List Mgmt. Contract, Trade and Draft Discussions - 2024 Edition

What should we do with our 1st round draft pick?

  • Finn O’Sullivan

    Votes: 57 19.0%
  • Sid Draper

    Votes: 86 28.7%
  • Josh Smillie

    Votes: 22 7.3%
  • Jagga Smith

    Votes: 34 11.3%
  • Split for best mid and Tobie Travaglia

    Votes: 46 15.3%
  • Split for best mid and Liam Baker

    Votes: 20 6.7%
  • Split for best mid and best KPD

    Votes: 4 1.3%
  • Split for best two mids

    Votes: 9 3.0%
  • Other

    Votes: 13 4.3%
  • Sam Lalor

    Votes: 9 3.0%

  • Total voters
    300
  • This poll will close: .

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.


Quick links:
Player contract status
Draft prospect video highlights (thanks to noobermensch)
AFL retirements and delistings



Latest news and rumours:


 
Last edited by a moderator:

Log in to remove this ad.

Lub u long time hansum man
Throwing American GIF
 
Have read suggestions that the Tigers will target our pick to get FOS and Jagga together, doesn’t sound like North are keen on Jagga. Wonder if we’d slide down to GC’s pick at 6 (for Rioli)? Would probably get 1 of the picks they get for Bolton/Baker on top?
Interesting insight.

Presumably then:
1. FOS [rich]
2. Smillie [nm]
3. Jagga [rich]
4. draper [crows]
5. Lalor [melb] - maybe Armstrong??
6. Leaves Reid or Langford for WCE, meaning Langford as Reid is flight risk. Ideally Lalor makes it though
7. Reid [saints]
8. Armstrong [saints]
9. Trainor [ess]
10. Bo Allen [frem] - this is more hopeful than anything but probably makes some sense
11. Travaglia [wce after trade from frem to rich]
12. Shanahan [coll]
13. Hotton or Berry [carl]
14. Lindsay [wce from haw in Barrass trade]

Then we take a KPd with our next (23 prior to blowout)
And use Haw's 30 (from Coll) for Barrass on some local talent like a davis

Would need hawks to lose this wkend to keep that 14.
Sounds as if Battle leaving & getting band 1 compo isn't a sure thing either.

I like it & can super-charge our rebuild having 3 picks within 14.
 
Dunno why we're all talking about Baker anyway, isn't he a midfielder? We can't possibly fit anymore midfielders in to this team! So choc full of midfielders.

No fair. I said adding Baker, Graham, Hewitt and Peatling to our midfield rotation will make mid rotations hard to break into next year for an 18 year old. Why do people insist on making such ******ed reductions of plainly uninteresting and true comments. I block you now sir.
 
I don't think adding 1 more player for them unbalances their list. They probably already plan on getting 2 first rounders from Freo for Bolton and could easily miss that. But in any case they will take a bunch of kids and the higher those kids are drafted the better for them. I'd be more concerned about how they are going to meet the salary cap next year when they have no players, than I'd be in 3 years time if every one of their picks becomes a player that needs to be paid 1 million a season.
No way Tigers trade out their F1 for ANOTHER 1R this year when they're going to have a GAZILLION of them anyhow.

I'll eat my hat if they do
 
I'd only give up our second this year for Baker myself, considering it'll be low 20s anyway, which is a more than fair price.
Whilst you're right that prob is the right price. Personally much prefer we just keep the 2nd rounder. Offer f3 and if they say no then walk away.

Baker is much more a product of a system then an actual talent. Everyone knows it.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Whilst you're right that prob is the right price. Personally much prefer we just keep the 2nd rounder. Offer f3 and if they say no then walk away.

Baker is much more a product of a system then an actual talent. Everyone knows it.
Yep, don't want.
 
Delist/Retire (9)
Jones, Gaff, Witherden, Rotham, Trew, LEdwards, Baker, Rawlinson, Culley

Trade (4 OUT, 2 IN)
HAW: Barrass for 12 and 30
MELB: BWilliams, Petruccelle, 58 for 38 & 49
FREO: Ryan for 27 and Knobel
FA: Cumming

Draft (9)
3-FOS/Lalor
12-Travaglia/Lindsay
23-Hynes/Oliver
27-O’Farrell/Mraz*
30-O’Farrell/Mraz*/Gerreyn
38-Champion match
49-Dennis/Johnson/Barrat
Rookie-Artemis
Rookie-Boxshall

1 list spot for DFA/SSP/MSD
I would love a Zac Johnson and a Hamish Davis and Will Hayes
 
I don't know what defensive beast truly is but if its tackling and grunt work on the inside its only one side of the coin .

Priddis has/had ? The tackling record was he a defensive beast ?

But he was also a witches hat on the spread and in transition.

Harley is a terrible defensive runner and I suspect Lalor is also. They burn their petrol tickets in offensive and have no tank the other way .

Sid draiper is a good tackler but a fantastic 2 way runner . He is perfect for our team . His team mate Kade Herbert is a fantastic hard running winger who can also lay a mean tackle .

Get these 2 and I'm happy .
Think Dunkley.

On Pixel 6 Pro using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
No way Tigers trade out their F1 for ANOTHER 1R this year when they're going to have a GAZILLION of them anyhow.

I'll eat my hat if they do

They currently have 1 first round pick, and Fremantle would be idiots to give them 2 for Bolton.

I refuse to believe Gold Coast will pay pick 6 for Rioli, even for them that's ridiculous.

Someone needs to get involved to balance out the overs on either of those trades we'd be very well place to do something given our proximity to Fremantle and holding pick 3 and likely 12. Happy for us to sit it out if it'll give the Bigfooty servers a break from all the childish melting though.
 
Baker is much more a product of a system then an actual talent. Everyone knows it.
Absolutely spot on about Baker’s footy, except that a lot of people don’t know it.
1724679771538.png
How on earth can we be discussing using an early 2R (Hynes, Oliver, O’Farrell) on Baker with stats like this? That last thing we need are more shitty footskills at the club. Particularly when they are expensive 27yo foot skills.
 
They currently have 1 first round pick, and Fremantle would be idiots to give them 2 for Bolton.

I refuse to believe Gold Coast will pay pick 6 for Rioli, even for them that's ridiculous.

Someone needs to get involved to balance out the overs on either of those trades we'd be very well place to do something given our proximity to Fremantle and holding pick 3 and likely 12. Happy for us to sit it out if it'll give the Bigfooty servers a break from all the childish melting though.
They could get:
the 1st tied to the dogs for Rioli which is 13 right now
9, 17, 27, F2 or something for Bolton and Baker

They could then package up some picks and target the Brisbane 1st rounder and pick 20 from GC or something

Move whatever is left into 2025

Thats 6 first rounders this year without getting anything ridiculous.
They could try to join 17 and 20 for a pick closer to 10, say the Carlton pick 11.
Still 5 good first rounders at 1, 9, 11, 13, 14
 
They could get:
the 1st tied to the dogs for Rioli which is 13 right now
9, 17, 27, F2 or something for Bolton and Baker

They could then package up some picks and target the Brisbane 1st rounder and pick 20 from GC or something

Move whatever is left into 2025

Thats 6 first rounders this year without getting anything ridiculous.
They could try to join 17 and 20 for a pick closer to 10, say the Carlton pick 11.
Still 5 good first rounders at 1, 9, 11, 13, 14
Mate, you're one different opinion away from being added to the block list.
 
Think we need to all call in to all the sport shows and say we dont want Liam Baker

92.9 abc 6pr any others

If enough people do it can genuinely have a effect.

It will also start to shape the media's view of the trade
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top