Preview Changes R13 Bulldogs vs Lions

[Dog 36]

When was the last time we challenged a suspension?

Who knows.

We must appeal this get it to low impact

Daicos punch had more impact and was behind play.

 

[Mojorisin]

Who knows.

We must appeal this get it to low impact

Daicos punch had more impact and was behind play.

I'm hoping we challenge but isn't something we usually do.

 

[Bald]

When was the last time we challenged a suspension?

I reckon it was Jack Redpath.

 

[Snarls Barkley]

I reckon it was Jack Redpath.

Was that when he got 3 for a clear Phil Davis dive? That was embarrassing

 

[Bald]

Was that when he got 3 for a clear Phil Davis dive? That was embarrassing

He got 1 that was upgraded to 2 on appeal, then because he played a VFL game whilst suspended they added a further week.

 

[Bald]

I'm hoping we challenge but isn't something we usually do.

We actually haven't had a lot of suspensions in recent times in fairness, especially since they scrapped the punishment for appealing. You never want to not have your best players out there but having a bit of mongrel is something we've needed for a long time so I'm somewhat welcoming of it.

 

[Chalky White]

Bramble, Daniel and Gallagher very lucky that the injuries/suspensions have occurred. All 3 appallingly bad. Gallaghers skills, Bramble brainfades and Daniel has just been worked out and slowed.

 

[Libbaaaa]

Bramble, Daniel and Gallagher very lucky that the injuries/suspensions have occurred. All 3 appallingly bad. Gallaghers skills, Bramble brainfades and Daniel has just been worked out and slowed.

Don’t know what game you were watching bud if you think Gallagher had an omittable performance.

 

[maddog37]

Bramble, Daniel and Gallagher very lucky that the injuries/suspensions have occurred. All 3 appallingly bad. Gallaghers skills, Bramble brainfades and Daniel has just been worked out and slowed.

 

[grassman75]

When was the last time we challenged a suspension?

Reckon it was probably the Redpath push on Diver Davis and his 3 weeks got turned into 4.

 

[grassman75]

He got 1 that was upgraded to 2 on appeal, then because he played a VFL game whilst suspended they added a further week.

I thought he ended up with 4

 

[Bald]

I thought he ended up with 4

Yep you’re right. Was originally 2, upgraded to 3 and then another added on for the VFL game.

 

[Next Waiting]

Yep you’re right. Was originally 2, upgraded to 3 and then another added on for the VFL game.

It's comical how badly we've been screwed over by the judiciary. Not just the excessive suspensions that we've historically incurred but the lenient treatment of those who've transgressed against us.

 

[stefoid]

Winning has to come first. I don't have any confidence Khamis or Bedendo will help us do so, nor do I think any of our small forwards are in strong enough goal kicking form for us to win with a smaller forward line.

I remember when we struggled to find 1 decent key dorward and now we are down to 2 and everybody panics and wants to throw a defender forward?

We can rotate mids through the forward line, cant we?

 

[grassman75]

Yep you’re right. Was originally 2, upgraded to 3 and then another added on for the VFL game.

It was a disgrace

 

[Bald]

It was a disgrace

Further, wasn’t the VFL game a practice game?

 

[ossie_21]

When was the last time we challenged a suspension?

Duryea last year v Eagles, ban was upheld

 

[Testekill]

Surely we can argue the impact down to low for West.

 

[cherrypie]

Further, wasn’t the VFL game a practice game?

It was. Ridiculously, he was eligible to play in AFL pre-season practice games but not VFL practice games because the VFL practice game was the week of AFL Round 1.

It was so dumb I can remember Chris Scott even made an unprompted comment about how stupid it was.

"A jumper push to the throat is innocuous. It doesn't get much more innocuous when it comes to the MRP. Now we've got guys getting three weeks."

 

[dogwatch]

West suspension is a joke, Howe wasn’t even taken off the field ffs.

Darcy for 2 is extremely harsh as well, how it can be equal to Pickett’s shoulder charge to the face is beyond me

Because the rule has changed since the Pickett on Bailey incident.

 

[perro_loco]

Think Libba and Richards comes back in for VDM and Harmes but not sure who comes in for Darcy as he will most likely be suspended.

 

[perro_loco]

Go Dogsz with Libba, Richard’s and anyone else back we win!

 

[fred cook]

I am not sure of his name but he wears the number 4 for the Western Bulldogs. I think he could play a little resting forward role.

On CPH2305 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[lachy]

Bramble, Daniel and Gallagher very lucky that the injuries/suspensions have occurred. All 3 appallingly bad. Gallaghers skills, Bramble brainfades and Daniel has just been worked out and slowed.

There may have been times when this was true but really poor take from not only this game but the last couple with the exception of Bramble.

Gallagher seems to have that time he kicks into the man on the mark too often but his skills are far from deplorable.

Daniel is one yes I would trade but in the last couple of games has certainly earned his spot

On SM-S926B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[lachy]

Seen a few suggesting Clarke. However if you have been watching the VFL though I still have serious doubts about him Artie Jones is way ahead of him at the moment

On SM-S926B using BigFooty.com mobile app