Changes v GWS

[John the Butcher]

In: Young 'uns
Out: Who cares

 

[Power Raid]

Out
O'Shea - Genuinely shit footballer and has been in every year of his career apart from 2013. The fact that he has so many fanbois on here astounds me.
Moore & Young - Had their chance to step up today with Wines out. Neither of them did anything.
Colquhoun - I like him as a player generally, but just about every one of his disposals today went straight to the opposition. A player like him who likes to take his time is always going to struggle big-time if his teammates aren't working hard enough to make options for him.

I'd like to have Lobbe out too, but unfortunately Harvey and Redden both stunk it up today.

Neade probably did less than Young or Moore, but I'd leave him in ahead of those two based on him having more upside than either of those two. I wouldn't really be complaining if he was dropped for someone like Jesse Palmer though.

In
Monfries - 26 touches and 4 goals in the SANFL today. Got dropped, took it like a man and had a big game in the SANFL to earn his way back in. Take note, Jonas.
Krakouer - 19 touches and 3 goals, we desperately need his kicking skills back in the side. If he's so terribly unfit, make him sub.
Ah Chee & Amon - Moore and Young have had their chances and haven't taken them. The season is shot. Both Ah Chee and Amon racked up the ball in the SANFL. Time to start getting games into the next generation of second string midfielders.

Please no Mitchell. He had 38 touches and a goal in the SANFL today. I don't care. It's well and truly proven time and time again that he can't translate that form to AFL level, and he needs to go at the end of the year.

agree re the outs but would prefer to look at DBJ, Shaw, Butcher, Harvey etc

even giving Redden another run before the year is through

 

[OneGreatClub]

S

In: Young 'uns
Out: Who cares

Strengthen the Maggies. They are finals bound

 

[PAFC66]

Missing in action. Koshe.

 

[Finest of Wines]

In: Monfries, Krak, Harvey and Palmer

Out: moore, young, neede, lobbe

 

[PAFC66]

Lobbe out. I think Ken has finally had enough.

I don't care about the other changes.

2 possessions in 3 quarters. Wow thats horrible. He also has 4 years on his contract. Lol

 

[Traveling_Power]

I am sick of people say in delist or drop Hoon. I think we should give him a chance wait until he has 40+ games under his belt before deciding on what to do with him. Also he is our youngest player who has played 15 games and he can be get a lot of the ball ... I am sure once he has the experience he can be a very good player for us

 

[QPower]

The lack of care and effort has been apparent all year and we have been building to that performance today.

The problems are fundamental and the Club needs to stop dealing in diversionary tactics such as citing a lack of confidence.

This coaching group are out of ideas and the playing group lazy and complacent.

A few ins and outs won't fix these real problems.

 

[Black 18]

I am sick of people say in delist or drop Hoon. I think we should give him a chance wait until he has 40+ games under his belt before deciding on what to do with him. Also he is our youngest player who has played 15 games and he can be get a lot of the ball ... I am sure once he has the experience he can be a very good player for us

Doesn't matter if you're young, if you've played 90 games or 5, if you can't find targets, if you can't compete physically you haven't a place in the side until you can.

Play in the SANFL until you can perform at the highest level possibly for weeks on end then get your AFL chance.

I don't think he'll ever make it but probably has a little more time on his side before it's curtains.

This notion to gift players games thinking it leads to improvement is flawed.

 

[Contested Marx]

In: Jennifer Hawkins

I know, she will probably have a Neade-like impact but at least the game will be worth watching.

 

[Contested Marx]

Ah, who am I kidding. She'd get more touches than Neade and Moore combined.

 

[yepits2020]

Time to blood some players.

I would keep Monfries out.

Neede has disappointed. Maybe Palmer for him. I know it's not like for like, but we have too many smells.

Schulz dropped for Harvey to crash the packs (assuming he is fit). I know his SANFL stats were not good.

Mitchell for Hoon and play him for the rest of the year. HOON WILL BE BETTER FOR THE RUN.

BUTCHER in for O'Shea. Love O'Shea, but WTF.

WHAT IS DISTRESSING IS WE HAVE NO MID FIELDERS TO BRING IN TO TRY OUT.

KRAK FOR I DO NOT KNOW WHO.

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

I'd seriously consider dropping Ebert.

I'm starting to believe in the "send him to an optometrist" theory

 

[b0ydman]

I honestly don't care, but Sam Gray must stay in. He was one of our best today, if not our best, which says a lot about our 'elite' talent.

I think that Sam grey is a spud.

However he earned his right to day to be in next week.

Just cut Ken. I want 5 players out and 5 players in.

As long as Kane Mitchell doesn't come in just play new players please

 

[BIG DADDY]

In: Young 'uns
Out: Who cares

Agree totally
Bring in anyone that even look like they want a game
Hoon out
Gray out
Young out
Shultz out
Lobbe out

 

[Long live PAFC]

Hmmm tough cause the theory is your should only make 4-5 changes in a week!

So why did Pittard not have to get through a SANFL game before coming back in?

Anyway for me match ups are out the window, play the guys who want to be there. S.Gray, Kane Mitchell, the Krak, Amon, Ah Chee, Monfries showed form today. Harvey or Shaw why not. Hoon, Clurey, Neade all worked hard but just weren't always effective, so should stay. What were we really expecting of them?

 

[ctpower]

I'd seriously consider dropping Ebert.

He's a shadow of the player from last year

 

[Andre]

As long as Lobbe is an out and one of Butcher, Harvey or Shaw is an in I'll accept it that Ken has finally started to realise his selection policies up to this point have been a contributing factor to our season of poo.

Full in's and out's if I was the selection committee though:

Outs: Lobbe, Moore, Young, O'Shea, Hoon
Ins : Harvey, Amon, Ah Chee, Krakouer, Monfries

Ken will spin shit that wholesale changes are panic, drop two of Moore, Young, Hoon and O'Shea, bring in Mitchell and another small, whilst watching Leonardo Di Caprio see if he can re-arrange all the deckchairs before the boat goes fully under.

 

[Long live PAFC]

I think that Sam grey is a spud.

However he earned his right to day to be in next week.

Just cut Ken. I want 5 players out and 5 players in.

As long as Kane Mitchell doesn't come in just play new players please

Whilst I know the idea about wasting a spot on him, Mitchell's endeavour can never be doubted. I'd give him a game over someone who isn't giving it 100%.

 

[Footy Matt]

Out

Lobbe
Scultz
O' Shea
Hoon or Neade
Moore
Young

In

Harvey
Palmer
Krak
Monfries
Ah Chee
Amon

Season is officially over. There's no denying it. Time to start preparing for next year, blooding some youngsters, and seeing who and who doesn't have what it takes.

 

[SgtSchulz]

Out: Everyone who will not be at the club next year.
In: Anyone who will be at the club next year.

 

[1954]

Ah, who am I kidding. She'd get more touches than Neade and Moore combined.

She would def get more touches, but the footy may not be in the vicinity.

 

[b0ydman]

Ah, who am I kidding. She'd get more touches than Neade and Moore combined.

Laces out, swallow the ball, right down her throat.

Some players would ..better stop there

 

[Holden Hillbilly]

Out: Kern

In: Lets back Jack

 

[1954]

Missing in action. Koshe.

There is no doubt Kochie has been very quiet since he copped a royal shellacking from a heap of members of this site for his ` I love yous all ' persona a few weeks back, maybe the message was received.