And who is ultra injury prone.... I can't see Shaw as a bloke who will carry injuries well......
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Changes for the Richmond game
- Thread starter Pilchard_Adams
- Start date
- Tagged users None
And who is ultra injury prone.... I can't see Shaw as a bloke who will carry injuries well......
Special J will be playing next year. No question. As long as he plays half forward/wing where he will be absolutely damaging...
WaynesWorld19
Moderator
- Moderator
- #403
Every team get analyzed looking for weakspots to the gameplan ....doesn't mean we have been worked out
IMO we are not executing anywhere as good as early in the season.
For example early on our tackling and in particular smothers were a feature .....when was the last smother a Crows player has done?
Which wing/half forward player do you propose he replaces?
C
Cough Porplysia cough cough.
Cough.. fair enough... cough cough
It is the season for it...........
Far cough.
Jaensch definitely has value, but I don't think it's as a defender - unless he doesn't have to defend.
- Jul 25, 2010
- 32,674
- 18,767
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Golden State Warriors NBA Champions
we're a much more attacking team but under Brenton Sanderson, everyone has to defend.
Wasn't Shaw sore today at training?
I saw Shaw by the sea shore and he sure looked sore.
Fwiw, I would have Martin as sub.
Yep it would be a waste for Smith or Knights to be the sub, must be bloody hard, you force your way back in and then you've got to sit on the pine and you've got maybe 30 minutes to make an impact and stake a claim for the following week. You don't have the benefit of ripping it up in the SANFL to get you the attention for a call up.
Douglas for me.
Maybe, but i can see him being just as damaging to us unless he develops a defensive side to his game. He has no impact on a contest so I'm not sure how he intends to gain possession to use his "sublime" foot skills in the forward 50. He is too one dimensional to be a success at this level with too many deficiencies to justify a spot on the list.
Drugs Are Bad Mackay?
Moderator
- May 24, 2006
- 79,730
- 161,733
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Redbacks, Sturt, Liverpool, Arizona
- Moderator
- #418
Polite round of applause.
Anyone want to recant their views in this thread. How many of us dropped Douglas, Porps and Martin?
Footypie32
especias secreto
I think a lot of it (not all), was Douglas and Martin being played out of position. Porps finally threw caution to the wind and was rewarded.
Would still drop Doughty, maybe Reilly.
Porps good, but a footy season isn't one week.
Should be dropped, wont be dropped
Prob minimal changes next week depending on how Pets, VB, Callinan pull up, i expect Tex to be on a nice little two week holiday, would be nice to see Luke Brown get a gig in the Showdown 
As long as Shaun McKernan stays as far away from the side as humanly possible.....
I think id keep Doughty over Reilly. Doughty was bad today but can do a good lock down job. The only thing Reilly has done the last 6 weeks is gift goals to the opposition. Did anyone see that one on one when Reilly grabbed his opponents arm didn't get anywhere near the ball, Richmond player still marked it and lead to a goal? Insipid weak effort.
Johncock or Henderson would give us a lot more drive.
Reilly is not going to get dropped, even though he was back to his error ridden best today. Dogga might actually be under the pump for the first time this year. Not sure who replaces him though, he may not have a direct replacement.
