Changes v GWS

[PAFC66]

There is no doubt Kochie has been very quiet since he copped a royal shellacking from a heap of members of this site for his ` I love yous all ' persona a few weeks back, maybe the message was received.

Yeah ****wit. Hope he gets bored and buggers off.. He's been great initially but so embarrasing.

 

[Andre]

Yeah *******. Hope he gets bored and buggers off.. He's been great initially but so embarrasing.

Pfftt. Idiotic statement. He has been and still is a great asset for the club. Just his only involvement in game day activities should be being in the crowd.

 

[raman]

Pfftt. Idiotic statement.

Look who you're responding to.

 

[PAFC66]

Nah he's a ****ing embarrassment. The sooner he leaves the better

 

[BornPort]

Nah he's a ******* embarrassment. The sooner he leaves the better

 

[Wargreymon90]

We need to put on size this off season.

 

[iskaral]

In: working out why so many players are a flipping shadow of 2014-14
Out: not sorting it out

Blah blah blah - good hard look in the mirror.

**** that - get in players that wont embarrass the club, themselves or the supporters.

Such a waste of a year.

 

[PeacefulWarrior]

Post of the week

 

[Rexie J]

Yeah *******. Hope he gets bored and buggers off.. He's been great initially but so embarrasing.

Arrant nonsense

 

[Black 18]

genuine LOL

 

[1954]

Yeah *******. Hope he gets bored and buggers off.. He's been great initially but so embarrasing.

Bit harsh wanting him to bugger off, his financial expertise may be needed more than ever if the band wagoner members begin to jump off after this season ( I expect the club will have a fight on it's hands to stay above 50,000 next year ), but there is little doubt a clamp needed to be put on his, at times arguably naive public persona.

 

[Wargreymon90]

Krakour should never have been dropped this year. We need smart players like him.

We have players with amazing talent. But at the same time, we probably have some of the dumbest players going around

 

[Interstater]

Out: Constant talk of who we should trade out to get Dixon
In: 50,000 supporters at AO next weekend, so that the players will have to look us in the eye if they play like that again

 

[RossFC]

We still have 4 more games?

My eyes have seen enough.

 

[x_les_x]

I agree with having krakouer spend 1 week in the sanfl just to get up to pace and test his hammy in return from injury. It was a more cautious approach, say he played against the dogs today he could have tore it quicker and re injured it again to suit afl pace. He will be better for it which will see his inclusion this week.

In:
Mitchell - ala sam gray type of selection, as much as everyone doesn't want him as an in on our board he's definitely coming in on form
Redden - didn't have his best game today apparently but is our only replacement for lobbe
ah chee - good form deserves another go
palmer - might aswell debut
Monfries - responded to his omission well
Byrne Jones - travelling emergency today might as well give him a go

Out:
Moore
O'Shea
Lobbe and pittard - I don't know what purpose dropping these 2 senior players to the reserves sends a message and what not but with 4 games left but they should be an out
Colquhoun
Young

wouldn't surprise me if pittard and young keep there spots

 

[RossFC]

IN: Redden, Ah Chee, Monfries, Krakouer, Amon
OUT: Lobbe, Moore, Young, O'Shea, Colquhoun

If Harvey plays well vs Glenelg next week I'd send Schulz to Freo early.

 

[BIG MATTY WHITE]

I'd seriously consider dropping Ebert.

This would be kens statement

 

[ab56452001]

Out
O'Shea - Genuinely shit footballer and has been in every year of his career apart from 2013. The fact that he has so many fanbois on here astounds me.
Moore & Young - Had their chance to step up today with Wines out. Neither of them did anything.
Colquhoun - I like him as a player generally, but just about every one of his disposals today went straight to the opposition. A player like him who likes to take his time is always going to struggle big-time if his teammates aren't working hard enough to make options for him.

I'd like to have Lobbe out too, but unfortunately Harvey and Redden both stunk it up today.

Neade probably did less than Young or Moore, but I'd leave him in ahead of those two based on him having more upside than either of those two. I wouldn't really be complaining if he was dropped for someone like Jesse Palmer though.

In
Monfries - 26 touches and 4 goals in the SANFL today. Got dropped, took it like a man and had a big game in the SANFL to earn his way back in. Take note, Jonas.
Krakouer - 19 touches and 3 goals, we desperately need his kicking skills back in the side. If he's so terribly unfit, make him sub.
Ah Chee & Amon - Moore and Young have had their chances and haven't taken them. The season is shot. Both Ah Chee and Amon racked up the ball in the SANFL. Time to start getting games into the next generation of second string midfielders.

Please no Mitchell. He had 38 touches and a goal in the SANFL today. I don't care. It's well and truly proven time and time again that he can't translate that form to AFL level, and he needs to go at the end of the year.

Well said and reasoned , but if was good enough for Guss , why not for Ebert ? , and there in lies the problem I reckon.

 

[ab56452001]

Time to see who stays in 2016 and who goes.

Our skills overall are terrible and has been for 5 years. Something needs to be done there.

We need a midfield coach that can coach a mid field. Our mid field sucked today.

That's true ,the problems with our skills or lack of them , and yes even 13/14 I thought our skills were suss , started under guess who ?

 

[ab56452001]

Krakour should never have been dropped this year. We need smart players like him.

We have players with amazing talent. But at the same time, we probably have some of the dumbest players going around

Agree , fit or not , has better skills than 95% of the rest.

 

[AdsGoNads]

I'd seriously consider dropping Ebert.

Hahahahahahaha





Ebert?






Hahahahahahahaha





Mate, he's been our best possession getter all season.. perhaps the only guy playing for the jumper.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Out
O'Shea - Genuinely shit footballer and has been in every year of his career apart from 2013. The fact that he has so many fanbois on here astounds me.
Moore & Young - Had their chance to step up today with Wines out. Neither of them did anything.
Colquhoun - I like him as a player generally, but just about every one of his disposals today went straight to the opposition. A player like him who likes to take his time is always going to struggle big-time if his teammates aren't working hard enough to make options for him.

I'd like to have Lobbe out too, but unfortunately Harvey and Redden both stunk it up today.

Neade probably did less than Young or Moore, but I'd leave him in ahead of those two based on him having more upside than either of those two. I wouldn't really be complaining if he was dropped for someone like Jesse Palmer though.

In
Monfries - 26 touches and 4 goals in the SANFL today. Got dropped, took it like a man and had a big game in the SANFL to earn his way back in. Take note, Jonas.
Krakouer - 19 touches and 3 goals, we desperately need his kicking skills back in the side. If he's so terribly unfit, make him sub.
Ah Chee & Amon - Moore and Young have had their chances and haven't taken them. The season is shot. Both Ah Chee and Amon racked up the ball in the SANFL. Time to start getting games into the next generation of second string midfielders.

Please no Mitchell. He had 38 touches and a goal in the SANFL today. I don't care. It's well and truly proven time and time again that he can't translate that form to AFL level, and he needs to go at the end of the year.

This is crazy talk I know but I would seriously consider playing Frampton. Stand him near the goalsquare let him ruck a few minutes, sit him on the bench now and again. He's genuinely scary.

 

[edgie]

In: Jennifer Hawkins

I know, she will probably have a Neade-like impact but at least the game will be worth watching.

I'd rather be in Jennifer Hawkins, than Jennifer Hawkins be in

 

[edgie]

Are the people calling for Harvey, the same people who deride those who call for Butcher, because of "form" and other pearlers?

 

[Papa G]

Hahahahahahaha





Ebert?






Hahahahahahahaha





Mate, he's been our best possession getter all season.. perhaps the only guy playing for the jumper.

Must be great for your super coach.