Bulldogs v West Coast - Rd 11, 2016

Remove this Banner Ad

The way deliberate out of bounds is being called is that the majority of whistles is when it was actually accidental ...and then they never call when the player paddles or runs it over deliberately which is 99% of the time.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

It was.

Name me exactly what else he was doing? Went for the line, deliberate.
But he didn't take it out of play deliberately. He tried to handball it inside the boundaries. It went inside but then bounced outside the boundaries. That tells me that he was trying to keep it in play rather than deliberately taking the ball out of bounds
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

When people say we get a free ride from the umpires at home, they dont realise that its usually during games that we would win regardless.

The reason the umpires favour us at home is it gives license to crucify us away from home when it matters.
 
It was.

Name me exactly what else he was doing? Went for the line, deliberate.
uhhhh legally disposing of it so he wouldn't be caught holding the ball.

you know how it happens a thousand times every match at all locations over the ground? Well, imagine that and now imagine it happens near the boundary.

I mean, players rarely actually need to legally dispose of it in the stoppages. He did then, but no..you will be penalised because we're in a fantasy land of random interpretation.
 
But he didn't take it out of play deliberately. He tried to handball it inside the boundaries. It went inside but then bounced outside the boundaries. That tells me that he was trying to keep it in play rather than deliberately taking the ball out of bounds

Correct. Not deliberate in any sense. Anyone who thinks it is needs to read a dictionary.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Bulldogs v West Coast - Rd 11, 2016

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top