List Mgmt. Contract, Trade & Draftee Discussion - 2022 Off Season Edition

[Keys]

Contract status of all players now fully updated

The Contracts Thread

2024 List Changes : Out: Retired- Gaff Delisted - Jones, Trew(R), Baker(R), Witherden, Burgiel, Culley(R), Rotham, L Edwards Traded - Darling (NM) Barrass (Hawthorn) In: Trade/FA acquisitions - Graham (Richmond) Baker (Richmond) Owies (Carlton) Draft - Allan (Pick 16) Shanahan (Pick 30) Gross...

www.bigfooty.com

 

[HoneyBadger35]

What would it take to get pick 8 off Port?

Assuming 8 and future first doesn’t get it done for JHF, Port will need to up their offer. I wonder if our pick 2 could get involved in some way, as it would be massive for North and could net us a fair few picks in return?

2 and Junior for 8, 27 and a future second? Seems unders for us I think.

2 and Junior for 8 and a future first, Port send 2, 27 and a future second to North?

 

[rko121]

I wonder if port will ask the question for our pick 2 to help get JHF.

Thoughts on the below trade?

North - Pick 2, pick 38 from us
Eagles - pick 8, Georgiades, future 1st from Port.
Port - Rioli, JHF and 4th rounder from north

 

[Opposite Kids]

What would it take to get pick 8 off Port?

Assuming 8 and future first doesn’t get it done for JHF, Port will need to up their offer.

2 and Willie for 8, 27 and a future second?

Seems unders for us I think. I wonder if our pick 2 could get involved in some way, as it would be massive for North and could net us a fair few picks in return?

2 and Willie for 8 and a future first, Port send 2, 27 and a future second to a north?

Interesting. If Georgiades comes into the frame now our selection becomes interesting depending on the pick we end up with

 

[TerryFilk]

I would expect Port ask the question about pick 2 from us

I could see North loving taking Wardlaw and Cadman at 1 & 2

 

[AsterixTheGaul]

I doubt we would give 26 & 27 for a 5 pick upgrade on 20.

Disagree - there is real quality at the 10 to 16 pick mark.

 

[HoneyBadger35]

Eagles receive: 8, 2023 1st (Port)
Port receive: JHF, Junior
North receive: 2, 27, 2023 2nd (Port)

Final draft hands if the above happens.

Eagles: 8, 20, 26, Port’s future first
Port: JHF, Junior
North: 1, 2, 27, Port’s future second

Is any of this egregious? Is the Eagles end of things up there better than just keeping 2 and getting 27 for Junior?

 

[Keys]

Pick 2 for 8 and Georgiades

 

[Mulldogg]

WCE: 8, 20, 26, Port’s future first
Port: JHF, Junior
North: 1, 2, 27, Port’s future second

Is any of this egregious? Is the Eagles end of things up there better than just keeping 2 and getting 27 for Junior?

What if Port jag a GF appearance, or heaven forbid a flag next year? 2 for 8 and 17/18 doesn’t really excite me.

 

[TOA.]

Eagles receive: 8, 2023 1st (Port)
Port receive: JHF, Junior
North receive: 2, 27, 2023 2nd (Port)

Final draft hands if the above happens.

Eagles: 8, 20, 26, Port’s future first
Port: JHF, Junior
North: 1, 2, 27, Port’s future second

Is any of this egregious? Is the Eagles end of things up there better than just keeping 2 and getting 27 for Junior?

I think we lose out there. Better off keeping 2 and getting 27 for Rioli

 

[HoneyBadger35]

What if Port jag a GF appearance, or heaven forbid a flag next year? 2 for 8 and 17/18 doesn’t really excite me.

Agreed, but there’s always a version of next year where Port implode early and finally, FINALLY, sack Ken, limp to a 12-14th finish.

It all hinges on what Port do. I think we’re the club worst off in that deal. Maybe if Georgiades got involved…

 

[CountryLad]

I wonder if port will ask the question for our pick 2 to help get JHF.

Thoughts on the below trade?

North - Pick 2, pick 38 from us
Eagles - pick 8, Georgiades, future 1st from Port.
Port - Rioli, JHF and 4th rounder from north

We are winning that trade hands down. Won’t happen

 

[HoneyBadger35]

Revising it because this is the only part of the offseason that is fun.

Eagles receive: 8, 2023 1st (Port), Georgiades
Port receive: JHF, Junior
North receive: 2, 27, 2023 2nd (Port)

Final draft hands if the above happens.

Eagles: 8, 20, 26, Port’s future first, Georgiades
Port: JHF, Junior
North: 1, 2, 27, Port’s future second

That’s more like it.

 

[wirra44]

Sponsorship by wirra44 = Poison Chalice

My other player I sponsored was gerrick weedon so fair to say after that I banned myself from sponsoring players again

 

[Shueygod]

I was curious to see if this was biased at all...

