Changes for Collingwood

[ThePezDispenser]

Gotta be a late change, surely?

Sirra... Please

 

[DarwinRoo]

So no change to the team that took it right up to Hawthorn? Absolutely ludicrous. How dare Scott go in with an unchanged line up after a performance like that.

 

[ThePezDispenser]

So no change to the team that took it right up to Hawthorn? Absolutely ludicrous. How dare Scott go in with an unchanged line up after a performance like that.

Yeah but, Sirra..

 

[boneofshin]

I would be expecting some late changes for this one.

Assuming we're still a chance for the Finals of course.

 

[The Nostradamus]

don't see why siera is getting a game, he is not up to it. and i would be surprised if he wasn't delisted, thankfully he is out of contract and not signed yet

 

[Psicosis]

Please, Goldie will smash Grundy to pieces. The Grundy train needs to ease up a little (we all get it the Pies haven't had a good ruck man for a long time so now Grundy is hyped up as Jesus MK 2).

Goldie is a top 3 ruck man and with the help of Petrie he will smash the Pies just like he did last season.

The kid is a dead-set star, to assume that Goldy is going to smash him would only be made by a fool.

 

[Black2Blue]

Yeah but, Sirra..

After months of confusion as to why Adams was getting a game, he is left out having returned to some of his better form in the last month. Hard to justify Sirra over Patch. Perplexed. Again.

 

[Black2Blue]

don't see why siera is getting a game, he is not up to it. and i would be surprised if he wasn't delisted, thankfully he is out of contract and not signed yet

Perhaps a farewell game.

 

[Kimbo]

So no change to the team that took it right up to Hawthorn? Absolutely ludicrous. How dare Scott stubbornly go in with an unchanged line up after a performance like that.

Fixed that for you.

 

[scooby1279]

Surely adams is still injured?

 

[Deleted member 98541]

After months of confusion as to why Adams was getting a game, he is left out having returned to some of his better form in the last month. Hard to justify Sirra over Patch. Perplexed. Again.

injured perhaps?

 

[ThePezDispenser]

Surely adams is still injured?

injured perhaps?

Seems odd to name an emergency that can't play then.

 

[Black2Blue]

injured perhaps?

Could be, but doesn't it usually work the other way? If needing a final fitness test tomorrow would be selected first on the proviso gets through the test. Anyway, won't bother me if he is a late inclusion.

 

[The Maestro]

The kid is a dead-set star, to assume that Goldy is going to smash him would only be made by a fool.

Sorry, but the only fool here is you who thinks a 5 game ruck man can beat Goldie, one of the best rucks in the business.

Back our players in rather than be so pessimistic.

 

[Psicosis]

Sorry, but the only fool here is you who thinks a 5 game ruck man can beat Goldie, one of the best rucks in the business.

Back our players in rather than be so pessimistic.

Yeah, because I said that a 5 man ruckman would beat Goldy didn't I?

I said he wont smash Grundy, which is absolutely true.

How about you learn to read and interpret posts before going on the attack, there is a word for that, I believe it's a fool. Good one.

 

[The Maestro]

Yeah, because I said that a 5 man ruckman would beat Goldy didn't I?

I said he wont smash Grundy, which is absolutely true.

How about you learn to read and interpret posts before going on the attack, there is a word for that, I believe it's a fool. Good one.

Interpreted just fine. You are underselling Goldy which is the underlying tone.

Also, Grundy is NOT an "absolute star", it's just not true, he MAY be a good player and has done a solid job since debut. Some of our supporters are quick to give opposition players credit.

For what it's worth, Goldy will smash Grundy and is one position on the ground where I expect us to get an advantage over the Pies.

 

[nicko74]

Sirra has to come out if we are playing for 8th spot. A liability! Adams if fit. If not Garner for mine. McMahon has eaten too many pies!

 

[Egga]

Surely Siera will succumb to "general soreness" and be replaced by Patch

 

[Psicosis]

Interpreted just fine. You are underselling Goldy which is the underlying tone.

Also, Grundy is NOT an "absolute star", it's just not true, he MAY be a good player and has done a solid job since debut. Some of our supporters are quick to give opposition players credit.

For what it's worth, Goldy will smash Grundy and is one position on the ground where I expect us to get an advantage over the Pies.

Incorrect, you interpreted my post terribly, hence your need to perhaps slow down when reading.

I said he was a dead-set star (if you're going to quote me at least do it correctly), which he is, a super young footballer who is only starting to scratch the surface of his ability, it would be extremely moronic to undersell him and his ability to influence the contest, regardless of only playing 5 games, I'm thankful that Scott and Goldy do not possess the same clueless mindset. They would be wary of Grundys ability and will be very careful in the way they approach it.

 

[Psicosis]

For what it is worth, I believe Goldy will beat Grundy 1 on 1, but it will be a good contest.

 

[The Maestro]

Incorrect, you interpreted my post terribly, hence your need to perhaps slow down when reading.

I said he was a dead-set star (if you're going to quote me at least do it correctly), which he is, a super young footballer who is only starting to scratch the surface of his ability, it would be extremely moronic to undersell him and his ability to influence the contest, regardless of only playing 5 games, I'm thankful that Scott and Goldy do not possess the same clueless mindset. They would be wary of Grundys ability and will be very careful in the way they approach it.

Of course not, he is not a spud but is no "dead set star". That was my point.

Would you say Goldy is a dead set star just out of interest?

 

[Saintly31]

So no change to the team that took it right up to Hawthorn? Absolutely ludicrous. How dare Scott go in with an unchanged line up after a performance like that.

Yeah, like lets lose "honorably" again by picking the same team rather than making it stronger to win when players appear available

Surely adams is still injured?

You would think so. An absolute nonsense if otherwise.

If Adams is fit, how Siera has got yet another game (after another poor performance) shows Scott prefers personality over performance.

 

[Psicosis]

Of course not, he is not a spud but is no "dead set star". That was my point.

Would you say Goldy is a dead set star just out of interest?

Yeah Goldy is a super footballer, and very good ruckman

 

[Saintly31]

Sorry, but the only fool here is you who thinks a 5 game ruck man can beat Goldie, one of the best rucks in the business.

Back our players in rather than be so pessimistic.

I hope Goldy gives this overhyped player an absolute lesson.

Sick of hearing every young Pies player being the next big thing

 

[DarwinRoo]

Yeah, like lets lose "honorably" again by picking the same team rather than making it stronger to win when players appear available



You would think so. An absolute nonsense if otherwise.

If Adams is fit, how Siera has got yet another game (after another poor performance) shows Scott prefers personality over performance.

The only players who could come into our side to make it stronger are all injured.

If Adams was fit he would be named. He clearly isn't. We gave Jack right up until game day to prove his fitness, if we aren't doing that with Patch then clearly his injury is bad enough to make him unavailable.