sydney Friday 7:50pm AEST @ES

Who wins?

  • Essendon

    Votes: 44 49.4%
  • Sydney

    Votes: 37 41.6%
  • Draw

    Votes: 8 9.0%

  • Total voters
    89
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

It'going to be a long 4 years then. By the way, the Bombers were superb last night.
With front loading of his contract and his age, whether he actually play another four years is another matter of course. The nine years was as much about locking him away as a Swan for the rest of his career, which is fair enough.

Delighted with the win!
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I thought the first buddy free in the 3rd was fair enough, I was in one of the suites with a perfect view of it (what a kick). It's kinda bs but they pay them enough...

Second was a load of horse shit.
 
I’ve said it nearly every week, but the umpiring has been absolutely appalling all year. I haven’t been an umpire basher prior to this season. They have been unspeakably bad, I don’t know what it is - perhaps all the tweaking with the rules has finally caught up with them.

No 17 (Schmitt) should not be umpiring AFL. He makes shocking call after shocking call every week. Clueless.

I actually think this is the problem. They get asked to change their interpretations so often, they just have no clue anymore. There are patches in some games where they just pay the obvious ones and let it flow, and you think "awesome, they've figured it out", but it never lasts more than a quarter or two.
 
Four years.

Reports of his demise are well exaggerated, and without underplaying the supreme job Hurley did last night, he's clearly not 100% right at the moment.

Yeah, there's clearly something wrong there. Kennedy didn't look his usual self either (suspect from his back jarring last week).
 
Yeah, there's clearly something wrong there. Kennedy didn't look his usual self either (suspect from his back jarring last week).
Yeah, definitely not 100%. It was the first game I could remember in ages where Kennedy didn't completely tear us apart.
 
I actually think this is the problem. They get asked to change their interpretations so often, they just have no clue anymore. There are patches in some games where they just pay the obvious ones and let it flow, and you think "awesome, they've figured it out", but it never lasts more than a quarter or two.
And Schmidt coulndn't bounce the ball to save himself.
 
With front loading of his contract and his age, whether he actually play another four years is another matter of course. The nine years was as much about locking him away as a Swan for the rest of his career, which is fair enough.

Delighted with the win!

Has it been front loaded though? I seem to recall the later years were actually slightly higher (which in theory makes cap sense as it should go up once or twice in nine years). But maybe I’m remembering incorrectly.

I believe they need to count it in the cap though, whether he retires before the contract end or not.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Has it been front loaded though? I seem to recall the later years were actually slightly higher (which in theory makes cap sense as it should go up once or twice in nine years). But maybe I’m remembering incorrectly.

I believe they need to count it in the cap though, whether he retires before the contract end or not.
I thought it had been reported that it was front loaded, could be false for all I know though.
 
It was terrible for both sides i reckon. Both sets of supporters had reason to go apeshit at the umps at various times.
Does the game need fixing or does more investment need to go into the ump dept?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Umpiring dept has a long list of injuries at the moment. More mistakes will be made.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

AFL Round 19: Essendon v Sydney Friday 7:50pm AEST @ES

Back
Top