Gibbs was ranked number 1 by everybody. Selwood went at 7. This was not an example of poor decision making.
Yeah I think when assessing draft decisions you need to look back at how the players were rated. Sometimes it's just luck and every other club would have made the same call.
Dow over LDU and Cerra was very poor by us as all were rated similarly and we picked the fail.
McCartin over Petracca was shocking as most rated Trac 1 but the Saints went needs over best available.
Billings over Bont not so bad. Kelly and Billings were consensus 2 and 3 picks. Almost every club would have done the same. Just bad luck for Saints.