Preview Changes: R20 2019 v St Kilda: it's a SUSHI-PIZZA PARTY!!

[skam85]

How is Wilson not in the list? His effort as an AFL footballer on Saturday was cringeworthy.

We played him out of the goal square at six centre bounces.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

We played him out of the goal square at six centre bounces.

Well, we are stupid

 

[OzSparrow]

We played him out of the goal square at six centre bounces.

Was that because we were trying to hide him?

He was positively awful to watch at the ground on Saturday. Ran around like a startled gazelle and his airswing miskick pass summed up his performance.

Made D-Mac look truly Fyfe-like in direct comparison.

But hey at least he didn't squib out of the contest like several of our big-named so-called stars.

 

[Brenton Davy]

As for current players not hungry you need your top 5 highest paid $$$$ players playing to the wages they are paid, imagine if Richmond had Dusty and Cotchin their big paid guns failing, you may aswell write them off aswell

Collingwood had most of their big $ players out with injury last year and this. Can’t say that team hasn’t, for the most part, performed. It’s more about the quality of your depth

 

[marty36]

Collingwood had most of their big $ players out with injury last year and this. Can’t say that team hasn’t, for the most part, performed. It’s more about the quality of your depth

Will they challenge?

Who are the pies top 5 would you say

Ill give you two Grundy and Pendlebury

 

[Brenton Davy]

Will they challenge?

Who are the pies top 5 would you say

Ill give you two Grundy and Pendlebury

They challenged last year and barely lost a grand final they led for 90% of the game. Their injury list read like a who’s Who of their list throughout the year

 

[Mike Smyth]

Eddie back this week - lol - this club has lost it.

 

[marty36]

They challenged last year and barely lost a grand final they led for 90% of the game. Their injury list read like a who’s Who of their list throughout the year

The call was our top 5 or 6 highest paid players are pretty much failing

Tex
Sloane
Talia
Betts
Gibbs
Crouch

has collingwood had the same service out of their top 6

The highest paid players at any club are that for a reason, without them we are screwed dont expect murphy atkins mackay to have the output of the 6 mentioned on the big Bickie$$$$$$ they are paid that for a reason

 

[marty36]

Eddie back this week - lol - this club has lost it.

In the top 5 money earners at the club is eddie

 

[skam85]

The call was our top 5 or 6 highest paid players are pretty much failing

Tex
Sloane
Talia
Betts
Gibbs
Crouch

has collingwood had the same service out of their top 6

The highest paid players at any club are that for a reason, without them we are screwed dont expect murphy atkins mackay to have the output of the 6 mentioned on the big Bickie$$$$$$ they are paid that for a reason

Collingwood's top 6 players would probably be injured, and boy would we hear about it

 

[Mike Smyth]

In the top 5 money earners at the club is eddie

So?

 

[thebirdman 24]

Eddie back this week - lol - this club has lost it.

Don't mind Ed back, just hope Stengle remains in.

 

[marty36]

So?

Do you expect the same output out of Murphy as sat eddie on the big $$$ ?

If eddie is paid the big $$ he needs to be in and doing what he is paid for

 

[marty36]

Collingwood's top 6 players would probably be injured, and boy would we hear about it

Pretty sure Pendlebury and Grundy havent missed a game

 

[skam85]

Pretty sure Pendlebury and Grundy havent missed a game

it was a joke because #collingwoodhaveinjuries

 

[MRB37]

Lots of rumours that Atkins is out.

 

[SuperBashBros]

Lots of rumours that Atkins is out.

We can only hope these are true.

 

[footy4ever]

How is Wilson not in the list? His effort as an AFL footballer on Saturday was cringeworthy.

I don't know why so much Wilson love. He is bog ordinary. Not AFL standard. It has nothing to do with lack of games played in the A's.

 

[Murray2503]

Unchanged. Back em in.

 

[TexForPM]

Lots of rumours that Atkins is out.

please

 

[Anzacpaul]

Knight had confirmed he's in.

 

[relapse]

Eddie back this week - lol - this club has lost it.

I'm fine with Eddie being back provided that it's not at the expense of Stengle or Murphy.

I want us to have the three of them playing up forward at the same time to provide more forward line pressure and I want to see how Eddie plays for the rest of the year with Stengle in the side.

However if it's OUT: Stengle IN: Betts then the club has officially has no clue

 

[footy4ever]

Would like to see Eddie with Stengle again. Best way for Stengle to learn on match day.

Im not sold on having Stengle learn the trade. He really is as slow a small forward as I've ever seen. He's no doubt clever but jeez how many more plodders can we add to this team?

There was so much hype about him before he got a game I couldn't wait to see him play AFL. I had visions of a cross between Charlie C and Eddie.

The reality is disappointing. Lovely chappy. Clever. But worried about his lack of speed.

 

[Thegibbsgamble]

The match committee must feel like old fashion garbage collectors, always picking rubbish up.

Betts has been a liability for a month.
Gibbs is a liability.

These are the guys who will be rewarded for someone else's ineptness.

 

[MrBarry]

Im not sold on having Stengle learn the trade. He really is as slow a small forward as I've ever seen. He's no doubt clever but jeez how many more plodders can we add to this team?

There was so much hype about him before he got a game I couldn't wait to see him play AFL. I had visions of a cross between Charlie C and Eddie.

The reality is disappointing. Lovely chappy. Clever. But worried about his lack of speed.

Betts was never overly quick, but has kicked over 600 goals. That first goal Stengle kicked on the weekend showed a lot for me, balance and enough speed of mind to get away from his opponent.

Maybe I'm old school but I don't need every single small forward running around like they've just done a bag of gear, I want goals.