	2014​	2015​	2016​	2017​	2018​	2019​
2​	Christian Petracca	Josh Schache	Tim Taranto	Andrew Brayshaw	Jack Lukosius	Noah Anderson
3​	Angus Brayshaw	Callum Mills	Hugh McLuggage	Paddy Dow	Izak Rankine	Luke Jackson
12​	Corey Ellis	Charlie Curnow	Jy Simpkin	Darcy Fogarty	Zak Butters	Kysaiah Pickett
19​	Blaine Boekhurst	Ryan Burton	Tim English	Will Powell	Liam Stocker	Sam De Koning
20​	Jayden Laverde	Brayden Fiorini	Isaac Cummin	Callum Coleman-Jones	Riley Collier-Dawkins	Sam Philp
21​	Hugh Goddard	Ben McKay	Will Hayward	Oscar Allen	Ely Smith	Thomson Dow
26​	Toby McLean	Keiran Collins	Brandan Parfitt	Liam Ryan	Rhylee West	Will Gould
27​	Lukas Webb	Darcy Tucker	Zac Fisher	Brent Daniels	Tom Sparrow	Jeremy Sharp

A few handy players in the 12/19/20/21/26/27 group but I reckon you'd take 2/3 in all six years

What?

15/17 are easily better, 19 questionable and in 18 the group of 6 has the best player.

You’d seriously rather Brayshaw over Allen, Fogarty, Ryan and Powell?

 

[Shueygod]

I'd want a top 5 pick for any deal involving pick 2.

Why top 5? I feel the top 10 are very even.

 

[chaddy22]

Pick 2 for 8 and Georgiades

and rioli to port and georgiades to west coast.too easy.

 

[rko121]

Revising it because this is the only part of the offseason that is fun.

Eagles receive: 8, 2023 1st (Port), Georgiades
Port receive: JHF, Junior
North receive: 2, 27, 2023 2nd (Port)

Final draft hands if the above happens.

Eagles: 8, 20, 26, Port’s future first, Georgiades
Port: JHF, Junior
North: 1, 2, 27, Port’s future second

That’s more like it.

Not far off, as long as we are not too generous and start with Georgiades. At the end of the day if they come to us for pick 2 we have the upper hand.

 

[amazingjoshy]

Revising it because this is the only part of the offseason that is fun.

Eagles receive: 8, 2023 1st (Port), Georgiades
Port receive: JHF, Junior
North receive: 2, 27, 2023 2nd (Port)

Final draft hands if the above happens.

Eagles: 8, 20, 26, Port’s future first, Georgiades
Port: JHF, Junior
North: 1, 2, 27, Port’s future second

That’s more like it.

Port get reamed there imo

 

[Godfather32]

Revising it because this is the only part of the offseason that is fun.

Eagles receive: 8, 2023 1st (Port), Georgiades
Port receive: JHF, Junior
North receive: 2, 27, 2023 2nd (Port)

Final draft hands if the above happens.

Eagles: 8, 20, 26, Port’s future first, Georgiades
Port: JHF, Junior
North: 1, 2, 27, Port’s future second

That’s more like it.

Port can't trade a future 1st and a future 2nd can they?

 

[Dark Sharks]

Oh goodie.

Apparently we're getting Meek again gaiz.

 

[HoneyBadger35]

Port get reamed there imo

Port gain JHF and Junior, lose Mitch, 8, 27, 2023 1st, 2023 2nd.

This is all predicated on 8 and 2023 1st not being enough for JHF, so they’d have to up an offer from there anyway. Surely North aren’t copping that.

 

[TerryFilk]

Can not believe this fan base would slide down from 2 to 8 for ****ing Georgiades, he’s so average man whilst also having dodgy groins and undersized, putting another tweener next to Oscar is a laughable idea, they are not a good pairing

 

[HoneyBadger35]

Port can't trade a future 1st and a future 2nd can they?

Don’t know about draft rules, don’t know about the strength of various draft classes, all I know is massive trades in fantasy football and that’s what this is babyyyyyyy.

Why could they not? Can the AFL not tick off exceptions to all the future trading rules, and surely acquiring last year’s #1 pick would qualify.

 

[wooshwhisperer]

Agree with this, yesterday he got caught 4 times holding the ball by taking on, or trying to take one too many players or one more swerve around a plater too many.

Love his pace and run and carry but he needs a bit of polish on his game, before he would ever be AFL worthy.

That said he had a very good season.

Yes ...but I saw a bloke still running in the dying minutes of a torrid contest on a pretty soft surface desperately trying to get a win... you can't train that at any level of footy.

PS... It's a grand old flag.

 

[Shueygod]

Yeah Georgiades is definitely not the type to pay up for.

Is too short to be a dominant key forward.