List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016 part 2 - see Mod Warning p 281

[Mondi21]

I hope we get WHE would prefer him over Stewart, we had a chance to take Stewart father son a few years ago and didn't take him, so not sure why would won't him now, hasn't done much to impress me at GWS ball hits the ground and his no where to be seen, Marchbank would be a great addition at CHF his a 10yr player, and fits age selection, I'm not too sure about Wells good player when his on the park but that hasn't been a lot lately, his getting order too more risk to injury, if be targeting Marchbank & WHE at this stage.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[ChubbyGallon]

l thought with Sando now onboard we would have a good shot at landing Henderson.
l still think we will get Wells, l think our offer is one he is happy with and will take despite late interest from the Cats.
WHE l keep hearing we will get him but not sure about that, l think he will stay at GWS or end up at Essendon.
Stewart l think maybe the one we will try and pry out of GWS. Also l think a chance to still get Marchbank.

I dont understand the love for Henderson.. Medium Size Half back is someone we dont need.

 

[ChubbyGallon]

I hope we get WHE would prefer him over Stewart, we had a chance to take Stewart father son a few years ago and didn't take him, so not sure why would won't him now, hasn't done much to impress me at GWS ball hits the ground and his no where to be seen, Marchbank would be a great addition at CHF his a 10yr player, and fits age selection, I'm not too sure about Wells good player when his on the park but that hasn't been a lot lately, his getting order too more risk to injury, if be targeting Marchbank & WHE at this stage.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

NOt sure if it was a typo or not but Marchbank is a Defender not a CHF - I'm a fan and would be a great pickup..

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

I'm not too sure about Wells good player when his on the park but that hasn't been a lot lately,

Look at his career stats and that seems to be a myth.

Worth a punt. Tons of room to take an older player.

With Swan (31) Macaffer (28) Cloke (29) Toovey (29) and possibly Brown (28) gone our oldest player is Goldsack (29). And hes probably not even best 22.

Oldest best 22 players are White Pendlebury Greenwood and Varcoe. The rest of the list are born in the 90's so 26 or younger.

 

[Crazy Tails]

I dont understand the love for Henderson.. Medium Size Half back is someone we dont need.

I think it is on the back of the injury uncertainty surrounding; Ramsay/Scharenberg & Sinclair. Henderson is a known quantity who would be gettable as a FA. I'm not keen just trying to rationalise the chatter.

 

[Mondi21]

NOt sure if it was a typo or not but Marchbank is a Defender not a CHF - I'm a fan and would be a great pickup..

sorry mate typo meant CHB

 

[Matt_352]

Love for Henderson is that Ramsay and Shaz will take some time to get going and I see us trading Marley ans well and there is concern over the health of Sinclair with his concussions. He is also a decent kick and good runner.

 

[Prochard123]

Some talk that we've enquired with the Lions about Rockliff.
Not saying we have him or anything...
Tony Sheahan @TonySheahan
Rockliff is see you later #gonski https://twitter.com/bambam10989/status/775839876306436100 …

3:17 PM - 15 Sep 2016

If im not mistaken nothing has been mentioned about us being linked with Rockliff right?

Also !@#$ off Geelong.

 

[I_want_Moore]

So is wells coming? Anyone with inside info?

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

I think it is on the back of the injury uncertainty surrounding; Ramsay/Scharenberg & Sinclair. Henderson is a known quantity who would be gettable as a FA. I'm not keen just trying to rationalise the chatter.

DO. NOT. WANT.

Even if all three of them fail for various reasons we have a zillion midfielders to swing into half back. Greenwood Aish Varcoe to name a few. Smith. De Goey. Sidebottom. Fasolo. Williams. Langdon. Phillips. They all cant fit in the midfield anyway!

 

[mike123]

I dont understand the love for Henderson.. Medium Size Half back is someone we dont need.

We have allot of them, just not good ones.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

We have allot of them, just not good ones.

And how does Henderson solve that

 

[Mondi21]

DO. NOT. WANT.

Even if all three of them fail for various reasons we have a zillion midfielders to swing into half back. Greenwood Aish Varcoe to name a few. Smith. De Goey. Sidebottom. Fasolo. Williams. They all cant fit in the midfield anyway!

Greenwood butchers the ball more than butcher butchers meat, so there is no way i would wont to see him on my half back line, id prefer we didnt play him at all, unless there is a shut down role for him to play.

 

[Tassiepies83]

latest on the news we already knew.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/wan...s/news-story/46f1fec72730fa774b3e90a6c3c45ed7

 

[ChubbyGallon]

And how does Henderson solve that

As I have quoted before Seedsman couldnt get a game for the pies yet got a game before Henderson at Adelaide. Enough Said

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Greenwood butchers the ball more than butcher butchers meat, so there is no way i would wont to see him on my half back line, id prefer we didnt play him at all, unless there is a shut down role for him to play.

As Toovey managed successfully for many years? Worth a try. Besides he wasnt the only name I threw up.

 

[Matt_352]

I suppose if we got Rocky we could release Adams to defence.

 

[Crazy Tails]

latest on the news we already knew.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/wan...s/news-story/46f1fec72730fa774b3e90a6c3c45ed7

Yeah most of that already covered on here. Interesting that we might look at a Dogs player starved of opportunity instead of a later draft pick. Could open up for Bailey Dale or Nathan Hrovat. I like Dale but Hrovat is BKen Mark 2.

 

[I_want_Moore]

Hoskin-Elliott Please, would be a great get

 

[nahnah]

Club has known Clokes desire to go to the doggies for months, I'd be very surprised if there wasn't a player that we've been in their ear throughout the year as possible compensation, probably Jong but wouldn't be surprised if there was another one

 

[RupetFan]

Rockliff is known as the Supercoach/Fantasy player.

Gathers all the points in the world but is just a little cheap player like Cotchin. Adams off Half Back again ? He's our most important player and we need him in the middle.

 

[RupetFan]

As I have quoted before Seedsman couldnt get a game for the pies yet got a game before Henderson at Adelaide. Enough Said

Don't really want him but Hendersons form this year has been really solid. Seedsman was dropped for him at one stage.

 

[RupetFan]

I think if Marchbank nominates us, Carlton want Witts, then we should look at a 3 way trade. It's scary who Witts nominates, let's just keep our fingers crossed he chooses either GWS or GCS.

Why would Carlton want Witts when they have 3-4 rucks already...

 

[TradeDraft]

Fox Sports says Cloke has Agreed to a Contract with Dogs and we pretty much give Cloke away

 

[Aishole]

Lol at the rockliff bashing.... You really have no idea. Rockliff at his best is a beast, whose field kicking is safe yeah, but it isn't bad. And if you've ever watched brisbane, he actually delivers the ball extremely well into the forward 50, and is also decent when inside the forward 50 himself.

You are all judging him off the 'sideways accumulating crab' impression which seems to be the 'in' thing at the moment.

He is an excellent player, and would be a great addition to any side in the AFL.

Go and watch some games, instead of judging off the in-trend rockliff impression.